Similarities Between If And To Kill A Mockingbird

694 Words2 Pages

It is often said that the phrase “human nature“ implies similarity, and indeed, most can relate to other’s experiences. Literature, as well as works of art, feature a few commonalities also. In my essay, I will be comparing the successful novel, “ To Kill A Mockingbird “, by Harper Lee and the poem, “ If “, by Rudyard Kipling. Both literary pieces deal with hatred, prejudice, and ignorance to the innocent. To start with, in “ To Kill A Mockingbird “, Scout Finch, an innocent child has no experience with the evils of the world. That is until her father, Atticus Finch, takes up the offer to defend Tom Robinson, a black man accused of the rape and beating of Mayella Ewell. The conflict is between white people, with Tom as …show more content…

When Tom appears in person for the very first time at the trial, everyone else gets to give their version of what happened before he even has a chance to speak. At the trial, there are two very different versions of Tom’s relationship with Mayella. Mayella and her father tell the story that everyone would like to hear, about how Tom is this wicked beast who acts out of animalistic lust. The town just assumes that any African American man would rape a white woman, given the chance. However, Tom presents himself as a good guy who was literally just trying to help out a fellow lady in need. He states the only feelings he has for Mayella are compassion and pity, but neither of those are accepted by the town. Which story is the jury going to believe—the bias one about a black man raping a white woman or a disturbing one about a black man pitying a white woman. The answer is obvious. But does the jury believe Mayella’s story despite all of the factual evidence proving the Ewell’s wrong, or are they afraid to say otherwise. After the guilty verdict ignores Tom’s version in favor of the Ewell’s, Tom loses hope. Although Atticus promises him an appeal, all …show more content…

In disbelief of Atticus’s words, Tom attempts to escape, only to be shot down by guards in broad daylight resulting in the death of Tom. When it comes to the poem, “If “, Kipling said that, in writing the poem, he was inspired by the military actions of Leander Starr Jameson, leader of the failed Jameson Raid against the Transvaal Republic to overthrow the Boer Government of Paul Kruger. The theme is very similar to “ To Kill A Mockingbird “, dealing with the ability to still trust in yourself when all men doubt you. However, in “TKAM”, Tom failed at that and preferred to take his own chance. For example, the poem states,” If you can wait and not be tired by waiting, or being lied about, don't deal in lies, or being hated, don't give way to hating -- yours is the Earth and everything that's in it.” From my point of view, I believe Kipling purpose for those lines is to inspire the reader and give a guide through life. Kipling took you on his journey, which many of us go through, but he let you know you can win, you can survive whatever and everything you put your mind to. Adversity can be conquered. The two literary pieces both have very similar symbolic weights. In “TKAM”, the title represents the idea

Open Document