The Clouds By Aristophanes, The Apology And The Republic Essays

The Clouds By Aristophanes, The Apology And The Republic Essays

Length: 1364 words (3.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Clouds by Aristophanes, the Apology, and the Republic by Plato collectively demonstrate the hazardous relationship between the philosopher and the city. Each work reveals how Socrates’ method of dialectic inquiry and search for wisdom hindered Athens’ city structure and order. The tension between the city and the philosopher ultimately leads to Socrates’ death. Yet, the jury’s decision does not denounce Socrates as a pious individual. The decision merely represents Socrates’ unwillingness to conform to the Greek traditions and beliefs.
There are several charges laid against Socrates in his trial. Plato’s Apology divides these charges into two sets- the original charges and the new charges. The original accusations are: “Socrates does injustice and is meddlesome, by investigating the things under the earth and the heavenly things, and by making the weaker speech the stronger, and by teaching others these same things” (Plato 19b4-c). These accusations are brought upon by Meletus, but are influenced by Aristophanes and a poem that he wrote, called the Clouds (Plato 19b2). In the comedy, Aristophanes describes in depth Socrates and his actions inside of the “Thinkery”. Socrates agrees to introduce a son, Pheidippides, to the Unjust Speech so that his father, Strepsiades, can avoid paying back a large debt to creditors in court (Aristophanes 886). This agreement provides a basis for Meletus’ claim that Socrates makes the weaker speech the stronger. When Strepsiades enters the Thinkery, he sees Socrates’ students looking down at the ground and turned upside down with their heads on the ground (Aristophanes 191). Strepsiades asks a student what they are doing and he answers that they are “investigating things beneath the earth” (Ari...

... middle of paper ...

... men ignorant, they naturally became upset (Plato 22e6-23a2). Socrates might have disgruntled the citizens as well because they looked highly upon these men and valued their positions in the traditional Greek society. If Socrates had forced the citizens to disclaim the value and wisdom of the men in these professions, then they would inherently have to disclaim the traditional virtues and norms that the men represented.
Socrates’ practice of philosophy was a constant threat to Athens and its citizens. Skepticism and newfound knowledge would have been disruptive to the city’s order, as tradition played a large role in Greek society. Socrates’ journey for knowledge was naturally offensive and destructive to Greek society’s standards of religion and wisdom. Thus, his methods of dialectic received vast criticism from society, which made his trial defenses less believable

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How Xenophon’s Oeconomicus is a Response to Aristophanes’ Clouds Essay

- A significant body of work regarding how Xenophon’s Oeconomicus is a response to Aristophanes’ Clouds has been written in the last few decades, beginning with Leo Strauss’s enigmatic book on the dialogue. And while great consideration has gone into the pronounced relationship between these two works, as well as its relation to Xenophon’s treatises on the arts and his Hiero, the fertile Oeconomicus has many more fruits to yield for us regarding a greater understanding of the coherence of the dialogue to Xenophon’s thought....   [tags: Philosophy]

Better Essays
1049 words (3 pages)

Essay on The Clouds

- CLOUDS Production The setting of the Clouds requires two doors in the skene, one representing Strepsiades's house and the other, the Thinkery, both in the city of Athens. The play begins with Strepsiades and Pheidippides sleeping in their beds. Since the ancient Greek theater had no curtain, these two men in their beds had to be carried out in full view of the audience by stagehands (probably slaves) and placed in front of one of the doors of the skene representing Strepsiades's house. The audience was no doubt expected to imagine that this was an indoor scene, because it was not usual for Greeks to sleep outside....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2187 words (6.2 pages)

Just and Unjust Speech in Aristophanes' "Clouds"

- Throughout Aristophanes’ “Clouds” there is a constant battle between old and new. It makes itself apparent in the Just and Unjust speech as well as between father and son. Ultimately, Pheidippides, whom would be considered ‘new’, triumphs over the old Strepsiades, his father. This is analogous to the Just and Unjust speech. In this debate, Just speech represents the old traditions and mores of Greece while the contrasting Unjust speech is considered to be newfangled and cynical towards the old. While the defeat of Just speech by Unjust speech does not render Pheidippides the ability to overcome Strepsiades, it is a parallel that may be compared with many other instances in Mythology and real...   [tags: Justice, Aristophanes, Clouds, ]

Better Essays
591 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Aristophanes's The Clouds

- Aside from all the prodigious number of Greek tragedies in history, stands a collection of Greek comedies which serve as humorous relief from the powerful overtone of the tragedy. These comedies were meant to ease the severity and seriousness sometimes associated with the Greek society. The ideas portrayed in the comedies, compared to the tragedies, were ridiculously far-fetched; however, although abnormal, these views are certainly worthy of attention. Throughout his comedy, The Clouds, Aristophanes, along with his frequent use of toilet humor, ridicules aspects of Greek culture when he destroys tradition by denouncing the importance of the gods' influence on the actions of mortals, and he...   [tags: Greek Plays Aristophanes Clouds Essays]

Better Essays
1639 words (4.7 pages)

Aristophanes And Plato 's Apology Essay

- Most of the time, we assume that two different authors have a similar idea of the same thing, but sometimes, the two interpretations can widely vary. The philosopher, as described in both Aristophanes’ Clouds and Plato’s Apology, has certain traits that both authors agree with: they consider philosophers to be thoughtful and curious but not well liked among the people. However, they disagree as to the effect the philosopher has on society. Aristophanes believes that the philosopher is creating unrest in a society that was in good shape beforehand, while Socrates, being a philosopher, sees himself as a key component in the development of Athens....   [tags: Socrates, Plato, Philosophy, Aristophanes]

Better Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Aristophanes’ Clouds a Satyr Play Written in 419 BCE

- Aristophanes’ Clouds, if read hastily, can be interpreted as a mindless satyr play written in 419 BCE. Yet the chorus warns the reader not to expect the play to have farcical ploys like “a hanging phallus stitched on” the actors to evoke a laugh, but to take note of underlying seriousness as “she [the play] comes in trusting only her words” (Clouds 538-44). Even if the play does use some low devices, the play’s message is sophisticated and can be read as a warning to Socrates. Aristophanes is a “friendly critic” of Socrates and warns Socrates to change his ways for Athens and for the good of himself (Whidden)....   [tags: apology, socrates, youth in athens]

Better Essays
1147 words (3.3 pages)

Plato's The Republic and Aristophanes The Birds Essay

- Plato's The Republic and Aristophanes The Birds      It is evident, by Plato's The Republic and Aristophanes The Bird's, that one's vision of an ideal state is not the same mystical utopia. Plato's Republic is an well-ordered society that emphasizes the development of the community, which leads to its people believing in this philosophy. Cloudcuckooland, the idea of two lazy Athenians, is an unorganized society that lacks the substance to make it a workable society. I would much rather live in the organized Republic to the unorganized Cloudcuckooland....   [tags: Plato Republic Aristophanes Birds Essays]

Better Essays
1197 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about The Apology Of Socrates And The Republic Of Plato

- Over the years of my highschool and college education, I have read the “Apology of Socrates” and “The Republic of Plato” four times. Every time I read these two texts, I come out of the experience with something new. There is just so much information in these two books that you are never able to catch all the little details and hidden meanings. I imagine that even if I read these books hundreds of times, I still wouldn’t have grasped all that I was intended to. I think the reason behind this is because Socrates’ personality is so complex, and you never fully understand exactly what he’s trying to say....   [tags: Plato, Socrates, Apology, Athens]

Better Essays
1279 words (3.7 pages)

The Clouds by Aristophanes Essay examples

- "The Clouds" by Aristophanes - Relevant in Today's World "The Clouds" by Aristophanes, is a play centrally concerned with education. Aristophanes employs satire to illustrate his conservative beliefs. It is intended to show readers that in the tendency to philosophical subtleties lies the neglection of the real needs of the Athenians. According to Aristophanes, philosophical speculation only acts to shake the established foundations of accepted religion, gods, and ideals of morality. Specifically, as it was even discused in "The Apology," Aristophanes believed that philosophical attitudes held by the Sophists enabled those who held them to convince others of wrong or weaker beliefs simply...   [tags: Classical Greek Literature]

Better Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Comparing The Simpsons and Aristophanes' Clouds Essay

- Tomorrow on the Simpsons, Homer will discover that Bart has stolen his credit card and charged $10,000 worth of "Itchy and Scratchy" merchandise. Having no hope for paying off this debt, Homer decides to go to law school because he cannot afford to hire a bankruptcy lawyer. The famous lawyer, who teaches classes, sends a crestfallen Homer home to retrieve his son, for Homer is much too thick-headed to possibly learn the ways of the courts. As Bart graduates from law school, he uses his newfound skills of argument to convince the courts that his parents are insane, his sister Lisa deserves to be in a boarding school, and he should be able to put his youngest sister up for adoption....   [tags: comparison, compare contrast]

Better Essays
1943 words (5.6 pages)