Similarities Of An Effective Leader In Hbo's Band Of Brothers
analytical Essay
521 words
HBO’s series “Band Of Brothers” involves analysis of effective leadership and what qualities make for an effective leader. Despite having several similarities including serving in the same unit, holding leadership roles and suffering from some sort of trauma several of these leaders serve as foils for each other. By analyzing the differences between Captain Winters, Sergeant Lipton and Lieutenant Dike an argument can be made to decide what qualities make the most effective and ineffective leader. By looking at what the leader does, what the leader says and what others say about the leader the series determines what does and does not make a good leader in a military setting. The best of these leaders is Captain Richard “Dick” Winters, for he is highly respected. When Lipton was comparing the leaders of E company, he said, “Winters was a leader we could all respect” (Yost “The Breaking Point”). When a leader is highly respected their men are less likely to disobey orders. When a leader is respected their men often put more trust in them. When a leader is respected their followers put confidence in them and are more likely to agree with what they say. If a leader is not respected they will be second guessed when they make choices and their followers are less likely to follow them blindly. By this example, Winters being highly respected makes him an effective leader. …show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes the differences between captain winters, sergeant lipton and lieutenant dike to determine what qualities make the most effective and ineffective leader in a military setting.
- Explains that captain richard "dick" winters is highly respected, and he is an effective leader.
- Explains that sergeant lipton is the 2nd best leader amongst these leaders, for he is responsible. he steps up when dike is not present, and gets respect from his peers.
- Explains that lieutenant dike is the most ineffective leader amongst these leaders, because he is selfish.
- Analyzes how captain winters, sergeant lipton and lieutenant dike's individual characteristics characterize them as effective or ineffective leaders in both a general or military setting.
Throughout the episode titled “The Breaking Point,” we see Lipton step up when Dike is not present. An effective leader steps up when he is needed regardless of the task. A leader who is responsible takes care of tasks that must be done even if they are not appointed to them. Lipton gets respect from his peers because they recognize that he steps up and leads or helps them when their leader is not present. This example shows that Lipton being responsible makes him an effective
Related
- argumentative
- explanatory
- analytical
- opinion
- Leadership, Characteristics, Irrelevance, And Influenceargumentative essayThe influence and leadership qualities demonstrated by the authors are harmonic with in themselves. They provide great balance to leadership and influence; traits that are often forgotten.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that influence is a captivating trait that is sought-after by many leaders, but key elements are often missed because constant measuring is not in place.
- Explains that leadership and influence can be gained through motivation and ability. proper empathy and sincerity will ensure there's positive and beneficial motivational behind each individual.
- Compares lencioni and grenny's books, stating that their influence and leadership qualities are harmonic with each other and provide great balance to leadership and influence.
- Explains grenny's suggestion that leaders must demonstrate three (3) qualities that lencioni is instructing. the six sources of influence play a key role.
- Explains that anonymity, irrelevance, and immeasurement lead to being miserable at work. if these three items are not in focus by an individual's manager, motivation and ability will decline.
- Explains that people cannot be fulfilled in their work if they are not known. when recognized for their accomplishments, their personal motivation will be directly impacted.
- Opines that a person needs to feel they have relevance in the work they are performing. this reminds them of "busy work."
- Explains that irrelevance plays a part within personal and social motivation from the six sources of influence.
- Analyzes how lencioni coined a word, 'immeasurement.' employees need to be able to gauge their progress and level of contribution for themselves.
- Explains that the principle behind a leader is often overshadowed by an individual's powerful position. motivation and ability need to be measured on three different levels, personal, social, and structural.
- Explains that a leader can learn that we are all human beings and we all have emotions tied to our work ethic. finding importance in sincerity and relevance can provide the spark that is needed for personal, social, and structural motivation.
- Concludes that a leader can use the information within the two books to create an effective organizational environment by measuring the six sources of influence and applying rules to avoid miserable jobs for others.
834 wordsRead More - What Are The Characteristics Of Leadership In Nursing Essayexplanatory essayAccording to Sherman (2012), followers greatly contribute to the success of their leaders, and one must give their participation, support, acceptance of the challenge, open communication, trust and give their feedbacks. Behind every successful leader is a motivated and responsible follower.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that they prefer to write an article about leadership qualities because leadership is more than just a title, remuneration received, power vested, but it's about the unequivocal changes an leader can cause not just to their subordinates but to the recipients of quality healthcare.
- Aims to identify the characteristics of a leader that their followers perceive as contributing factors to their success and the organization in the health care system.
- Explains that leading health care professionals is a challenging and demanding role. leaders can be followers and followers can become future leaders.
- Explains the common characteristics of a leader as perceived by nurses are their passion for the nursing profession, the sense of positivity, good interpersonal skills, an excellent health educator and role model, and strong communication skills.
- Explains that followers greatly contribute to the success of leaders, and one must give their participation, support, acceptance of the challenge, open communication, trust and give feedbacks. behind every successful leader is a motivated and responsible follower.
- Analyzes how westphal (2012) explores the changes in leadership workforce due to the demands of leadership positions, generation gap, and competency and skills requirement.
- Opines that there are numerous essential and excellent leadership qualities, but unpleasant qualities such as incompetence, domineering, rigidity, ill-tempered, cruelty, corruption, narrow-mindedness, immorality and absenteeism could destroy leadership performance.
- Explains that successful leadership entails a symbiotic relationship, in which everyone will take part to achieve each others’ goal.
- Explains anonson et al.'s study that infective role as a leader can be measured by the productivity of their subordinates, frequency of absenteeism, fast turnover, detachment from the group and low morale as its consequences.
- Explains the positive outcomes of effective leadership are high team spirit, valuable staff retention, sense of belongingness to the group, mutual respect, high collaboration, open communication, empowerment and especially high patient satisfaction and outcome.
- Opines that leaders should know how to present themselves to their colleagues and manage themselves properly because good governance starts from oneself.
- Explains that leadership is an important tool for the effective delivery of health care services. it is important to understand and distinguish the essential characteristics of a leader that will help uplift the nursing profession.
874 wordsRead More - Essay On Manfred Von Richthofen's Leadership Qualitiesanalytical essayTo be a good leader you need to be brave, experienced, and hardworking. Unlike the football game life isn’t always about the final score. Leaders such as Richthofen, Rickenbacker, and Mitchell put their lives on the line for what they believed
In this essay, the author
- Explains that the players look to the quarterback as he runs onto the field with the final play of the game.
- Analyzes how manfred von richthofen, also known as the red baron, faced fear by looking on the bright side of the situation that he was placed in.
- Explains that eddie rickenbacker, a ww1 fighter pilot, excelled at multiple jobs and was hard-working. he made mistakes and became one of the best us air force pilots.
- Describes how william "billy" mitchell was an army general for the united states. he vigorously promoted the idea that the airplane would replace the fleet as america's first line of defense.
- Explains that leaders like richthofen, rickenbacker, and mitchell put their lives on the line for what they believed in.
572 wordsRead More - Leadership Vs Followership Essayanalytical essay2. You must first be a follower to be an effective leader. Retired Air Force Colonel Phillip S. Meilinger states, “Leadership is not a commodity to be bought at the price of followership.”1
In this essay, the author
- Argues that followership is more important than leadership. the first main point considers that an individual must first be a follower to know how to lead others.
- Explains that leadership is not a commodity to be bought at the price of followership. followership drives organizations with individuals who strive to solve problems, think critically, and project goals of their business.
- Explains that leaders are the ones who command and direct followers. the active duty oath of enlistment dictates to enlisted service members that they obey the orders of the officers appointed over them.
- Concludes that followership is more important than leadership by illustrating the importance of following mentors.
794 wordsRead More - Theme Of Leadership In Lord Of The Fliesexplanatory essayIn Lord of the Flies, leadership is shown in a variety of ways. Ralph is your ideal leader, he’s a good person, looks out for others, is selfless, and always has a goal in mind. Jack is a power hungry leader, bound and determined to have the power for one person, himself. He doesn’t care what happens to the others around him as long as long as he himself is happy. Simon is the spiritual leader, being all knowing and guided by what he feels from his surroundings. Piggy is the smart leader, thinking logically and with reason to achieve his goals, whilst still minding the others out of respect. All these leaders can be great in their own way, but it begs the question; what kind of leader am I? If I had to change my name and be a character in the novel, which character would he write me as?
In this essay, the author
- Explains that in lord of the flies, leadership is shown in a variety of ways. ralph is your ideal leader, he looks out for others, is selfless, and always has goals in mind.
- Explains that a good leader is someone who is goal-oriented, but bases their goals on one's own desires. a leader who lives in the present and fails to take time to think of what their actions may constitute for the future is toxic.
- Describes the traits of a good leader, such as maturity, sensibility, and goal-oriented leadership.
- Opines that they have a particular fondness for ralph as his actions are very reminiscent of actions they display in their own leadership. ralph commandeers the task of building shelter for the littleuns.
- Opines that having the same ideas as ralph, they would have been able to get the tribe just as far, if not further.
1092 wordsRead More - Platoon Sergeantopinion essayRegardless of the career you choose in your life, whether it be an accountant or a Soldier in the United States Army, someone, somewhere most likely had an influence to bring you to that decision. The Army defines leadership as the process of influencing people by providing purpose, direction, and motivation while operating to accomplish the mission and improve the organization (JP, p. 1). Now imagine you are a young Private, in one of the most dangerous places in Iraq and you have constant leadership changes, and not much support from your direct leadership. I am sure at this point you can imagine, it is not the best scenario to be in. Throughout the duration of this essay you will read about Sergeant First Class Rob Gallagher and Sergeant First Class Jeff Fenlason, their leadership abilities, and the techniques they attempted to use to resolve the issues in this Platoon that was in a downward spiral after losing many leaders to the hell of war.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that leadership is the process of influencing people by providing purpose, direction, and motivation while operating to accomplish the mission and improve the organization.
- Explains that sfc gallagher was the original platoon sergeant of 1st platon, bravo company, 1-502nd infantry regiment. he was removed from that position to serve on the mitt.
- Opines that sfc gallagher's strength was his ability to say what he believed was the correct way to do something, and not just back down when higher leadership would say no.
- Opines that sfc gallagher should have remained the platoon sergeant of 1st platon. he was an engaged leader who instilled discipline and empathy in a non-traditional way.
- Explains how cpt goodwin, bravo company's commander, lost faith in sfc gallagher as the platoon sergeant of 1st
- Explains that sfc fenlason was viewed highly from his senior leaders due to the job he did in 2004 to 2005 as first sergeant of echo company, as well as being ranger qualified and a former drill sergeant.
- Analyzes how sfc fenlason's behavior allowed the soldiers of 1st platoon to become even more undisciplined. spc cortez, a soon-to-be sergeant, got intoxicated and beat up some local iraqis.
- Opines that the alamo was a concern of sfc gallagher and he fought to have that position manned by more personnel or covered differently.
- Opines that if they were sfc fenlason, they would have done some things differently, such as winning hearts and minds of mullah fayyad, but coordinate with the other platoons.
- Concludes that sfc gallagher would have been a better leader, at least for this deployment.
1446 wordsRead More - tanalytical essayBand of Brothers was a TV miniseries produced by Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks. This ten-part, eleven hour episodes captures the history of “Easy” Company (101st Airborne Division) from the beginning of their training at Camp Tocca, Georgia to their final battles in the front lines of Germany. The focus of these men from training to battle gives the audience a first hand experience of how these men were transformed into soldiers. Within the next couple of months these soldiers were then shipped out to the front lines where they experienced the horrors of war. It is particularly interesting to note that before every episode there are contemporary interviews of the actual men who partook in the battle and they would tell the audience what their experience was like. This would give a prelude to each episode; this would also authenticate every episode that it is being accurately portrayed. Major Richard Winters is the main character centralized in Band of Brothers, he is shown working with his men to accomplish the missions at hand while making sure each man remains safe. There are some other members of the supporting cast of soldiers who deal with life’s struggles of the war. “As the series is based on historic events, the fates of the characters conform to the persons they are drawn from. Numerous characters die or sustain serious wounds, some of which lead to survivors' being sent home; in other cases, soldiers recover under treatment in hospital and can rejoin their comrades on the front lines. Their experiences and the moral, mental, and physical hurdles they must overcome are central to the story.”
In this essay, the author
- Explains that band of brothers is a television miniseries produced by steven spielberg and tom hanks. the ten-part, eleven-hour episodes capture the history of "easy" company (101st airborne division).
- Analyzes how hollywood depicts world war ii films, and the different landscapes and environments that the soldiers have to adapt with.
- Analyzes how the movie u-571 gives the audience that claustrophobic environment where the only way to live is to defeat the enemy.
- Analyzes how hollywood has evolved from early war films of propaganda and how masculinity should reflect in battle. hollywood films today show the japanese side as being human.
689 wordsRead More - Goals and Visionopinion essayIf those placed in the position of leadership are acting as leaders, then they need to be follow-worthy and people must like them. If their employee workforces do not like the leaders in authority, they won’t listen to anything that they have to say or follow their example. This follows hand in hand with their people desiring to “choose a leader with lots of prestige” (Adams, S., 2011). It is important for leaders to set an example. When employees choose a leader with prestige they are saying that they want to follow in prestigious footsteps. Leaders must be all these things because their workfor...
In this essay, the author
- Opines that leaders must be the pinnacle of what their workforce would want to follow, accessible by the people while being above reproach at an attainable level.
- Opines that a leader needs to be both likeable and authoritarian on opposite sides of the spectrum. if they possess such qualities, people will follow them and shadow their inspirations, goals, and visions.
- Opines that leaders need to be follow-worthy and people must like them. if their workforces don't like the leaders in authority, they won’t listen to anything that they have to say or follow their example.
- Opines that workers who are under a good leader will desire and want to be victorious in their job categories or titles. they must be focused on and adhere to the group mindset and focus on unmeasured ambitions.
- Opines that leaders must set goals and objectives that are representative of the company and attainable to all those involved.
- Explains that goals and objectives are vital and important to the furtherance of any company. they are the fabric of the company’s aptitude for achievement.
- Explains that goals bring an adherence to the group mindset and make up the cohesion of group directive. they aspire and encourage people's creative nature.
- Opines that it's imperative that managers and those in charge of operations of a company achieve the best vision and goals for their employees and the company’s growth and development.
- Explains that vision in a company shows the goals for what the leaders or the leadership group wants or desires to see in the future. tasks are important to keep everyone motivated and on the right track.
840 wordsRead More - How to Overcome Leadership Challengesopinion essayOne very important aspect of a great leader is to lead by example. Any person in a position to guide others cannot ask the team to do one thing and act in the complete opposite way. This is a sure way to show that the leader has a need to show power and quickly loose respect from those who should be learning from him or her. Being a role model is importan...
In this essay, the author
- Explains that organizations face new and recurring issues every day. the outcome of the situation depends on many factors including the issue at hand, the management style, and the ethics of an organization.
- Opines that leadership styles and practices set the standard for every level of management within a company. poor leadership can affect employees, customers, shareholders, partnership companies, and supplier needs.
- Explains the importance of being a role model in an organization. leading by example shows the best way to be productive and profitable. attitude is additionally important.
- Opines that leaders must be willing to learn and be effective communicators, which is important in order to be thorough with employees on their expected job duties and listen when an employee needs guidance.
- Opines that any organization will not be successful if consumers are not satisfied. good communication habits are required to ensure customer satisfaction. word of mouth can make or break a company.
- Opines that feedback should be positive and not bring the team member down.
- Opines that leadership is a complicated thing to overcome and practice on daily basis. confidence is definitely required so that teamwork can be built.
- Opines that being open about expectations and communicating with the team is a great way to show that the leader is compassionate.
- Explains that leaders contribute to the direction of the company on many levels. without a solid leader, negative movement will definitely come about.
- Opines that a solid plan to meet the expected goals for the team is important, and that the leader should be responsible for this.
- Explains that a great team of employees knows how to work together and the duties are shared equally. it takes training and long-lasting employees to reach this goal.
- Opines that happy employees reflect the moral of the company, which is vital for profitability. satisfied employees want to advance within the organization they believe in.
- Opines that building trust will show respect and employees should feel trusted to complete their job duties successfully unless proven otherwise. incentives, benefits, retirement, and vacation time show that employees are appreciated and deserve time off.
- Opines that it is important to avoid micromanagement, but to ensure the leadership role is still being played out. nobody wants to be disliked.
- Opines that management is important to reach a goal instead of being everyone’s friend. building friendships must be avoided in order to gain respect in the workplace.
- Opines that micromanagement prevents trust and respect between employees and the supervisor, but it is important not to practice the opposite. no leadership or guidance will result in low productivity and little respect.
- Opines that being available to guide and manage your team should definitely be a priority. without giving support to the team, job duties will lack in certain areas and completion.
- Explains that employees are motivated by more than a promotion or pay increase. placing incentives within the team keeps everyone motivated. vacation days or increased benefits are great ways to show appreciation.
- Opines that finding the right candidate is crucial for any job. not just anyone can be great for a team.
- Opines that if the wrong person is placed in the position, the hiring process will simply need to be repeated.
- Opines that a manager lacks trust in the team members they are responsible for. instead of delegating responsibilities and job duties to employees, they complete the tasks themselves.
- Opines that putting pressure on yourself isn't okay and hurts productivity within the organization. being a supervisor is an accomplishment, but it can be hard to overcome.
- Opines that being open about your goals in successfully transitioning into this new role as everyone’s supervisor is a great way to get all worries and overcome them before they become problems.
- Explains that transitioning into this new position is an exciting time and can certainly be beneficial for the entire team. technology has helped overcoming these issues a lot easier.
- Opines that leadership in any organization is the key to success. communication, trust and respect are very important to have a successful team.
- Cites fields, c. and horsager, d. on recruiting really is the most important hr function.
- Cites mcnamara's report on business/careers/leadership-lab/six tips to communicate like a leader.
- Explains how technology is impacting leadership. realtime leadership. retrieved january 24, 2014.
- Explains tanveernaseer's article, "encouraging your employees to reach for the moon".
- Explains quast's 8 tips to transition from co-worker to manager.
- Cites richins, m., "negative word of mouth by dissatisfied consumers: a pilot story". american marketing association.
- Cites april shetrone's article, 7 ways to improve employee satisfaction, from http://www.inc.com/guides/201105/7-ways-to-improve-employee-satisf
2793 wordsRead More - Stanley Yelnatsanalytical essayRespect makes a good leader because when you have respect for others they like to give respect back you know treat people how you would like to be treated.
In this essay, the author
- Explains that respect makes a good leader because they treat others like they would like to be treated. stanley yelnats was the most important character in the book holes.
- Analyzes how stanley sees a boy named zero getting "bullied" and decides to help him. he told the bigger guys to stop and to leave him alone.
- Narrates how zero and stanley became friends after stanley was doing his over-the-summer project. stanley wanted to teach zero to read and write, and zero wanted zero to dig his wholes.
324 wordsRead More