Unjust Law

480 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Aquinas natural law theory essay

Just laws are necessary because they provide an essential guidance. Aquinas mentions that “Man has a natural aptitude for virtue” (Aquinas in Dimock, ed., 2002, p.18). Virtue confirms the high moral standards to one. It leads to an end of eternal happiness. This is the goal for all, as Aquinas finds. However, no man is perfect in virtue. To achieve precision, there must be assistance. The assistance may devise from training. Aquinas believes that law is obligated to train virtue within mankind. Law leads any type of man to virtue. “Men who are well disposed are led willingly to virtue by being admonished better than by coercion, but men who are evilly disposed are not led to virtue unless they are compelled” (Aquinas in Dimock, ed., 2002, …show more content…

It is a scaffold that aims to perfect society as a whole. Aquinas defines that law is composed of an end in pursuit of happiness, a common good, created by an official legislator, and promulgation. He articulates that these laws that have the compulsory characteristics that define law, are just. However, laws that do not follow these guidelines are unjust. Aquinas claims that “an unjust law is no law at all” (Aquinas in Dimock, ed., 2002, p.19). A just law is a formulation of natural law, while an unjust law is not. Unjust laws consequently do not aim at eternal happiness, making it detrimental to society. Aquinas also listed the factors that results in the failure of a law. He states that unjust laws aim only at the good of the legislator and exceeds His authority, as well as it imposes unequal benefits and burdens among its followers. Similar to so, the success of law is dependent on it’s binding force. The law must be in favour of human and divine good. As the binding force illuminates, there is also a moral obligation and coercive power. Furthermore, Aquinas finds that law is a basis to acquire a strong virtue. After a critical analysis of Aquinas’s Natural Law Theory, one can presume that unjust laws are unfavourable to society. They create disorder, chaos, and confusion. Not only do just laws organize society, but they also work to allow every individual to grow with society. Ultimately, bringing mankind closer to the

Show More
Related

  • The Case Against Civil Disobedience

    913 Words  | 2 Pages

    Morality is the principles and standards set by society for evaluating between right and wrong. “One has not only a legal but a moral responsibility to obey just laws” (A Natural Law Approach 284). Unreasonable laws created by a democratic legislature can very e...

    Read More

  • Abuse of Religion in The Handmaid’s Tale

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    laws is to keep the bad things out from the old society out such as

    Read More

  • Natural Law, Rationality and the Social Contract

    2087 Words  | 5 Pages

    While Hobbes’ and Aquinas’ theories hold the same basic boundaries of recognizing inherent human knowledge, they have different opinions regarding the specifics contained within these boundaries. The foremost difference rests in the concept of natural law. Aquinas sees natural law as the second link in the chain of laws that originated directly from God. The foundati...

    Read More

  • Cathleen Kaveny: The Primary Purpose Of Law

    1681 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bernard Brady reflects on similar aspects that comprise a good law, many of which are closely related to the works of Thomas Aquinas. Dr. Brady remarks on what Isidore of Seville, a theologian, believes to be the most important characteristics of a good law: “Law shall be virtuous, just, possible to nature, according to the custom of the country, suitable to place and time, necessary, useful; clearly expressed, lest by its obscurity it lead to misunderstanding; framed for no private benefit, but for the common good” (Brady, p. 32). Thus, all the conditions listed are needed to fulfill the requirements of being a good law or policy and in turn be a law to improve the common good. The importance of a law being “possible to nature” is reflected in both Aquinas’ and Brady’s writings; without this requirement, the common good will be diminished. As Brady explains, “Laws, to be good laws, have to be enforceable.

    Read More

  • The Canadian Criminal Justice System

    1961 Words  | 4 Pages

    In every society around the world, the law is affecting everyone since it shapes the behavior and sense of right and wrong for every citizen in society. Laws are meant to control a society’s behavior by outlining the accepted forms of conduct. The law is designed as a neutral aspect existent to solve society’s problems, a system specially designed to provide people with peace and order. The legal system runs more efficiently when people understand the laws they are intended to follow along with their legal rights and responsibilities.

    Read More

  • Letter To Birmingham Jail

    1153 Words  | 3 Pages

    12). By this he means that if a law is going to be unjust it should not even be a law because it is not fair as laws should always be. For example King says “A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law, or the law of God” (par. 13). King says this so he can appeal to the nature of the clergyman and help them see the error of their ways. He also says this so that he can tell them that these laws that are placed upon him and his people are unjust laws that do not comply with the law of God which also contradict the teachings of the clergymen. Another example that further develops the quote “‘An unjust law is no law is no law at all”’ is when King says “So segregation is not politically, economically, and sociologically unsound, but it is morally wrong and sinful” (par. 13). When King says this, he is implying that if segregation is sinful and wrong it should not even be a law and it should not even be supported by the clergymen as they are supposedly men of

    Read More

  • Difference Between Virtue And Relative Virtue

    2158 Words  | 5 Pages

    It is part of the middle well-being of a person under its subjective criteria and it is guided by the rational capacity of a human and more specifically of that of a rational person (1144b27-29). Virtue has the capacity to develop periodically and it becomes a habit of the disposition. However, virtue plays an important role in society because the people learn through social connections and experimentations how to act and how their acting reflects to their social surrounding. Our social surrounding judges on how ethical our acts are and develop the capacity to judge the rest of the peoples acts accordingly.

    Read More

  • Thomas Eternal Law Summary

    630 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this reading, Thomas expounds upon the idea of law by examining the very basis and nature of its existence. Through his highly structured rhetoric, he explains the purpose of law and its consequences on the nature of law. Once he establishes reason as the basis for all law, he summarizes the four types of law – eternal, natural, human, and divine – and briefly discusses their purpose, relationship to other forms of law, and effects. Thomas next scrutinizes the intricacies of eternal and natural law; though he does not explicitly state the content of such law, he suggests it through his arguments regarding their nature, reach, and promulgation. Thomas appeals constantly to the idea of rationalism, arguing that all law is based on human’s nature of reason.

    Read More

  • Rule Of Law

    1663 Words  | 4 Pages

    According to Aristotle, "The rule of law is better than that of any individual”, suggesting every member of society, even a ruler, must abide by and follow the law. The rule of law is linked to the principle of justice, meaning that everyone within a society (including both private citizens and government officials) are subject to the law, and that those laws are administered fairly and justly. The intention of the rule of law is to protect against arbitrary governance. It is the basic underpinning of a free society.

    Read More

  • St. Thomas Aquinas Influence On Christian Theology

    1195 Words  | 3 Pages

    St. Thomas Aquinas was an incredibly influential philosopher and theologian during the medieval period whose thoughts and ideas have enormous influence on Christian theology. His thoughts on the philosophy of law strive to answer the many questions of law and in doing so identifies four different kinds. However, before the different types of law can be identified and explained, the true definition of law must be understood. Law, according to Thomas is “a standard of measurement for behaviour, fostering certain actions and discouraging others” (Selected Philosophical Writings (SPW), 411). Aristotle claims that the starting point for anything becomes the standard of measurement for anything in that realm.

    Read More

  • Natural Law And Positive Law

    1257 Words  | 3 Pages

    While the philosophers such as Plato were not deemed to be lawyers, their theories later set forth later developed with natural law (Riddall, pg. 59). Classical natural law theory was deemed skeptical by those believing many would value selfish means of natural desires to an extent in which others are disregarded, but philosophers such as Plato recognized the need for such principles to be moderated in order for natural responsibilities to occur a moral approach (Coleman, pg. 3). Such moderation sought by Plato was with the intent to legitimize legal orders on the account of their ethical principles. These desires or responsibilities are founded on natural, universal yearnings, demonstrating why such a foundation has proven to be so versatile in its use. The moral principles set forth through religion also played a major role in determining what was the appropriate standard as Christianity was such a dominant force in this age. This power was further applied by St Thomas Aquinas through his interpretations of living in a godly society, primarily how this involved man being at peace with one another, and allowing them to serve their religious inclinations. Aquinas favored law being for the “divine good” of society, and claimed that law that does not adhere to such principle is in fact, unjust, therefore invalid (Riddall,

    Read More

  • Unjust Justice

    1114 Words  | 3 Pages

    Justice is in fact the most important system of our government. To some people justice is the punishment someone receives after being convicted of a crime; other people could think it means the difference between knowing right from wrong. In my opinion, along with dictionary.com, justice is best defined as the fair and equal treatment of people. This is not just used in the court of law however; my definition should be used in every aspect of human life, from work to school and beyond. But, for that to happen, I believe "fair and equal treatment" needs to be defined, and that means to treat people of any skin color, gender, age, sexual preference, or any other personal trait the same way.

    Read More

  • Law And Morality Essay

    811 Words  | 2 Pages

    Both law and morality serve to regulate behaviour in society. Morality is defined as a set of key values, attitudes and beliefs giving a standard in which we ‘should’ behave. Law, however, is defined as regulating behaviour which is enforced among society for everyone to abide by. It is said that both, however, are normative which means they both indicate how we should behave and therefore can both be classed as a guideline in which society acts, meaning neither is more effective or important than the other. Law and morals have clear differences in how and why they are made. Law, for example, comes from Parliament and Judges and will be made in a formal, legal institution which result in formal consequences when broken. Whereas morals are formed under the influence of family, friends, media or religion and they become personal matters of individual consciences. They result in no formal consequence but may result in a social disapproval which is shown also to occur when breaking the law.

    Read More

  • Thomas Aquinas Natural Law Summary

    1713 Words  | 4 Pages

    In question 94 of his On Law, Morality, and Politics, Thomas Aquinas initiates his interpretation of natural law. He defines law as, “an ordinance of reason for the common good by one competent to make it, and promulgated” (10). Here, he suggests law is derived from an act of reason which commands or prohibits. Thus, it compels behavior. It must be rational and ordered to the common good of a community. Throughout On Law, Morality, and Politics, Aquinas analyzes four kinds of law: human, divine, eternal, and natural. Although human law is integral for the order of society, humans require more in order to live virtuous lives. Therefore, natural law is important due to its focus on human beings and their societies, as well as for its interconnected

    Read More

  • Importance Of Law In The Society

    1628 Words  | 4 Pages

    Law serves to preserve the interests of the majority such that everyone has equal opportunity at and access to resources. If everyone were to pursue their own self-interest certain people would be better off than others and or have greater advantage over others and completely dominate over them which would eventually lead to chaos.

    Read More

More about Unjust Law

Open Document