Doubt And Skepticism In Psychodynamic Research

1058 Words3 Pages

Delving deeper into the axioms and theorems one realizes that theorems rely on logic, and can be proved or disproved using axioms. However, axioms often rely on empiricism as a way of knowing. Going back to Euclidean Geometry , the fifth axiom stated that if two lines are perpendicular to the same line they are parallel to each other. The proof of this observation could not be provided using any other axioms or theorems, and was included by Euclid on the basis of common observation. This was widely accepted till two European mathematicians working independently - Bolyai and Lobachevsky discovered a flaw in this axiomatic truth. On a sphere, such as the earth, two lines (longitudes) which are perpendicular to the same line (the equator) end …show more content…

In the primary years of psychology as an empirical science, many people believed that cognition and human behavior cannot be studied scientifically because it cannot be measured directly and observed accurately. This was called behaviorism and scientists who studied this were called behaviorists. However, doubt and skepticism began to emerge when language could not be explained through a behavioristic perspective (Chomsky, 1959). Based on these doubts, scientists started focusing on the human mind and cognition which led to the emergence of cognitive psychology. This field has greatly excelled our knowledge and confidence from explaining abstract concepts like emotions, to addressing the various attribution errors humans tend to make. Another example of how doubt led to increased knowledge and confidence in the domains of psychology is through the gender- neutral theory, proposed by Dr. Money. Dr. Money was one of the leading sex researchers who had put forth the claim that all humans are born gender neutral, and that biological sex did not have to correspond to psychological sex (gender), but the study suffered from logical fallacy. To validate his theory Dr. Money had raised a young boy belonging to Reimer family as a girl named Brenda. Scientists began doubting his theory when Brenda experienced many problems in school due to her masculine behavior. Based on these doubts Milton Diamond examined the role of hormones on the developing fetus and proved that gender specific behavior was preprogramed inside the womb. After conducting a multitude of studies which provided evidence for his theory on role of hormones for gender label and identification, he published his findings in a book titled ‘The Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine’. Now his theory which has been supported by the intersex

Open Document