Narrative Critique of a Qualitative Research Study Essay

Narrative Critique of a Qualitative Research Study Essay

Length: 555 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Good Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The study outlined in the article is well organized in its major parts, including introduction, literature review, methodology, results, and discussions. The introduction provides the research question and purpose, while the remaining parts provide sufficient data to help in justifying the hypothesis and rationale of the study.
The introduction of the article explains all the important aspects of the study; the study is about using the bona fide group aspect to examine leadership. The introduction also explicitly indicates the aim of the study, which is to investigate the leadership process and success from a bona fide group’s perspective (Galanes, 2003, p. 742).
The literature review of the article by Galanes (2003) is well organized with different subheadings such as “What Do Leaders Do” (743), “Self Monitoring” (746) and “What Do Leaders Think” (747). The subheadings enabled the researcher to explain the major aspects of leadership exhaustively. The review examines studies and literatures, such as LaFasto and Larson (2001) and Bowman (1997), which support the purpose of the curren...

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Qualitative Research Critique Essay

- Article Citation Gilmartin, J. (2003). Day surgery: Patients’ perceptions of a nurse-led preadmission clinic. Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 243-250. Initial Reaction This research article is from the UK and the writer questions if the findings from this study will have heuristic relevance and applicability to nursing and healthcare in the United States (U.S.). Primary healthcare in the UK is provided through the National Health Service (NHS); this writer has little knowledge as to how it works and its impact on patient care and nursing....   [tags: Advanced Nursing Research]

Good Essays
1821 words (5.2 pages)

Business / Management Journals Focused On The Principle Qualitative Research Methods

- Introduction - This paper provides a review of five articles from business/management journals focused on the principle qualitative research methods. For each article review a brief description, guided by Myers (2013), and a critique, guided Pratt (2009), is provided. Table 1 provides a summary of the five articles identifying the research method, data collection technique, data analysis approach and key. The narrative descriptive review of each article coupled with figure and tables to organize and visualize thoughts (Pratt, 2009) follows the summary table....   [tags: Scientific method, Qualitative research]

Good Essays
1148 words (3.3 pages)

Evidence Based Practice : Research Design Essay

- Introduction Evidence-based practice utilizes research design analysis from arrays of studies design, it is imperative for research scholars to understand how to read, and how to comment on the quality of research design utilized. There is three major research designs, namely quantitative, qualitative and mixed method; however; mostly utilized in evidence-based practice are quantitative and qualitative. The quantitative and qualitative research designs are exclusive in the description and generate distinct outcomes....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Good Essays
1134 words (3.2 pages)

American Girl And The Brand Gestalt : Closing The Loop On Sociocultural Branding Research

- focused on the key qualitative research methods. For each article review, a brief description, guided by Myers (2013), and a critique, guided Pratt (2009), is provided. A summary of the five articles identifying the research method, data collection technique, data analysis approach and critique is provided in Table 1. The narrative review of each article coupled with figures and tables to organize and visualize thoughts (Pratt, 2009) follows the summary table. 1. Journal Article - Reference - Diamond, N., Sherry Jr, J....   [tags: Scientific method, Qualitative research]

Good Essays
1570 words (4.5 pages)

Chronic Venous Leg Ulcers And Examined Factors That Influenced Directly Or Indirectly On The Quality Of Life Of Patients

- Introduction This critique reviewed a quantitative study based upon chronic venous leg ulcers and examined the factors that influenced directly or indirectly on the quality of life of patients with these chronic venous leg ulcers (CVLU). The goal of this paper is to analyze a research results that are related to chronic venous leg ulcer and, more importantly to caring for CVLU and the wounds. To do this research, some systematic methods were utilized with sourced studies synthesized using a narrative approach and, where homogeneity has allowed, meta-analysis (Lucas, P....   [tags: Qualitative research, Research, Scientific method]

Good Essays
895 words (2.6 pages)

A Qualitative Study of Charge Nurse Competencies Essay

- There have been relatively few informative studies examining what to look for in an effective Charge Nurse. The occupation of Charge Nurse is exhibited by effective leadership and is tantamount to the successful running of a Nursing Unit. It is well-known that successful nursing leaders have the ability to think on their feet, while effortlessly solving day-to-day problems. Their duties combine administrative, educational, along with clinical expertise. The qualitative research study that was examined in this article uses grounded theory to determine what makes a good charge by using the experiences and observations of staff nurses, charge nurses along with nurses in upper management along w...   [tags: Nursing Qualitative Study]

Good Essays
1365 words (3.9 pages)

Qualitative Study On Qualitative Research Essay

- Qualitative Study Design Chart From a distinctive case study to an all-encompassing interview, the talent to analyze the nature of a phenomenon utilizing qualitative research designs is established upon in-depth analysis by the researcher (Bryman, 2006). Case studies, observations, interviews, and survey designs are the most frequently exploited approaches (Ukiwe, 2011). The objective of this research is to create a chart listing the various designs one may consider for a qualitative study along with the type of data collection....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Good Essays
1627 words (4.6 pages)

Types Of Qualitative Research Essay

- Week Six Chapter four and five in Creswell (2013) helped me realize how important it is to focus on one type of qualitative research. This leads to writing a coherent paper in the approach chosen. It was also interesting to learn that because subjective and objective experiences, phenomenology lies somewhere in between both qualitative and quantitative research. The study I am conducting is a phenomenological study. Thus, when I interviewed my participant this weekend, I couldn’t help, but be a little worried I was not staying true to the phenomenological approach....   [tags: Qualitative research, Case study, Question]

Good Essays
713 words (2 pages)

Types Of Qualitative And Qualitative Research Essay

- Types of Qualitative Methods When a qualitative approach seems to make the most sense, the task becomes one of selecting the qualitative method or methods to be used. A number of different ways of framing qualitative methods exist. Lee, Mitchell, and Sablynski (1999) use purposes (e.g., theory generation, theory elaboration, theory testing, or critical theory), research design (e.g., case study, ethnography, and in-depth interviews), and analytic data techniques (e.g., grounded theory approaches, pattern matching in case study research, and hermeneutic techniques as a way of categorizing types of qualitative research....   [tags: Qualitative research, Scientific method]

Good Essays
2206 words (6.3 pages)

Critical Appraisal Of A Qualitative Study Essay

- Critical Appraisal of a Qualitative Study This paper will provide a critical appraisal of the design and methodology used within the research study Thinking Processes in Social Workers’ Use of a Clinical Decision Support System: A Qualitative Study, conducted by Menachem Monnickendam, Riki Savaya, and Mark Waysman. The format of the critical appraisal has been formed around the template Critical Analysis of Qualitative Research, found in Csiernik’s Practicing Social Work Research. Information regarding properly conducted qualitative studies has been used and found within Research Methods for Social Workers written by Grinnell et al., to evaluate the design and methodology of the study....   [tags: Research, Psychology, Quantitative research]

Good Essays
1370 words (3.9 pages)