The Failure of the Qing Dynasty

857 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Historiography on the collapse of the qing

The Failure of the Qing Dynasty

Although some short term successes were achieved for China when

dealing with western demands of diplomatic relations and free trade,

in the sense that it retained their pride in their tributary systems,

such responses were in flawed in the long term. Focusing on the time

period 1793-1839, this essay will investigate what were the western

attempts and demands in diplomatic relations and free trade. It will

also investigate what was the reason to the failure of the Qing

dynasty to respond effectively to western demands of diplomatic

relations and free trade. The two aspects will be explored

respectively. It will be argued that the Qing government’s failures in

responding effectively had led to long term grievances towards China’s

existing system by the West, as well as exacerbated silver outflow of

Chinese economy. The main factor leading to failures in effective

response to western demands was China’s construct that it was superior

to any other alien powers.

Western demands for diplomatic relations can be seen in the three

missions from 1793-1834 (Macartney, Amherst and Napier), but Qing’s

rejection of Western demands resulted in Western grievances towards

the existing system. The failure for Qing to respond effectively to

Western demands was due to its world view that it was superior.

The Macartney mission was a relative success, for communication

between the West and China had been established, but the latter two

missions were failures in term of establishing a friendly relationship

between powers. The main objectives of the missions were to open the

whole East to British trade, place relatio...

... middle of paper ...

... free trade between 1793-1839 was mainly due to China’s construct that

it was superior over any other countries. If the Chinese had not been

so self-absorbed and so intent on keeping their country as closed off

as possible, they might have at least realized that the Guangzhou

system of trade was collapsing and that if it did collapse, the

tribute system would go down with it. China established the

relationship between tribute and trade as an instrument for

controlling the “barbarian”. The failure in responding effectively to

Western demands due to Chinese construct was a failure, for not only

it had exacerbated grievances of foreigners towards the Chinese

system, it had also aggravated the devastating silver outflow and

inflation problem in China. As a result, by 1839, the stage for the

Opium War was already well set.

Show More
Related

  • The Political Turmoil of China From 1911 to 1927

    368 Words  | 1 Pages

    Consequently, no particular warlord was able to unify and stabilize China. A third reason was continued intervention of the foreign powers. Since the 19th century, the West had intervened in the affairs of China, forcing China to open up its ports and trade with them. Their exploitation caused many people to think lowly of the central government. Their continued presence after 1911 revolution caused a lot of resentment amongst the people.

    Read More

  • British Imperialism in China and Africa

    840 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the most important aspects of imperialism is the take over of government. The English accomplished this in several ways. Some of the “Unfair Treaties” forced the Chinese to allow the English ships into their ports and to allow them to have a major role in the trade market. The English wanted tea, porcelain, and silk from china. The Chinese however didn’t want to gods the English offered in return. The English began trading opium in return for the goods. Although it was illegal, many of the money hungry merchants excepted the opium in return for the things that were valuable to the English. Because of this, the first Anglo-Chinese war erupted. China underestimated the power of England and was defeated. At the end of the war, they were forced to sign the Treaty of Nanjing (1842). The treaty was one of the first treaties known as the “Unfair Treaties.” Under this treaty, china gave up the island of Hong Kong, abolished the licensed monopoly system of trade, granted English nationals exemption from Chinese laws, and agreed to give England whatever trading concessions that were granted to other countries then and later.

    Read More

  • European Imperialism of China and Japan

    402 Words  | 1 Pages

    At the end of the eighteenth century, China’s goods were much desired by Britain. However, the Chinese saw Europeans as savages and did not want to trade with them. During trade, there was an imbalance in China’s favor, because the Europeans were forced to buy Chinese goods using silver. The Western Imperialists began to grow opium poppies from in India, and then smuggle them into China. China soon became addicted to the drug and spent most of it’s money on the purchase of it from the Europeans and Americans. This shifted the balance of power to be in Europe’s favor.

    Read More

  • The Political Importance of Zheng He’s Voyages

    913 Words  | 2 Pages

    The lack of imperial political interests and support in navy expeditions to foreign countries was the main reason why China withdrew from the ocean after Zheng He’s 7 voyages. However, the political significance and legacy of Zheng He’s expeditions cannot be ignored. It strengthened the Middle Kingdom’s power and influence in Asia during the early years of the Ming Dynasty. The peaceful nature of Zheng He’s voyages is still used by the Chinese government today as a political tool to advocate the benevolent intention of contemporary Chinese foreign policy (Dreyer, p. 29). Works Cited 1.

    Read More

  • Westernization in China and Japan

    1311 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Chinese empire had once been one of the greatest and most powerful empires in the world. Before the 19th century, China had a large population and was ruled by families or dynasties. It was considered technologically advanced as China had a history of many miraculous inventions, such as: writing, magnetic compasses, movable sails, porcelain, abacus and paper money. Although China was isolated from the rest of the world, it coped well on its own, and saw no need to begin trading with the west, (as Lord McCartney proposed in 1793), since it was a self-sufficient nation. At that particular time, the Chinese empire was still able to exclude the ‘barbarians’, thus forcing them to only trade at one port. However, China soon took a turn for the worst as important ...

    Read More

  • Comparison Of J. A. Hobson's Imperialism On China

    1062 Words  | 3 Pages

    China would like to think of themselves as living in a microcosm. Foreigners are almost inferiors to China because each culture is so different that any influence foreigners would encourage to Chinese men would only be observed rather than accepted. Persistent Westerners hardly made any influence on China. Two different views upon Western impact on China were compared between J.A. Hobson’s Imperialism and Mike Davis’s Late Victorian Holocaust. Hobson’s coverage on China was a perspective written a century earlier than Davis’s coverage. The comparison of China on different timelines can explain the progress China has made, although between the two coverages, China was still adamant in preserving their culture and traditions.

    Read More

  • Ottoman vs. Qing

    875 Words  | 2 Pages

    Chapter 4: China's Qing Dynasty & Its Collapse." East-Asian-History Home. Penn State. Web. 06 Apr. 2011..

    Read More

  • Han Dynasty Collapse

    779 Words  | 2 Pages

    Collapse of the Han Dynasty Many years ago in China, the Han dynasty was the most powerful empire of its time. The Han dynasty took place from 221 BCE to 220 CE. The decline of the Han was due to the fact that both external and internal pressures began to build against the empire. During the two centuries of fighting in the Sino-Xiongnu Wars, the Han dynasty began to collapse due to financial burden and higher taxes being pushed onto the citizens. Another factor of external collapse was by a group called the Yellow-Turbans who rebelled against the Hans from 184 BCE to 204 CE.

    Read More

  • Reasons For The Fall Of The Han Dynasty

    220 Words  | 1 Pages

    One of the most influential reason for the fall of the Han Dynasty was Taxation. The reason why taxation had such a big impact was because once the Han Dynasty was getting weaker it could no longer tax many of its subjects. It was no longer strong enough to force anyone or anything to pay their taxes, or even give the work time that they owed to the government. Eventually when that didn’t work either the Han dynasty had to increase taxation levels. The Han tried to get rid of the power of the wealthy by raising the taxation levels but once it started to fall, it just made the wealthy even more powerful and they used the fall to their advantage, which just made the Han dynasty even more weak. On the other hand, Western Rome also had a similar

    Read More

  • The Cause of the Opium War

    894 Words  | 2 Pages

    The geography of China was something like a fence. This isolation made the people of China feel like their country was prestigious and secluded from the rest of the world. With deserts and the Himalayas running along most of the border, it was extremely difficult to cross over one of the most dangerous mountain ranges in the world and a few other scorching deserts with the little transport they had during that time. The only way merchants could come into the country was the southeastern coast of China where most of the prosper cities resided. What led China to become conceited was because they had an abundant of goods that most of the world wanted. In 1760-1830s, China was famous for its porcelain (rich Europeans loved it), silk, and of course, tea. Since this Eastern Powerhouse’s goods were so popular, therefore, there were only a few things that interested them to trade with. It seemed as if tea was a drug for the Europeans because for them it was just so addicting, to the point they would do anything just to get more and more. The only things that were worthy for trading with the Chinese were gingko (type of plant), shark fin, a soft type of wood (used for incense) and silver. As the demand for tea rose, Britain gradually ran out of silver to trade with, and was desperate to find what China wanted. Then, the British resorted to trading opium. China was very picky of their opium. There was a certain kind of make they wanted, it was a compact ball wr...

    Read More

  • Qing Dynasty Europe During The Qing Dynasty Europe

    203 Words  | 1 Pages

    With hindsight, I still believe a conflict between the west and China would have not been avoidable. All throughout the Qing dynasty Europe was in an imperial craze, going all over the world colonizing and conquering different areas. In the beginning of the Qing dynasty Europe was going to colonize the Americas, and by the 1900’s Africa was split through of the Berlin conference in 1884 and India would have been under British control in 1858. China would have been no different as the Imperialistic powers would have just competed in a new country to conquer lands. In the book it also mentions Kang Youwei essays of the fear of becoming Poland ,”divided by the European powers in the Eighteenth century” (254) there was a real fear that China would

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The West Unique, Not Universal

    701 Words  | 2 Pages

    Many societies who viewed Western culture as parasitic were forced to adapt to Western culture for survival. For China, the Americans made the Chinese dependant on them for supplying Opium. When the Chinese fought against the sale of Opium, the America's superior military defeated them and forced them into an unfair treaty. This created a Western presence in China, pushing Western laws, values, religion, and language on the Chinese.

    Read More

  • The Rise And Fall Of The Xia Dynasty

    201 Words  | 1 Pages

    Despite the prosperous years that the Xia Dynasty or the city of Ur witnessed over the years, famine and annihilation were not absent. Although both of these civilizations dealt with obstacles and difficulties in the past, nothing could’ve prepared them for what was forthcoming. The spread of hunger, the wrath of the Gods and natural disasters and weather patterns inevitably proved to be the downfall of these once thriving societies and civilizations.

    Read More

  • The 1911 Chinese Revolution

    1164 Words  | 3 Pages

    The 1911 Revolution kicked out the Qing Dynasty and broke the barriers to different developments in China. However, the 1911 Revolution has only provided a framework of a republic and made changes in some particular aspects related to immediate problems and difficulties in society. Hence, the relationship between the revolution and the subsequent development of China was very weak. On one hand, I do not agree with the latter part of the statement that the 1911 Revolution brought new problems to China. The conflicts and problems that China suffered in the early/ mid 1910s were mainly due to the weakness of the military force, conflicting political organizations and disorder in society. On the other hand, I agree with the first part of the statement that the 1911 Revolution did not bring peace to China afterwards. In the following paragraphs, I am going to focus on explaining the reasons of emerging new problems in China and also illustrate my points on the factors of the 1911 Revolution which could not bring in peace to China related to the conditions of the country.

    Read More

  • The Ming Dynasty

    1275 Words  | 3 Pages

    The purpose of this paper is to tell the history of the Ming Dynasty’s impact on the Chinese Empire, and to explain why the Chinese Empire was in fact an empire.

    Read More

More about The Failure of the Qing Dynasty

Open Document