Analysis Of Frederick Douglass And The Library Card By Richard Wright

1638 Words4 Pages

No matter how bad one may be suffering, there is always another who is suffering even worse. Even throughout history, African Americans suffered due to segregation and discrimination; however, those who were enslaved anguished more than those who were freed. Well, such is essence in both “Learning to Read and Write” by Frederick Douglass, and “The Library Card” by Richard Wright, where Douglass wrote about his suffering as a slave; however, Wright poses his perspective as a free man. An EOF student named Kathy Huynh claims that Douglass had it worse than Wright because the risks he exposed himself to were immense. Corresponding to Huynh’s reaction, evidence from the text proves that Douglass indeed had it worse than Wright because he received …show more content…

Since Douglass was a slave, he did not have anyone to there to rely on, nor did he trust anyone. At first, he did have his mistress teaching him the alphabet; however, she turned out to be deceitful. Evidently, Douglass indicates: “she finally became more violent in her opposition” (Douglass 146). Even so, Douglass met two Irishmen who may have attempted to support Douglass by advising him to escape north; however, he became paranoid and was unable to trust them because they may have been using Douglass for their own benefit. In efforts to show his paranoia, Douglass asserts: “I fear they might be treacherous” (149). The fact that he becomes so paranoid after realizing whomever he encounters is cynical, it shows how quickly he forces himself into isolation. On the contrary, Wright was not isolated like Douglass because he was not alone. Being he was a freed man, he was given access to go into the library by a man named Mr. Falk because Wright’s library card was filled with books. Douglass added that Falk utters: “But when you’re through reading those books, I want you to tell me what you get out of them” (Wright 334). It just proves that Wright had someone to conversate with and to confide with and it indicates how Wright was not alone, unlike Douglass who was alone. In …show more content…

Comparative to Huynh’s perspective, evidence from the text proves the case that Douglass suffered more than Wright because Douglass was a slave, whereas Wright was a freed man. If it was not for Douglass’s condition, he would have never: been paranoid and developed isolation towards the world; acquired a disadvantaged with his education; and be maliciously mistreated by his slave owners. Likewise, an American author named Brennan Manning concluded that: “Suffering, failure, loneliness, sorrow, discouragement, and death will be part of your journey.” In Douglass’s and Wright’s case, they both were a part of their own journey, but because Douglass’s journey was more severe, he indeed had it far worse than

Open Document