Pearl Harbor Thesis

714 Words2 Pages

PEARL HARBOR: AN INVITATION TO WAR
I. INTRODUCTION- On December 7, 1941, to the astonishment of the United States, the Navy fleet at Pearl Harbor unceremoniously attacked resulting in the immediate involvement of the United States into WWII. Although the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor was unexpected and unprovoked, it is a direct result of multiple failures in military policies and procedures. Early warning signs of a pending attack would have decreased the causalities and limited the overall collateral damage at Pearl Harbor.
A. Key points
1. Under estimation and overconfidence, lead the United States to misinterpret the Japanese striking capabilities.
2. Due to the overwhelming surprise of the attack at Pearl Harbor, the United States …show more content…

BODY-
A. The United States thought the Japanese to be inferior war fighters lacking aggressiveness and the ability to adapt to military challenges.
1. United States thought the Japanese pilot training was inferior and that they lacked the proper skill to execute a coordinated attack.
2. The U.S Navy thought the depth of water at Pearl Harbor was too shallow for effective torpedo attacks from the air.
B. The quick and decisive nature in which the Japanese attacked was so initially devastating that the U.S. forces on Oahu suffered catastrophic losses denying them the ability to effectively fight off a well-executed and coordinated Japanese attack.
1. United States overestimated its ability to properly defend Hawaii from possible attacks.
2. Swift and surprising attacks by the Japanese quickly devastated and disorientated forces on Oahu.
C. The military services on Oahu were not postured properly to thwart off a large-scale attack by a sizable Japanese military …show more content…

While docking ships force at Pearl Harbor was a good practice in order to increase supply, fueling, and ammunition restocking efficiency, it was not an optimal docking procedure in a high alert situation.
D. A culmination of many individual events throughout the early morning of December 7, 1941 should have raised red flags and caused reason for concern of an impending attack.
1. Personnel of the minesweeper Condor spot a periscope in the water while patrolling off the entrance to Pearl Harbor.
2. The destroyer Ward fires first shot at the sub, misses, fires second shot and hits. The submarine appears to be slowly sinking so the captain of the destroyer orders depth charges dropped.
3. Oahu radar station operator sights 50 or more aircraft bearing down on Oahu and misinterprets it as scheduled friendly aircraft incoming.
4. President Roosevelt and General Marshall learn from a decoded
Japanese message that the two Japanese negotiators receive a message ordering them to cease negotiations. Believing this may mean war, they notify the commander of the U.S. Army forces in Hawaii.
III. SUMMARY- Although a total repel of a Japanese force so large would have been impossible, the United States hubris attitude toward the Japanese left them vulnerable and poised for an attack of such devastating

Open Document