Habib Moody, a student at Yale University, is the author of “Soldiers for Rent”. In this article written for The New Atlantis, Moody argues that the government should not be hiring companies to fight the war for our soldiers. At one point in the article he says by hiring private companies to fight, we are “degrading such a noble calling”. In other words, by having civilians working alongside the military we are degrading a soldier’s work. He generates claims and describes why he thinks there is a lack of oversight and regulation on contractors overseas. Because of this, the contractors are unpunishable and getting away with war crime. While I agree with Moody that there is an excess of government military contracts, having private companies overseas is highly beneficial to our government. Without these contracts, the amount of U.S. military personnel would need to be increased to more than double, leading to a higher government expense than what the contractors charge.
Private military companies or PMCs have been taking part in wars for the United States for a long time now. Deborah Kidwell is the Assistant Professor of Military History and has done a lot of research on PMCs. She says in her book “Public War, Private Fight? The United States and Private Military Companies” that PMCs were used as far back as the American Revolution.
During the revolution companies were hired for means l...
... middle of paper ...
...rmy You Can Afford: the United States, International
law, and the Private Military Industry.” Boston University International Law
Journal Spring 2010: 181-218.Academic OneFile.
Hartung, William D. “Privatizing war.” Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 60.2 (2004):
78+. Academic OneFile. Web. 19 Mar. 2014
Karp, Jonathan. “Contractors in War Zone Face Legal Front; Private Firms Like Blackwater could
be Held Liable for Casualties during Military Tasks.” Wall Street Journal Mar 08 2007,
Eastern edition ed. ProQuest. 4 Mar. 2014
Kidwell, Deborah C. Public War, Private Fight? The United States and Private Military
Companies. Fort Leavenworth, Kansas: Combat Studies Institute Press, 2011. Google
Scholar. Web. 13 Mar. 2014.
Moody, Habib. “Soldiers For Rent.” The New Atlantis 17 (2007): 122-27. Web. 2014.
Ruohenen, Thomas. Personal interview. 19 Mar. 2014.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Definition of Terms Before we begin we must first understand the different definitions of proprietary and contract security operations. There are many definitions and explanations that are used to distinguish between the two but I will use the definitions provided by Fischer, in his book titled Introduction to Security. “Proprietary security operations are those that are “in-house,” or controlled entirely by the company establishing security for its operations” Fischer, Robert; Halibozek, Edward; Walters, David (2012-11-23).... [tags: Private Security Contractors]
4403 words (12.6 pages)
- In 2013, a West Point survey found that American “civilians born between 1980 and 2000 want no part of military life and want it separate from civilian life”. According to Lieutenant Colonel Remi H. Hajjar, a professor of behavioral sciences and leadership at the United States Military Academy, “most Americans consider our military to be like a guard dog. It offers them protection, but they would rather not have it as a neighbor.” The question to ask is why. Why is it that Americans choose not to connect to their military if they seek their protection.... [tags: Military, Armed forces]
727 words (2.1 pages)
- ... Women’s rights, it may have taken a long time to gain rights but women fought till they had them. Women everywhere cherish having them. Women not being able to fight in combat has alienated them. When in fact women can actually do many things for their country. I believe women gained their rights for a reason. Women shouldn’t be able to not do things just because of their gender. Women should not be excluded on the basis of their gender but be entitled to test themselves against the criteria required for combat ("MP Fights to Let Women in Close Combat”).... [tags: combat, rights, military]
593 words (1.7 pages)
- The American Civil War was the wars of all the great wars. The casualties of the war included men, women and children, whites and African-Americans. Men and boys of the southern states either volunteered or were conscripted into the army. Many of the soldiers thought that they would be fighting for the southern Nation and its rights. Soldiers from both sides and civilians in the vicinity of battles and the war suffered from hardships. Sam Watkins was high private in the war, and approximately twenty years later he wrote his memoirs.... [tags: Military History]
2009 words (5.7 pages)
- Steven Speilberg's Saving Private Ryan The opening 30 minutes of “Saving Private Ryan” is significantly effective as an example to the war film genre. It begins brilliantly with battle between the American and German forces. As the American troops were approaching enemy lines, the representation of the soldiers is that they are just ordinary human beings, not gung-ho. The conscripts were full of anxiety and fear. In fact it’s the very first thing you see with Captain John Miller (played by Tom Hanks) as he is drinking his hand trembles.... [tags: Steven Speilberg, Saving Private Ryan]
510 words (1.5 pages)
- America is a nation built on the beliefs and ideals that man is free. In WWII, challenges arose in America’s freedom. The Declaration of Independence stated that “…all men are created equal.” However, the rights for the ‘White Man’ were significantly above all others, and because of this, women and black men lacked the same equality as the ‘White Man’. In WWII, women took up jobs previously held by men, while the African Americans attempted to join the military. They wanted to assist in the war effort and help defend America to gain their freedom.... [tags: communism, equallity, freedom]
1223 words (3.5 pages)
- In order to save a dying franchise, Dana White, now president of Ultimate Fighting Champions, along with his friends Lorenzo and Frank Fertitta, purchased the league for $2 million in 2001 and invested $44 million along the way (CNBC Originals, 2009). Today, according to the organization’s website, they are the fastest growing sports organization in the world (UFC.com). The UFC is operated under the Zuffa, LLC brand, and their global outreach can be rivaled by the major professional sports leagues in the United States.... [tags: business analysis]
696 words (2 pages)
- In the narrator’s quest for information about the bombing of Dresden, he wrote to the Air Force, hoping to gain more knowledge about what went into the decision. His only official response at the time was “that the information was top secret still” (11). How bombing of Dresden could ever be considered classified when it had such a devastating effect on so many people is just one of the many absurdities pointed out by the narrator in his quest to provide a balanced view of the war. One novel, The Execution of Private Slovik by William Bradford Huie, details the only execution of an American soldier for desertion during World War II.... [tags: Literary Analysis, William Bradford Huie]
898 words (2.6 pages)
- Shakespeare, intending for his plays to be performed as well as published, included the idea of trial by combat in many of his works. During his time, men valued their honor. Based on their friendships and alliances, English men upheld that honor through combat. Because audiences enjoyed the action of one character fighting another, the writer included several duels in his literary works. Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing reflects the history, philosophy, and offenses marked with a duel; his characters’ conflicts mirror the dueling that was common during the Renaissance in Europe.... [tags: fighting for honor]
871 words (2.5 pages)
- Considering that the military’s logistical structure hasn’t had a major improvement in over 60 years, the idea of streamlining and consolidating systems would be a welcome and much needed change. I currently work in the ammunition field for the U.S. Army and have done so for the past 18 years. The changes that the Marines are beginning to implement will help to free up resources and cut funds that could be used for other projects. With the attacks of 9-11, many of the military logisticians realized that we were not finished with what we had begun in 1991.... [tags: essays research papers]
1297 words (3.7 pages)
- Horse Training and Showing
- President Ronald Wilson Regan
- Cloud-Based Energy-Saving Datacentre Architecture
- Poverty Discrimination in Minorities in the United States
- Phillip Morris: Changing Marketing Strategies As a Result of New Governmental Laws and Regulation Regarding Smoking
- Prevention of School and Workplace Violence