Challenges In 'Cut, By Patricia Mccormick's Cut'

1353 Words3 Pages

Many people in today’s society face challenges within themselves. Some challenges deal with adults paying their bills, while others involve kids and their self-esteem. In the novel Cut, by Patricia McCormick, a young teenage girl experiences just this, self-esteem trouble. According to Angela Kennedy in the article “Self-Injury on Rise,” a shocking 25 percent of people who self-injure said they started by sixth grade or younger; 60 percent by seventh or eighth grade and 12 percent in ninth grade. Inside the book, the reader views Callie’s thoughts from a first person point of view. At first, everything seems normal as Callie runs in her cross-country meet. Things escalate quickly as she runs off the track to her house where she turns to self-mutilation. …show more content…

First, some people harm themselves simply because they can. A friend of Callie’s, Amanda, cuts herself and said to Callie, “Listen, I don’t see how what I do is so different from people who get their tongues pierced. Or their lips. Or their ears, for Chrissakes. It’s my body” (McCormick 37). She doesn’t see the harm in hurting herself which is why teaching this book could tell teenagers that this isn’t the path to go down and that there are other alternatives. She thinks that this is normal and a way to cope with her problems on a day-to-day basis. Amanda is one of the 1,400 out of 100,000, and growing, people who admitted to self-injury (Kennedy). Secondly, some people self-injure to cope with their feelings and tensions. Callie explains to her therapist about her father’s job situation and said, “’Now he just sells to companies nearby.’ I don’t tell you [her therapist] about how it seems like all the companies nearby already have computers, that for a while he took people out hoping they’d become customers and that now he mostly just goes out. ‘He has to work a lot’” (McCormick 111). Callie explained how her fathers situation seemed to cause her a lot of stress and how she seemed worried for him. To add, “some reasons why teens self-injure include: release of tension and feeling overwhelmed” (Styer). This is a lesson that could be taught in …show more content…

One may say that this novel shouldn’t be taught in schools, because this doesn’t happen to teenagers. However, it was found that of teenagers who have been sexual assaulted in their life, 70-90 percent of them experimented with self-injuring methods (Kennedy). Also, someone doesn’t have to be sexually assaulted to intentionally injure themselves. An untrue belief is that all self-injurers have been sexually abused, however this is not the case as many have a history of not being sexually abused in the first place (Styer). Another argument could be that this book shouldn’t be taught in schools because self-injury is a suicidal attempt. This is not true, because the person hurting themselves doesn’t intend on dying, but rather releasing the tension in their lives in order to cope with their thoughts. In the book, Callie is worried when a friend of hers is seriously injured and says, “’So she’s going to be OK?’,” while her therapist responds, “‘I can’t say. She will be, if she begins taking responsibility for her health, for her recovery here’” (McCormick 96). This concludes that not all people who self-injure are suicidal, because from this point on Callie became proactive and had a willingness to become better. In summary, many people may disagree and state that the novel shouldn’t be taught in schools; nevertheless, the book has life lessons that are

Open Document