Violence Is Necessary For The Function Of The Successful State Essay

Violence Is Necessary For The Function Of The Successful State Essay

Length: 1593 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

While both Carl Schmitt and Michael Foucault establish the ubiquity of violence to the Modern State in The Concept of the Political and Society Must be Defended (respectively), Schmitt focuses on violence as a mechanism of interstate relations, while Foucault concentrates on violence as a mechanism of State control and regulation over the populace. Both Schmitt and Foucault agree that violence is necessary for the function of the successful State, but differ on what forms of violence it is acceptable to implement and where violence is required.
In his The Concept of the Political, Schmitt establishes that violence is political and central to the Modern State as a basic form of interaction that prevails between States. Violence can only be functional as an interstate interaction between established enemies, and such violence is termed ‘war’. War exists as a staple of interstate interaction, which Schmitt regards as being fundamentally based on military conflict: “War is armed combat between organized political entities; civil war is armed combat within an organized unit” (Schmitt, 32). For Schmitt, violence depends on the friend/enemy distinction to function. The State, as a Sovereign, establishes other political entities as its friends and enemies to dictate the subsequent interactions that can take place between them. “The friend, enemy, and combat concepts receive their real meaning precisely because they refer to the real possibility of physical killing. War follows from enmity. War is the existential negation of the enemy” (Schmitt, 33). Political action, such as war, always presupposes the humanity of those governed by the Sovereign, and those it deems friend or enemy. “The justification of war does not resid...

... middle of paper ...

...uses on the State and relationships with its contemporaries, Foucault looks at the intricacies of the State itself. Schmitt does not take into account racism in his concept of violence within the State: power relations are undefined and there is no normative distinction within the populace. For Foucault, racism becomes the mechanism to distinguish between the internal/domestic friend and enemy within the State. Both Schmitt’s and Foucault’s concepts of violence in the Modern State have the potential for poetic imagery. Foucault’s concept of biopower and racism evokes the image of the State as a rosebush, and any act of violence under the mechanism of racism is like the pruning of dead leaves and stunted stems. Schmitt’s concept of violence as interstate relations suggests a chess board, with each piece enacting violence on its opposition until reaching victory.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Violence and Freedom- Exploring the Use of Violence to Liberate the Oppressed

- The role of violence in the liberation of peoples from systems of domination is necessarily entwined to the concept of freedom. Herbert Marcuse and Frantz Fanon argue that violence, in various forms, is the only reasonable rebuttal to the abhorrent system of subjugation, whether it is in shape of something as transparent as apartheid to thinly veiled laws that take away the rights of humans under the capitalist system. To even understand the relationship between freedom and violence it has to be established what it is even meant by the phrase “violence” while simultaneously attempting to understand what means are necessary to achieve this end....   [tags: violence]

Better Essays
2156 words (6.2 pages)

The State Of Nature : A Questionable Conceit Of The Enlightenment Essay

- The State of Nature: A Questionable Conceit of the Enlightenment Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau are all Enlightenment-era philosophers from the disciplines of early social and political science that each propose and outline their own forms of civil society (all of which rely on the idea of a social contract in some way) and corresponding models of sovereignty. The three authors fall along a spectrum of ideologies. Hobbes argues for an absolute monarchy enforced by a social contract that requires citizens to divest all their power into a single leader, known as the “Leviathan” (Hobbes 120-121)....   [tags: Political philosophy, State of nature]

Better Essays
1083 words (3.1 pages)

Essay about Domestic Violence And Domestic Abuse

- Domestic violence has become a significant issue in our society. Many incorrectly assume that domestic violence only impacts the victim, their friends and family at home. In reality, it is a much broader issue that affects ones colleagues, the workplace environment, and their ability to perform required tasks at work. However, little is being done to combat this issue within the workplace. There are many supports available for victims of domestic abuse. They range from counseling services, anonymous hotlines, and help groups, to a safe work environment and work protocols that may be put in place....   [tags: Abuse, Child abuse, Psychological abuse]

Better Essays
1456 words (4.2 pages)

Respect for Children: Stop Bullying in Schools Essay

- The human race is connected to this earth. Humans, being part of nature, need to nurture the life of, and on, this planet. With this in mind, a prerequisite for society should incorporate the comprehension of, respect for human life. Parents and family are the key sources to supply lessons in respect for humanity, and schools are equally important, as the key secondary source. Although many people think the core curriculum is rigorous enough for students, the basic four classes in math, language, history, and science are not enough for children to function fully, or adequately, as conscientious and considerate member of society....   [tags: Violence ]

Better Essays
1558 words (4.5 pages)

Peace Over Violence Organization Essay

- Introduction Approach, Mission Statement, & Philosophy The Peace over Violence organization approach is to run crisis intervention, violence, prevention and education programs tailored toward women, youth, and children, and by natural extension, men. They listen, counsel, support, guide, and work to heal survivors of violence and they stand at the center of a social movement that is advancing individuals, groups and society to stand over violence. The mission statement reads as follows: “Building healthy relationships, families and communities free from sexual, domestic and interpersonal violence” (Peace Over Violence)....   [tags: approach, mission statement, philosophy]

Better Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Globalization And Its Impact On Nation State Essay

- Despite the fact that globalization has existed for centuries, it appears for many as a threat to the concept of nation-state. However, according to others, globalization has greatly benefit nation-states, and should therefore be conceived as a helpful phenomenon rather than a drawback. But if globalization is not more recent than nation-states, it has however been on the rise for the last decades. Thus it has taken more and more importance at domestic and global scale. This explains the concerns raised by many scholars who see in this expansion the end of nation-states....   [tags: Globalization, Culture, Nation, Nationalism]

Better Essays
972 words (2.8 pages)

Modern Politics in Giorgio Agamben´s State of Exception Essay

- ... He thinks about the law in a way that separates it from what is held by authority normally and stations it in a new place, a new stage where it becomes the law while remaining a distinctive. The state of exception needs to reach a point where it can hold together the two aspects, law and life, and create a limit between them. Agamben suggests that an alternative is to show the artificiality and violence within the current system where law and life are bound ambiguously, and to a point where the exception extends and overarching negative influence....   [tags: life, privacy, living]

Better Essays
1489 words (4.3 pages)

The Philosophy Of Absolute Sovereignty Essay

- As a nation we are obligated to obey the rules and regulation of society in which was given to us by a higher power, the government. The government doesn’t have absolute power of society but it holds a balance of limited power to maintain society from failing into chaos or revolutions. However many believe there should be absolute power in order for society to fully function properly and away from war. This idea is based on Hobbes philosophy of absolute sovereignty. In which power should neither be limited nor divided but given absolute authority to a single person or an assembly to have an effective society....   [tags: Political philosophy, State of nature]

Better Essays
1289 words (3.7 pages)

Essay on Is Outsourcing A Refugee Crisis?

- ​It was instructed to compare and contrast two of the authors from BF190 discussed throughout this course to a media object provided by the professor. The authors I chose to focus on are Thomas Hobbes and Jean Jacques Rousseau. From the readings “Leviathan” by Thomas Hobbes (CITE) and “Discourse on the Origin of Inequality” by Jean Jacques Rousseau (CITE), both authors have similar but yet very different viewpoints on ideas they have made. The ideas I will be comparing and contrasting between these two philosophers are their different beliefs and understandings on the State of nature and the Social contract....   [tags: State of nature, Political philosophy]

Better Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)

Unconventional Warfare Essay

- To influence and move foreign policy in the direction they desire international leaders have several tools available to them ranging from diplomatic interaction with other countries to the use of overt or covert military force. The United States is not the only country to use its military as a political instrument and all can use the military at various levels of force. This paper will review the levels of force options American political leaders have for the use of the military in accomplishing U....   [tags: Definition, Function, Politics]

Better Essays
1597 words (4.6 pages)