Compare And Contrast Rogerian Therapy To Rational Cognitive Therapy

977 Words2 Pages

A Compare-Contrast Analysis: Rogerian Therapy to Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy
Barton, A. (1974). Three worlds of therapy: An existential-phenomenological study of the therapies of freud, jung, and rogers ([1st ed. ed.). Palo Alto, Calif: National Press Books.

A. Background: not available for this source
B. Underlying assumptions: humans are motivated by self-fulfillment and move in a positive and goal-oriented direction. Needs are partially factored in, such as hunger and sex.
C. Views of human development and maladaptive behavior: Not much is given in this source on theory of personality, other than saying that the stages of development are not described in great detail in person-centered therapy. Maladaptive behavior arises when certain …show more content…

Process of therapy: A distressed client comes to therapy for guidance from the therapist. There is an emphasis on focusing on the client as acceptance of the client to make the therapeutic relationship a strong one.
G. Evaluative research on treatment outcomes: not available for this source
H. Issues of individual and cultural diversity: different therapists may be more sensitive to certain aspects of their client’s conditions of worth (different values between client and therapist). Coming from different cultures can affect created conditions of worth for both.
I. Scholarly pros and cons: the becoming of a growth oriented and real self under positive regard. Others see this as relying on feelings too much.
J. Student opinion: the comparison between Freud, Jung, and Rogers proved to be interesting in that the theories are all drastically in their own ways. I felt that it specifically summed up PCT pretty well, however left out seemed to up-talk it instead of suggesting possible fallacies of the theory as much.
Binder, V., Binder, A., & Rimland, B. (1976). Modern therapies (A spectrum book, s-397). Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.

A. Background: not available for this …show more content…

Process of therapy: not available for this source
G. Evaluative research on treatment outcomes: not available for this source
H. Issues of individual and cultural diversity: not available for this source
I. Scholarly pros and cons: help clients get better and not just feel better
J. Student opinion: this source provided basic information of REBT and then provided a case study that I found to be very helpful. The dialogue helped to give an example of how questioning works as well as how it guides the client to rethink faulty beliefs.
Burton, A. (1959). Case studies in counseling and psychotherapy (Prentice-Hall psychology series). Englewood Cliffs, N.J: Prentice-Hall.

A. Background: not available for this source
B. Underlying assumptions: not available for this source
C. Views of human development and maladaptive behavior: false conditions of worth are noted in the two provided case examples in the form of interviews.
D. Assessment methods: the interviews show that there is not much assessment in PCT; the client just begins where they want to begin. Both clients in both cases told the therapist what the general problem was, instead of the therapist telling the

Open Document