Essay PreviewMore ↓
Over twenty-eight months after President Bush roared those words to the world, the United States still has approximately 138,000 U.S. troops deployed in Iraq , catastrophic havoc caused by Hurricane Katrina plagues the Gulf Coast , an undeniably inadequate government emergency response ensued and President George Bush's approval ratings are at their lowest point in his presidency . Despite the announced end to "combat operations" in Iraq and the declaration that the suicide terrorists have "failed", since the election of the new Iraqi government, there have been daily suicide bombing in Iraq against U.S. Forces . Two single days in September 2005 have been the bloodiest, with nearly 200 Iraqis killed by the hands of suicide terrorists . As a result, many Americans are questioning the administration's current policy toward Iraq, including doubting the need for the large presence of American troops in Iraq .
Dying to Win is a timely book that concludes the cause of suicide terrorism is the presence of foreign troops as an occupying force in a weaker state . It specifically concludes that the cause of suicide terrorism against the United States is the presence of combat troops in Iraq and on the Arabian Peninsula . Dying to Win is one of the first attempts to address the critical questions surrounding suicide terrorism and examines the conditions that permit the social acceptance of such carnage. Professor Robert Pape has created the "world's largest database on suicide terrorism" and examined the 315 suicide terrorist attacks worldwide between 1980 and 2003 , analyzing a myriad of variables in determining that occupation by foreign troops is the "taproot" of suicide terrorism . Dying to Win is a groundbreaking undertaking that is a necessary read for every decision maker in government, and especially all military officers.
How to Cite this Page
"The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism." 123HelpMe.com. 07 Apr 2020
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- “Terrorism involves the use of violence by an organization other than a national government to cause intimidation or fear among a target audience;” at least, this is how Pape (2003) defines terrorism in his article “The Strategic Logic of Suicide Terrorism” (343). The goal of this article by Pape is to discuss suicide terrorism and how it “follows a strategic logic, one specifically designed to coerce modern liberal democracies to make significant territorial concessions” (343). Similar to Pape, Bloom (2004) and Horowitz (2010) also delve into the exponential increase of suicide terrorism and why it occurs.... [tags: violence, intimidation, al-qaeda]
1414 words (4 pages)
- In Dying To Win, Robert A. Pape challenges the views about why suicide terrorists do what they do and to whom. Pape is trying to convey that "suicide terrorism is rising around the world" (Pape pg. 6). Since many terrorist attacks have been perpetrated by Muslim terrorist motivated by religious beliefs, it makes people think that Islamic fundamentalism is the central cause. The connection between suicide terrorism and Islamic fundamentalism is incorrect, and encourage foreign countries to harm many Muslims people that are harmless.... [tags: Terrorism, September 11 attacks, Al-Qaeda]
1426 words (4.1 pages)
- My first secondary source is the book, “Blood and Rage: A Cultural History of Terrorism” written by Michael Burleigh. In his book, he investigates the nature of terrorism, with its origins in the West to the current global acts of terrorism. Burleigh examines the roots of terrorism in the last 150 years such as the Irish Republican Brotherhood, the Russian Nihilists, Red Brigades, Black International, Tamil Tigers and Al Qaeda. He also explores the political impact of those who cause violence and those who are affected by it.... [tags: terrorism, history, research]
1371 words (3.9 pages)
- Although seemingly a discrete category, religious terrorism cannot be disentangled from other motivations for terrorist violence. To what extent do you agree. Terrorism is a vast and complex topic and has been occurring throughout history, there are many definitions and types of terrorism that are often described by society; one that has gained the most momentum within society and the media today is religious terrorism. Although religious terrorism has its own specific definition along with other forms of terrorism, it seems that this type of terrorism has been assigned as a definite explanation behind most cases of terrorist violence; despite they’re being other factors contributing.... [tags: Terrorism, Religion, Irregular military, Jihad]
1360 words (3.9 pages)
- This article, titled The Strategic Logic of Trade, talks about the importance of Trade within a specific country, and what benefits it has on the United States. Simultaneously, another point raised by the article is how American-based trade benefits to other countries of the world. According to the text and more specifically Thomas Schelling whom is quoted, “trade is what most of international relations are about. For that reason, trade policy is national security policy”. By saying this, Schelling means that an economy cannot be safe if no trades occur between countries, good relations between these formers cannot develop and maintain and sustainable relations cannot continue on the long te... [tags: United States, International trade, Globalization]
1861 words (5.3 pages)
- In Module one, I learned that terrorism is a result of physical harm or deadly acts of force with the intent of a political outcome by the use of terror for coercion. There are various types of terrorism such as international terrorism and domestic terrorism. International terrorism occurs outside of the United States with a purpose to influence the policy of a government by intimidation. International and Domestic terrorism both involve violent acts dangerous to human life that violate federal and state laws.... [tags: Terrorism, Federal Bureau of Investigation]
1108 words (3.2 pages)
- Given the growing global threats of terrorism, it is significant that an understanding of the history, nature and mechanism-premises under which terror operates is obtained. This is significant as it would shape the perspective of policy makers when addressing issues of this nature. Terrorism, as it is understood is the action of none-state weak actors, individual or groups, who for some reasons feels suppressed, marginalized and, or denied what they may view as the basic human right. All terrorism has political objectives, even though the perpetrators may use religious relics to appeal to a wider existing audience, and invoke a response through violent act to prove or propagate their point.... [tags: Terrorism]
1793 words (5.1 pages)
- Terrorism is a term commonly known by many all throughout the globe. It is a threat to national security, civilians, military personnel, government agents, and so on. As mentioned by Spindlove and Simonsen (2013), “Terrorism is clearly a very special type of violence. It is a tactic used in many situations: peace, conflict, and even war” (p. 5). Even though, terrorism is widely known, not many may be aware that there are several definitions for terrorism. The problem with having so many definitions for one term, specifically terrorism, is that it cannot be handled appropriately and in one single method.... [tags: Terrorism, September 11 attacks, Osama bin Laden]
1407 words (4 pages)
- Suicide Bombers What makes a suicide bomber. Is it religions upbringing with promises of paradise in reward for acts of martyrdom. Is it the parental support he or she receives for his convictions. Is it society with no means of fighting back against oppression and humiliation. (http://www.israelinsider.com/channels/security/articles/sec0049.htm). In this paper I will discuss the characteristics of a suicide bomber, their mission, as well as discuss suicide attacks. Suicide Bombers Suicide bombers are said to believe that God sends them on their missions, and by the time they are ready to be stopped with explosives, they had reached a hypnotic state.... [tags: Suicide Attacks Islam Koran Terrorism Essays]
836 words (2.4 pages)
- Terrorism Imagine a clear blue, sunlit morning; the most beautiful day you can recall. Imagine waking up from an amazing dream of a clear horizon. Imagine putting on your new fresh suit, to start your new job. Imagine having that extra hop in your step as you leave your front door, your mind anxiously awaiting the adventure of a new beginning to an amazing day. Then, imagine not getting to where you needed to be. Not because you fell victim to a traffic jam or missed the bus, but because you were a victim of a terrorist act - an innocent victim, whose life was cut short by terrorism.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
1946 words (5.6 pages)
Professor Pape, an associate professor at the University of Chicago specializing in international security affairs , is uniquely qualified to write Dying to Win. A former instructor at the United States Air Force School of Advanced Airpower Studies, he also taught international relations at Dartmouth College, and his opinion is widely sought in the area of international security policy . Pape is also widely published in international relations, devoting the past several years to the study of suicide terrorism .
In addition to its examination of every suicide attack between 1980 and 2003, Dying to Win is a thoroughly researched and well-written text, documented with 391 footnotes, three appendices and twenty-six tables supporting its analysis and conclusions . Pape's writing style is very academic and Dying to Win is structured like a textbook, with clearly outlined chapters and sub-chapters. Although he overuses the "rule of three " for organization of the text and supporting analysis, it does not detract from the material or readability of the book. Written in three parts , Dying to Win examines the "strategic logic," the "social logic," and the "individual logic" of suicide terrorism before concluding that the current strategy for dealing with al-Qaeda is doomed to fail .
The "strategic logic " of the suicide terrorists and their campaigns should come as no surprise to those in the military or students of military history. Since all proponents of suicide terrorism are significantly weaker than their occupying force, especially the United States, they cannot use traditional military means to repel the occupiers . It is precisely this weakness and lack of a military force that makes suicide terrorism an attractive and plausible course of action to those occupied . The fact that an occupying force is a democracy makes them even more vulnerable to suicide terrorism, since their public is perceived to have a low threshold for civilian deaths, they are less likely to retaliate against civilians, and suicide attacks are harder to organize against authoritarian states . Pape concludes the "strategic logic" section by pointing out several past successes that have taught the suicide terrorists that such a strategy "pays" and gets concessions from the foreign occupying force .
The "social logic" of suicide terrorism will be more difficult for almost all people to understand and accept. This is true especially since all religions, including Islam, condemn suicide . The exception to this condemnation is martyrdom . While Islamic fundamentalism is not the root cause of suicide terrorism, the fact that an occupying power has a religious difference from the land occupied allows them to be "demonized ." This demonizing allows suicide terrorism planners to appeal to martyrdom and permits the general population of the occupied nation to embrace suicide terrorism . The occupying power then is cast as a threat to the existence of the religion of the occupied, and suicide terrorism then becomes socially accepted . Pape points to several empirical examples of this logic, including the Tamils in Sri Lanka, a non-Islamic group, who have been the most active in suicide terrorism, and debunks the myth that Islamic fundamentalism is the cause of suicide terror . In fact, fifty-seven percent of the suicide terrorists' motivation was secular ideology .
The "individual logic" of suicide terrorism will surprise many in the military, especially since it runs counter to the traditional notions of who suicide terrorists are. Rather than being loners and criminals who have nothing to live for, most suicide terrorists are normal, well-adjusted people . Their motives for suicide terrorism are altruistic, and for the betterment of their people . Pape concludes this "individual logic" section by profiling three of the "deadliest" suicide terrorists -- Mohammed Atta, Dhanu, and Saeed Hotari -- by examining the attack, their background, state of mind, and training, to demonstrate the altruistic appeal of suicide terrorists .
Noting that occupation by a democracy is the cause of suicide terrorism, as opposed to Islamic fundamentalism, Dying to Win argues that there must be a two-pronged assault to combat this growing trend; America must root out all the existing suicide terrorists, but do it in such a way that it does not grow a new generation of those dying to win . To do this, Pape argues that America should abandon the use of heavy military power in Iraq , and return to "offshore balancing" to protect our oil interests in the Middle East . Offshore balancing includes the withdraw of U.S. ground troops from the region, and the use of naval power stationed in the region in the event military forces are needed to protect U.S. interests . Part of this offshore balancing is developing strategic relationships in the region, for instance with Iran, Turkey or Saudi Arabia so that they can use their influence to protect interests of the United States . This approach seems to dovetail with the transformation of the United States Army from a heavy, difficult to deploy, division-based force to the brigade based combat teams that are lighter and highly mobile ready-to-deploy units of action . Additionally, Pape notes that homeland security must be part of the solution. This includes improving the background checks of immigrants, and stopping illegal immigration . Pape specifically argues that the United States should build a security fence between the United States and Mexico , similar to the security fence under construction by Israel to protect it from suicide terrorists from the West Bank and Gaza .
Despite his thought provoking analysis, Pape leaves many questions unanswered, some because of the timing of the book. For instance, how do the London bombings fit into this theory? The bombers were British born Pakistani and Jamaican men whose homeland was Great Britain, not a foreign occupied nation . Why would Iraqi insurgents target other Iraqi day laborers or civil servants , especially after the election of a new Iraqi government ? How does the suicide bombing in Sharm el-Sheikh in Egypt fit into Pape's suicide terrorist campaigns? Egypt neither is an foreign occupied nation, nor is it a coalition partner with troops on the ground in Iraq. In fact, Egypt has steadfastly refused to send any troops to Iraq in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom .
It appears as if analyzing the most recent bombings in London, Iraq and Egypt from the constructs espoused in Dying to Win is like hammering the proverbial square peg through the round hole. While Dying to Win provides many answers to question surrounding the identity of the suicide terrorists, and theorizes why they attack the United States, it is merely another lens through which to examine our policy towards Iraq. Pape provides compelling reasoning to shift American troops out of Iraq, reduce our dependence on Middle Eastern oil, and develop stronger alliances in the region that would allow us to protect our national interests without provoking additional suicide attacks. While he does not provide all the answers, all military officers should read this thought provoking study to gain a much better understanding of the dynamics of suicide terrorism, and provide a framework on how to combat it.