The Social And Biomedical Models Of Health Essay

The Social And Biomedical Models Of Health Essay

Length: 1032 words (2.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Health and ill health can mean different things to different people. According to (Seedhouse, 1986) “A person’s optimum state of health is equivalent to the state of the set of conditions which fulfil or enable a person to work to fulfil his or her realistic chosen and biological potentials.” Seedhouse gives a social definition to health and does not take into consideration the advances that can be made when using factors of the biomedical model. This essay will evaluate the social and biomedical models of health, incorporating the sociological perspectives of Parsons (1951) and Marx (1818).
The biomedical model of health focuses on the physical and biological aspects of disease and illness along with the key elements of diagnosis and cure. The biomedical model is dominant over other models of health; this is due to the majority of funding, according to being allocated to the doctors and hospitals that provide patients with prescription drugs, scans, x-rays and tests. According to (NHS, 2015) “[NHS funding] for 2015/16… was around £115.4 billion”. It could be argued that society has become heavily dependant on medical professionals for ‘quick fix’ cures. According to (Hira, 2015) “…it is probably easier for patients to pop a pill as opposed to changing their lifestyle, exercising and losing weight”. However, Marx (1818) would argue that due to capitalism, hospitals and doctors promote and offer these ‘quick fix’ treatments, because they are the cheapest option and that the poor are being exploited. One of the advantages of the biomedical model is the ability to improve quality of life, for example; a patient born with cystic fibrosis (“… a genetic condition in which the lungs and digestive system become clogged with thick stick...

... middle of paper ... be trying to regain their health. Dementia is a condition that causes the brain to rapidly deteriorate and the ability to communicate, understand and remember can quickly decline; therefor the individual cannot be held responsible for not trying to regain their health. Society adapts to such illnesses so the patient can take on a more permanent sick role.
Both the social and biomedical models offer different perspectives of how health is viewed in society; this is either by focusing on how to stay healthy in order to prevent illness or how to cure an illness or disease. It may be beneficial to merge the two models together, making a bio/social model of health; a society that works towards promoting healthy lifestyles and preventing illness, but still uses medical advances in order to cure and diagnose illnesses and diseases that are out of the hands of society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Models of Health

- Diabetes Melitus Type 2 (T2DM) from the biomedical model and social models of health have important differences. This paper illustrates that the sociological approach to T2DM goes beyond the pathophysiology of the biomedical model and is founded on the premise that social factors impact health. An overview of the biomedical model and discussion of T2DM within this model is followed by a description of the sociological model with a discussion of T2DM within this model. Evidence will support the assertion that using a sociological approach will add to the understanding of the sociological factors contributing to the development of T2DM....   [tags: diabetes melitus, biomedical model]

Better Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

The Biomedical Model of Health and Illness Essay

- The Biomedical Model of Health and Illness The most dominant theory in Modern Western medicine of health and illness, held by many official health practitioners such as doctors, consultants, and surgeons has been labelled the 'biomedical approach' or by some as the 'biomechanical model'. The biomedical model presumes that illness is always due to abnormalities in the body's workings. It is the basis of modern Western medical practice. It works on the theory that if a part of the body goes wrong it should be fixed or replaced, in the same way that a machine would be repaired....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1050 words (3 pages)

Social Models Of Health Over The Last 150 Years Essay

- Social models of health have become more relevant and continue to do so when compared to the old biomedical model for health over the last 150 years. World Health Organisation (WHO) (2014) depicts as the health problems in this age have shifted towards cardiovascular diseases, cancers, obesity from infectious diseases in the early 1900s such as pneumonia and tuberculosis models only focusing on the biological solutions have become less important than the social determinants of these diseases. A biomedical model is a set of modelling systems which typically and solely looks at the physical processes including pathology, biochemistry and the physiology of a diseases body or biology behind dise...   [tags: Infectious disease, Epidemiology, Medicine]

Better Essays
900 words (2.6 pages)

Health Is Defined By The World Health Organization Essay

- Health is defined by the World Health Organisation (WHO) as being ‘a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing’. There are many differing perceptions of health in society, some believe health is based on the presence of illness, whereas other people take into consideration their overall wellbeing, and strive to prevent illnesses. Models of Health have been put into place with the aspiration of making a healthier individual or nation. These differ from simply treating any physical or biological illnesses, to looking at trying to make sure a person does not become ill in the first place....   [tags: Health, Health care, Illness, Patient]

Better Essays
1539 words (4.4 pages)

The Field Of Medical Or Health Geography Essay

- Literature Review The field of medical or health geography is saddled with the challenge of defining and conceptualizing medical system. Nevertheless, some argue that this lack of conception is due to the rich diversity of experience and theoretical perspectives among its representative scholars (Press, 1980). Similarly, the challenge of defining a medical system also arises from the different socio-cultural concept of health and medicine (Young, 1982). In this regard Press (1980) further notes that there is no definition which does not contradict the concept of medicine as conceived by others....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Health economics]

Better Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

The Medical Model View On Health Essay

- If one takes the time to study the medical model view on health there is often evidence to suggest that it is one of the eldest models created to help define mental illness compared to the social model which is relatively new (Pender, 1996) and still holds dominance (Bowling, 2005). Even though there are different phases used in order to strengthen the medical model such as “biomedical model”, “disease model”, “medical model” and “preventive model” all of them are used interchangeably in the compound of literature and upon review it is discovered that the views of each model is either the same or similar....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Health, Sociology]

Better Essays
1209 words (3.5 pages)

The National Health Services Essay

- The National health services (NHS) provides a comprehensive healthcare services across the entire nation. It is considered to be UK’s proudest institution, and is envied by many other countries because of its free of cost health delivery to its population. Nevertheless, it is often seen as a ‘political football’ as it affects all of us in some way and hence everyone carry an opinion about it (Cass, 2006). Factors such as government policies, funding, number of service users, taxation etc all make up small parts of this large complex organisation....   [tags: Health, Insurance]

Better Essays
2177 words (6.2 pages)

The Provision Of Mental Health Essay

- Introduction Mental health is something that every health professional will face in their careers, whether they specialise in mental health practice or not because it is one of the most common causes of non-fatal disability in Australia (Hungerford, et al., Chapter 1 The provision of mental health care in Australia, 2012). To efficiently and accurately help people with mental health issues, health professionals need to learn to recognise mental health issues, become familiar with the person centred approach and the recovery model used in mental health practice, understand therapeutic alliances or therapeutic relationships and how it fits into the person centred approach and recovery models,...   [tags: Mental health, Health care, Mental disorder]

Better Essays
2086 words (6 pages)

Sociology of Health and Illness Essay

- Sociology of Health and Illness The sociological approaches focus on identifying the two sociological theories. We critically analysed the biomedical model and doctor patient relationship. We also evaluated how the medical professionals exercise social control and medical professional’s contribution to ill health. The difference between society and health is studied by sociologist in relation to health and illness. This also discusses health in relation to social institutions for example family, employment and school....   [tags: Wellbeing, Society Health]

Better Essays
2118 words (6.1 pages)

Social Model of Health of the Maori Tribe Essay

- Discuss and Contrast the Maori and Social models of Health "Health is a social, economic and political issue and above all a fundamental human right. Inequality, poverty, exploitation, violence and injustice are at the root of ill-health" (Braum, 2008, p.3).The Maori model of Health, in particular "Whare Tapa Wha" is based on four simple key aspects to ensure overall general health and well being, Taha Wairua, Taha Hinengaro, Taha Tinana and Taha Whanau. These are the basic foundations or stepping stones to an significant determinant of good health, that can be found across the many multiple health models (Durie, 1998, p.66)....   [tags: anthropology, world medicine]

Better Essays
984 words (2.8 pages)