The Tragedies of Hamlet and King Lear Essay

The Tragedies of Hamlet and King Lear Essay

Length: 1596 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Both 'King Lear' and 'Hamlet' can be described as a tragedy because Shakespeare used Aristotle’s definition of tragedy to construct these plays. In a tragedy the main character suffers as a result of their fatal flaw.
King Lear fits Aristotle's definition of a tragic hero. Aristotle stated a tragedy must be a play where the hero suffers as a result of their fatal flaw, has overbearing pride or presumption, has a dramatic episode of emotions, realises there mistakes but it is too late.
King Lear proposes to retire from the cares of his kingdom which is of significant importance. His fatal flaw and King Lear’s harmatia is his vanity which makes the audiences feel pity and fear when he falls victim to flattery and is ruthlessly betrayed by those he should have been able to trust the most
Hamlet’s fatal flaw is it’s his ability to over think. When the ghost of his father appears to him and charges him with the demanding task of avenging his most foul murder, Hamlet accepts the challenge. As the play progresses, however, Hamlet finds it difficult to execute such a murderous task. In order to delay killing Claudius, Hamlet plans to act crazy, which forces Claudius to send him to England. He also devises the “mouse-trap” scene, (Act 3 Scene 2), where he asked a troupe of actors to play a scene similar to how Claudius murdered his brother (King Hamlet). Hamlet’s inability to act and to avenge his father’s death leads him, as well as many others to their graves.
Shakespeare's plays were written during the Elizabethan England because he had to impress the Queen. It took place on the edge of the Renaissance where ordinary people became liberated which was a huge step in the intelligence of mankind. The Renaissance was when people be...

... middle of paper ...

...n how others would want the plot. This means that King Lear and Hamlet are not plays entirely from Shakespeare's imagination; instead they are plays written in the way Shakespeare interpreted as being most likely to be popular. Consequently, Shakespeare can not be seen as the architect of their tragedies, Elizabethan England is responsible for the creation of the tragedies.

Traditionally, as Lear and Hamlet are characters from plays they cannot be architects of their tragedies. However, the way that they have been created with such dominant and apparent flaws believe that they are architects of their tragedies. This is because they both allow themselves to be manipulated by their emotions and react in contrasting ways. The emotions cause Hamlet to think too much, whereas they cause Lear to ignore the potential consequences of his action and not to think at all.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

William Shakespeare 's Hamlet And King Lear Essay

- ... Shakespeare perfectly captures the struggles and triumphs of seeking revenge. Revenge is the main theme that is apparent throughout all of Hamlet. Like many other Renaissance revenge tragedies, Hamlet is one of the most widely recognized and famous example of the best revenge tragedies (Black, Shakespeare and the Comedy of Revenge). Hamlet is one of the most famous revenge tragedies, inspiring many works of art following the play’s premiere. As well as inspiring works of art, Hamlet has also instigated a great deal of critical analysis and writing (ed....   [tags: Hamlet, William Shakespeare, King Lear]

Powerful Essays
1350 words (3.9 pages)

Emotion And Sympathy For Shakespeare 's King Lear Essay

- ... It was actually to Goneril who is one of the evil master mind of the whole play. However, Goneril 's sympathy the audience might hold for her dissipates immediately after Lear 's departure. King Lear 's cathartic moment was also explored when he was in the storm in Act 3 scene 2 where his use of language shows a gradual degradation in his mental state. In this scene the combination of storm and thunder can be used to explain the turmoil going on in King Lear 's mind due to his fury at his daughter and his impending madness....   [tags: William Shakespeare, King Lear, Hamlet]

Powerful Essays
1847 words (5.3 pages)

Essay King Lear's Folly in Shakespeare's King Lear

- King Lear's Folly    In Shakespeare's King Lear, the actions of King Lear and of his daughters bring ruin and chaos to England. Social structures crumble, foreign invaders threaten the land, and, in a distinctly non-Hollywood ending, almost everyone dies tragically. The outlook is very bleak, as many of the problems are left unresolved at the end of the play: There is no one in line to assume sovereignty, and justice and virtue have not been restored to their proper places in the country's structure....   [tags: King Lear essays]

Powerful Essays
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Fate in Shakespeare's King Lear

- Fate in King Lear "There's a divinity that shapes our ends, rough hew them how we will." These words from Hamlet are echoed, even more pessimistically, in Shakespeare's play, The Tragedy of King Lear where Gloucester says: "Like flies to wanton boys, are we to the gods, they kill us for their sport". In Lear, the characters are subjected to the various tragedies of life over and over again. An abundance of cyclic imagery in Lear shows that good people are abused and wronged regardless of their own noble deeds or intentions....   [tags: King Lear essays]

Free Essays
2056 words (5.9 pages)

Shakespeare's Tragedies Essays

- “To be, or not to be: that is the question:/ Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer/ The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune/ Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,/ And by opposing end them?” (Hamlet, III, i, 58-62). William Shakespeare penned these powerful words relating suicide and suffering. These themes are dark and somber, but the speech remains one of the most recognizable soliloquies in theatrical work. To be able to compose such compelling monologue, the great playwright experienced crises....   [tags: Character Analysis, Suicide, Jealousy]

Powerful Essays
928 words (2.7 pages)

Mental Illness in Shakespeare's Works Essay

- Throughout Shakespeare’s many works, mental illnesses have played an undeniable part in many of them, especially his tragedies. From Lady Macbeth hallucination of a bloody spot leading to her suicide, to Hamlet’s faked illness and Ophelia’s very real illness, afflictions of the mind are featured prominently in the Bard of Avalon’s many works. Still, in the Elizabethan era, understanding of mental illness was rudimentary at best, as were the methods of treating it. During the Middle Ages and Elizabethan Era, numerous theories about mental disorders and how to treat them abounded....   [tags: Hamlet, King Lear, McBeth]

Powerful Essays
1358 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about Scenes in Shakespeare's Hamlet

- When one reflects on the questions they are asked in life, one of the most thought provoking questions is “what is your favorite movie?” Though a trivial question, one constantly finds oneself baffled trying to think of a movie in which they can truly say is their favorite. Once one comes up with an answer to this question, the preceding question is “why?” What is it that truly makes a movie great. One can argue the characters, or the story line that makes the movie great. But ultimately it is the memorable scenes in which make the movie ones favorite....   [tags: Hamlet, Shakespeare]

Powerful Essays
654 words (1.9 pages)

King Lear And Hamlet: The Makings Of A Tragic Hero Essay

- In William Shakespeare's tragedy, King Lear, the plot is driven by the misguided and sometimes baseless decisions made by King Lear and the brutality of family members towards one another. Like many other Shakespeare tragedies, this play is a commentary on action versus inaction, which is also seen in Shakespeare's Hamlet. Hamlet is the prince of Denmark who is thrown into a tragic situation when his father is killed at the hand of his own brother, Hamlet's uncle Claudius. Both characters are riddled by family strife, the difficulty of running a nation, and dealing with the complex workings of their own mind....   [tags: William Shakespeare]

Free Essays
1862 words (5.3 pages)

The Tragedies Of Shakespeare Essay

- The Tragedies Of Shakespeare "Your noble son is mad — ‘Mad' call I it, for to define true madness, What is't but to be nothing else but mad?" (Wells and Taylor, 665) In Act two, scene two of William Shakespeare's play Hamlet, Polonius uses these words to inform Hamlet's parents of their son's insanity. He then continues on, telling Gertrude and Claudius that the cause of this madness is lovesickness over his own daughter Ophelia (665). From the privileged perspective of the audience, we know that Polonius is mistaken and that Hamlet is far from insane, but rather, "playing mad" for a purpose of his own....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1794 words (5.1 pages)

The Structure in Hamlet Essay

- The Structure in Hamlet       William Shakespeare’s tragic drama Hamlet invites various interpretations of the structure because of the play’s complexity. Let us in this essay analyze various interpretations of structure.   Mark Rose, in “Reforming the Role,” highlights the “double plot” structure within Hamlet and another tragedy:   Hamlet and Lear are the only two of Shakespeare’s tragedies with double plots. [. . .] The story of Polonius’s family works analogously in Hamlet. Each member of the family is a fairly ordinary person who serves as a foil to some aspect of Hamlet’s extraordinary cunning and discipline....   [tags: GCSE English Literature Coursework]

Free Essays
2949 words (8.4 pages)