Hick´s Hypothesis About Religions Essay

Hick´s Hypothesis About Religions Essay

Length: 1410 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Imagine that three people are all touching a part of an elephant. The first is touching the elephant's leg and says that the elephant is like the truck of a tree. The second is touching the elephant's trunk and disagrees with the first, saying that the elephant is like a large snake. The third person is touching the elephant’s side and says that the elephant is like a great wall.
Each person is convinced that they are right and the others are wrong because of what they know and have experienced. What they don’t realize is that they are all technically right because they are each describing a different aspect of the elephant. The same analogy can be applied to the major religions of the world.
In 1973, John Hick discussed the idea for a paradigm shift in thinking about different religions in his book God and the Universe of Faiths. Hick suggested that each of world's religions should be viewed as "different human responses to one divine reality…." In a later book, Hick presented a theory that attempted to explain all the religions. Hick refers to this theory as a "pluralistic hypothesis" and was that all religions are culturally conditioned responses to the same ultimate reality.
Hick’s pluralistic theory faces one major difficulty though, the contradicting claims that each different religions makes. How can all major religions be responses of the same ultimate reality when they contradict one another? For a pluralistic view to be plausible, the hypothesis has to sufficiently explain how religions can make incompatible claims while at the same time be responses of the same ultimate reality.
To overcome this difficulty, Hick attempts to explain four critical factors: (1) people are inherently religious; (2) there is substantia...


... middle of paper ...


...all are describing the same elephant? How much contradiction is required before it becomes obvious that it’s not the same elephant? A similar question can be asked of Hick's hypothesis. With the conflicting truth-claims of various religions, is it really reasonable to accept Hick's claim that all religions are interpretations of the same ultimate reality?
In a chapter of Disputed Questions, entitled "Jews, Christians, Muslims: Do We All Worship the Same God?" Hick evaluates the plausibility of the claim that all religions worship the same God and merely refer to him by different names. He notes that the difficulty with this position is that the various descriptions must be compatible. The same criticism Hick applied against that position can be applied to Hick's own hypothesis. The differences between religions are far too great for his hypothesis to be plausible.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

New Religious Movements: Cults, New Age and Related Phenomena Essays

- 1. Introduction The 1970’s brought with it an unexpected rise of new religions movements and most of these had links with Eastern origins. These religions operated on the fringes of the traditional religious institutions were immediately controversial. This controversiality combined with the interest shown in them by especially the educated youth, as well their subsequent conversion to these new alternate religious movements, raised serious concerns with the stalwarts of the traditional value systems and the term brainwashing became the acceptable theory in order to explain the reasoning behind those defecting to these movements....   [tags: religion history, rise of new religions]

Powerful Essays
2148 words (6.1 pages)

The Opinion of Parents on Their Children Inter-Marrying into Other Religions

- The Opinion of Parents on Their Children Inter-Marrying into Other Religions My aim was to find out the opinion of parents on their children inter-marring into other religions. To obtain this information I carried out 50 questions in the each of the following shopping centres; Harrow, Brent cross and Watford; I am looking at the North-West of London. I choose these 3 locations as they are large shopping centres in which a wide range of people of different religions shop. I handed out the questionnaires to people I believe to be the following: Aged 40-59 and of the following religions; Christian, Jewish, Hindu and Muslim....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
989 words (2.8 pages)

Moses and Monotheism Essay

- The word monotheism comes from the Greek ‘monos’, which means one, and ‘theos’, which means god. Thus, monotheism is a belief in the existence of a single god. Monotheism is usually contrasted with polytheism, which is the belief in many gods, and atheism, which is the absence of any belief in gods. Because monotheism is founded upon the idea that there is only one god, it is common for believers to also think that this god created all of reality and is totally self-sufficient, without any dependency upon any other being....   [tags: monotheistic religions systems]

Powerful Essays
2023 words (5.8 pages)

Biblical Exegesis Of The Bible Essay

- As cultures have grown and evolved throughout history, so too have opinions regarding the authorship of the Pentateuch. The Pentateuch encapsulates the first five books of the Old Testament: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. As a text that is considered to be the most sacred document in history, it is within the nature of the Bible to attract strong presuppositions that have developed across centuries. Exegesis of the Bible, specifically the first five books, naturally leads to questions of its origin....   [tags: Torah, Bible, Moses, Documentary hypothesis]

Powerful Essays
1304 words (3.7 pages)

The Hypothesis Of Hypothesis Testing Essay

- When utilizing hypothesis testing, we are trying to achieve the goal of accepting or rejecting a null hypothesis. Overall, we want to configure if the initial hypothesis is true. As in the case here, we are hoping to see if the mean birth weight of the women in our sample baby 's birth weight is greater than 5 pounds. Furthermore, we have to determine if there is enough sufficient evidence to prove our hypothesis about what we are setting out to measure. We need to utilize hypothesis testing here to draw inferences about a population from the data acquired from our sample of 189 women....   [tags: Statistical hypothesis testing, Null hypothesis]

Powerful Essays
1115 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Beyond Hypothesis Testing And Testing

- Kadane, J. B. (2016). Beyond Hypothesis Testing. Entropy, 18(5), 1-4. The author explains the disagreement over hypothesis testing and the pressure between easy explanations and the complex world we are a part of. We know that the world is not simple and there are areas of uncertainty in such things as the weather and the economy. He first discusses the frequentist approaches, and the contributions of R.A. Fisher, Neyman, and Pearson to hypothesis testing and tests of significance. Later, he describes the Bayesian approach and how to use Bayes Theorem for testing....   [tags: Statistics, Statistical hypothesis testing]

Powerful Essays
1109 words (3.2 pages)

Universal Religions are Beneficial for the World Essays

- Currently, there are thousands of religions in the world. These religions can be identified as two groups: universal and ethnic. Universal religions can be defined as two words: proselytizing, and accepting. Ethnic religions are religions that are clique. However, universal religions are more beneficial for the health of the world; they influence others on their culture and history, they are generally more accepting and welcoming of diverse affiliations of people, and they also encourage egalitarianism of people throughout the world....   [tags: Universal Religions Essays]

Powerful Essays
1241 words (3.5 pages)

The Many Benefits of Universal Religions Essay

- For thousands of years, religions have had a monumental impact upon billions of people’s lives. Religions have affected every square inch of the planet, and have influenced almost everyone’s life. There are two types of religions, universal, and ethnic. Universal religions have managed to proselytize an impressive amount of followers across the globe. Ethnic religions and universal religions are very different. While ethnic religions have stayed in concentrated areas, isolated from everyone else, not seeking any other followers, universal religions had openly welcomed many diverse people, and succeeded to rapidly solve major world issues....   [tags: Universal Religions Essays]

Powerful Essays
1140 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Too Many Religions, Not Enough Truth

- The number of converts to Sikhism, Zoroastrianism, Baha’ism, and Spiritualism is growing daily. People are searching for a genuine Faith that is not dominated by greed and hypocrisy. Indigenous, tribal practices are performed to this day in remote regions of the world. Shamans and medicine men continue to practice on isolated islands, in Africa, Australia, and New Zealand. Atheism, a concept that any and all religious beliefs are a bunch of bunk, is also gaining support throughout the world. Thousands of religious practices and beliefs exist across the world....   [tags: World Religions]

Powerful Essays
2564 words (7.3 pages)

Hypothesis Essay

- Hypothesis 2: Most Pupils Travel To School By Bus And Travel At Least 10 Miles. Most people travel to school by bus and travel at least 10 miles. The amounts of people who travel by bus from my random samples are 25 pupils all together. The amount of pupils who travel to school by car is 2 pupils and the amount of pupils who get to school by walking is 3 pupils. The bar graph which shows you the distance the pupils have travelled shows the pupils who travel less than 10 and more than 10 miles. This bar graph is the main graph for this hypothesis as we are also trying to find out if pupils travel more than 10 miles....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
415 words (1.2 pages)