Durkheim's Success in Using the Scientific Method

1318 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Sociological perspective theory of suicide

Durkheim's Success in Using the Scientific Method

In this essay I will discuss some of the approaches to the study of

suicide and its social causes described by Durkheim. I will then

present a few alternative theories or critiques of Durkheim; and

finally conclude with a Personal reflection on Durkheim`s analysis.

Durkheim believed that society is a part of nature, and a science of

society has to be based upon the same logical principles as those

which obtain in natural science. Therefore Durkheim set out to prove

that sociology was a science by applying his theory to the study of

suicide.

The study of suicide is seen as particularly important because it

illustrates the wider theoretical and methodological debates in

sociology. The study of suicide, by Durkheim was based on using

statistics from several countries and looked for causes of suicide.

This illustrates the positive approach. Later studies such as those by

Atkinson and Douglas use interpretative and phenomenological

approaches, which question the value of statistics and the idea of

causes and try instead to understand how meanings are attached to

actions.

The positivist approach in sociology is based on using the methodology

of the natural sciences as far as possible. This was part of an

attempt to establish sociology as an important academic discipline,

since science was seen as the highest form of knowledge. Durkheim

wanted to counter the then current explanations of suicide, which were

usually based on individuals, by showing that suicide could be

explained at the level of society; he wanted to show that one of the

most individual acts a person could perform...

... middle of paper ...

...bias. This view could be taken because Durkheim

himself was a Catholic when he was discussing the role of values and

morality within Catholicism as being superior. On the other hand

Durkheim’s approach has been useful in that other sociologists can

learn from his methodology and the drawbacks in it.

Bibliography

Atkinson, J.M. “Discovering Suicide” – London Macmillan, (1978)

Bilton, T et al “Introductory Sociology” Macmillan (1981)

Durkheim, Emile (1858-1917). Suicide: a study in sociology London:

Routledge & K

Gibbs, Jack P., & Walter T. Martin. “Status integration and suicide;

a sociological study”

University of Oregon Books, (1964)

Luke’s, S “Emile Durkheim” - Penguin Press (1973)

O’Donnell, M “A New Introductory to Sociology” Nelson (1992)

Show More
Related

  • Durkheimian Theories Applied to Buffalo Creek

    1934 Words  | 4 Pages

    In Durkheim’s concept of social/moral regulation, society imposes limits on humans to regulate their passions, desires, expectations, ambitions and roles. When these limits or social regulations break down, the controlling authority the society once had no longer functions and people are left on their own to make their own plans. In societies that have low levels of social regulations, a state of Anomie, or normlessness, can occur and affect the whole society or just some of its groups. Anomic suicide was more prevalent in this type of society. Anomic suicide basically involve...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Daniel Boorstin's The Discoverers

    1458 Words  | 3 Pages

    The word “bias” has always had a negative connotation. Although it is used synonymously with bigotry and prejudice, its meaning is actually more akin to “point of view,” “personal tendency,” or “preference.” Just as every individual has her own worldview, so she has a set of biases. These biases are often observable in a person’s habits, speech, and, perhaps most explicitly, writings. Daniel Boorstin, renowned University of Chicago professor, historian, author, and librarian of Congress, is undeniably biased towards certain cultures in The Discoverers. A book chronicling mankind’s scientific history, its first words are “My hero is Man the Discoverer.” In his telling of “man’s search to know his world and himself,” Boorstin declares that

    Read More

  • Scientific Revolution Dbq Essay

    540 Words  | 2 Pages

    The scientific revolution was what introduced the way we think based on experimentation, observation and how we apply reasoning to the things we do scientifically. During the scientific revooution this way of thinking brought forward new kinds of thinkers otherwise know as enlgihtentment thinkers. These enlightenment thinkers brought there ideas forward, which helped lead the strive for there independence . this is what led to the beginning of the scientific revolution. The scientific revolution began around the mid 1700s and went all the way through the mid 1800s theses revolutions did not only stay in one place, this was happening globally in Europe, the americans and through out the latin American colonies. You might ask yourself what did they these revolutions have in common ? they all became infulanced by one another and was infinced by the enlightenment thinkers.

    Read More

  • Sociology As A Life Or Death Issue By Robert J. Brym

    1245 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the text “Sociology as a Life or Death Issue”, University of Toronto sociology professor Robert J. Brym, explains death in the means of how sociology presents it. Brym presents three different situations in which sociology explains the reasoning for death, including homicide, suicide, and fatality from natural disaster. Throughout the book, Brym shows how death is present in any certain aspect of life and he does it in a presentable and applicable way.

    Read More

  • A Bully Film Review

    1064 Words  | 3 Pages

    Durkheim was concerned with studying and observing the ways in which society functioned. His work began with the idea of the collective conscious, which are the general emotions and opinions that are shared by a society and which shape likeminded ideas as to how the society will operate (Desfor Edles and Appelrouth 2010:100-01). Durkheim thus suggested that the collective ideas shared by a community are what keeps injustices from continuing or what allows them to remain.

    Read More

  • Sociological Approach To Suicide

    1440 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the recent years, South Koreans have coined the word, “Republic of Suicide” to refer to South Korea as a nation of unfortunately high suicide rates. Unsurprisingly, South Koreans in all ages have significantly higher suicide rates compared to people of the majority of the other nations in the world today. Regarding various personal and psychological factors as secondary factors, this paper relies on the sociological arguments discussed by Emile Durkheim in his celebrated work, Suicide, to explain suicide as a social phenomenon. Drawing from Durkheim’s explanations of suicide in relations to social integration and regulation, this paper attempts to expound on the general trends of high

    Read More

  • Durkheim Suicide Summary

    523 Words  | 2 Pages

    When Durkheim conducted his research on suicide he did it with the intention of establishing Sociology as a science and as a result almost validate the worth and power of sociology. Before Durkheim’s study, suicide was considered only as the act of an individual however Durkheim’s theory was that suicide tied in with social structures and even though he believed that suicide is ‘the most personal act anyone can undertake’ (Durkheim, 1897), he also believed it was accredited to social causes.

    Read More

  • What Is The Conflict Theory In Sociology

    760 Words  | 2 Pages

    13. Emile Durkheim- Durkheim was the creator of the theory of suicide. This Theory has four forms egoistic, aluturistic, anomic and, fatalistic. This theory led to the understanding of suicide and how we can prevent such actions.

    Read More

  • How Did Durkheim Commit Suicide

    565 Words  | 2 Pages

    Durkheim (1951) explains, “suicide is applied to any death which is direct or indirect results of a positive or negative acts accomplished by the victim himself…” (42). Suicide is a solidarity act; the cause has a significant connection to various social factors. Durkheim was trying to find a relationship between social interactions amongst individuals and suicide rates in different countries around Europe. “Since suicide in an individual action affecting the individual only, it must seemingly depend exclusively on individual factors, thus belonging to psychology alone” (Durkheim:46). What Durkheim is saying that suicide doesn’t come from within the individual but rather the influence of other factors on the individual. He compares different social factors that would potentially per sway an individual to commit suicide, like religion, domestic factors in a country, and political hardship.

    Read More

  • Emile Durkheim Suicide

    1280 Words  | 3 Pages

    As Durkheim puts it “we may offer society everything social in us, and still unable to control our desires; one may live in an anomic state without being egoistic and vice versa” (Durkheim 111). From previous readings it is clear Durkheim’s views, were centered within the economic sector, which in his opinion is where the most visible social sphere in which anomic imbalances could be found. He witnessed and examined the correlation between economic changes and levels of suicide, he was able to show how disruptions or changes in the economy push one to commit suicide. The disequilibrium brought on by rapid societal changes caused people to commit suicide more frequently. Aside from economic changes, as society continues for modernization, there is also a change in the family structure, another potential source of anomie. Divorce brought about a state of disequilibrium, because it interrupted the regulative functions of marriage, the regulation of

    Read More

  • Durkheim's Hypothesis Analysis

    386 Words  | 1 Pages

    Durkheim's hypothesis perceives that people are social creatures whose lives are tremendously molded by the way of their social connections. Despite the fact that Durkheim's work centered around macrolevel impacts on suicide, the hypothesis hypothesizes that powerless connections to societal organizations result in lower psychosocial prosperity, and more grounded join ments and shared qualities and objectives among mem-bers of a social gathering, got from the amount and force of their association, encourage prosperity (Durkheim, 1951; Thorlindsson and Bjarnason, 1998).

    Read More

  • Douglas On Homicide And Suicide

    1814 Words  | 4 Pages

    If homicide and suicide are analyzed through a Douglas point of view, it can be said that both of these violent actions are meaningful communicative acts. In the case of suicide Douglas makes the claim the suicide says something fundamental about a person, it says what kind of person they were. Douglas (1967) suggests that there are different meanings attached to suicides, for instance dying of suicide can provide the individual with the possibility of transforming the substantial self of the actor (284-5). This suggests a transformation, in other words, suicide can be a way to escape their realities and seek a different world. In general, Douglas claims that there are different meanings and motives behind every suicide, and the factors that can motivate an individual to do so, come from social and cultural context

    Read More

  • Mistakes In Praise Of Careful Science

    394 Words  | 1 Pages

    I believe that mistakes are absolutely not necessary to making discoveries. I believe this for a very good reason. If someone were to discover a cure for cancer, they could work on that cure and get closer and closer to the cure without making a mistake. They might have to put a tremendous amount of work into the cure, but that doesn’t mean they need to make a mistake. In Praise of Careful Science it says, “Most of the time, scientists work for decades and make very few mistakes.” Do honestly think that the scientists did not discover anything in those decades.

    Read More

  • Interpretations Of Suicide

    946 Words  | 2 Pages

    The concept of the male suicide was mentioned as an “easy way out”, but at the same time was still considered to require “strength”. This oxymoron was a major focus for the authors as they tried to make sense of those conflicting notions. They speculated that Western culture has concluded that the male suicide is a ‘lashing out’ towards external pressures like economic status and relationship status. One participant ‘Rob’ stated that men would rather kill themselves than suffer the shame of asking for help. The authors linked this to the concept of ‘honour’ (they are British), where a man who talks about his feelings and seeks help is ‘weak’ and a ‘failure’ when men must be ‘strong’ and ‘successful’. An additional effect of this hyper-aversion to expression and vulnerability is that if a man attempts suicide and lives through it, they are treated with less sympathy than a woman in the same scenario. Men were also expected by participants to be more impulsive and decisive and therefore more likely to commit suicide after a short amount of time and with low rate of

    Read More

  • The Amateur Scientist

    763 Words  | 2 Pages

    I was on my way to work, when I started to read this interesting story and I don't deny that I was a little sceptical in the beginning. But the more I read, the more I wanted to know about this man and his unique ways to define Science. I finished reading it in about 15 minutes, it literally sucked me in.

    Read More

More about Durkheim's Success in Using the Scientific Method

Open Document