Clausewitz and Strategy in The Civil War Essay

Clausewitz and Strategy in The Civil War Essay

Length: 1077 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Throughout history there have been few military theorists who have influenced military thinking. The military revolution that occurred during the American Civil War changed the face of warfare. The theories of both Antione-Henri Jomini and Carl von Clausewitz, the two most prominent military theorists of the 19th Century, can be seen in many aspects of the conflict. While Jomini’s tactics played a large role on the battlefield, the strategic concepts of Carl Von Clausewitz best characterize the nature of the Civil War. The writings of Clausewitz proved prophetic in three distinct areas: the strength of the defense over the offense, the concept of “Total War” used by General Grant, and the theory of war as an extension of policy.
The first area where Clausewitz better characterized the nature of the Civil War was in how he viewed the strength of offense in relation to defense. There is little doubt that the Civil War proved Clausewitz’s assertion that the defense is the stronger form of war.
Jomini advocated that the “offensive was almost always advantageous.” I believe this is due to his experience with, and admiration of, Napoleonic-era tactics and weapons. Clausewitz viewed the opposite and stated in his writings that the terrain gave the defender a decided advantage.
There were many advances in weaponry, such as rifled muskets, during the Civil War. The increased accuracy and range made repeatedly attacking an enemy using Napoleonic tactics very difficult. Combatants slugged it out at an average of 116 yards; only slightly longer than the 80-100 yards usually seen with smoothbore muskets and half the range these rifles were capable of. Casualties were especially heavy at the 1863 Battles of Shiloh and Antietam. ...


... middle of paper ...


...
MINIE BALL. http://www.history.com/topics/american-civil-war/minie-ball (accessed May 2, 2014).
Murray, Wiliamson. "The Industrialization of War." In The Cambridge History of Warfare, edited by Geoffrey Parker, 227. New York, New York: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Rean, Daniel. Shifting Strategies: Military Theory in the American Civil War. March 16, 2008. http://www.militaryhistoryonline.com/civilwar/articles/militarytheory.aspx (accessed March 30, 2014).
Shy, John. "Jomini." In Makers of Modern Strategy: from Machiavelli to the Nuclear Age, edited by Peter Paret. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1986.
Thompson, Robert. Battle of Cold Harbor: The Folley and Horror. October 26, 2006. http://www.historynet.com/cold-harbor (accessed May 1, 2014).
Trench Warfare at Petersburg. http://www.pbs.org/civilwar/war/map19.html (accessed April 30, 2014).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Nature of War: Clausewitz Essay

- ... Historically, the United States has most often engaged in irregular wars since its conception. Robert Scaife’s article in the Small Wars Journal discusses the few instances the US military has faced regular wars when stating that, “During the 20th Century, the United States arguably engaged in Peer on Peer battle four times over the 100-year period: World War I, World War II, the Korean War, and the first Gulf War.” The historical trend toward irregular wars is not unique to the US as Phil Reynolds describes in a 2012 article that states around the globe, “Since World War II, there have been 44 interstate wars and 372 asymmetric conflicts.” Therefore, the most likely threat the US will...   [tags: Conflicts, wars, army forces]

Strong Essays
1385 words (4 pages)

Essay on Carl Von Clausewitz

- Question 6: Clausewitz wrote “in war the result is never final.” Under what conditions and through what actions can belligerents make their victory more permanent. Carl Von Clausewitz theorized that “in war the result is never final” and that “the defeated state often considers the outcome as a transitory evil…” (Clausewitz, 80) There are many examples that support his theory that defeated belligerents will wait for another opportunity to achieve their objectives. There are also examples of belligerents who, under certain conditions and through deliberate actions, made their victory more permanent....   [tags: History, War, Victory]

Strong Essays
2228 words (6.4 pages)

Essay on The American Civil War By Robert G. Tanner

- When one thinks about the American Civil War (1861-1864), the question at hand begs questioning: what could the Confederacy have done to win the war. Ideally, according to Robert G. Tanner in his book Retreat to Victory. the idea that the south might have won had it used a different strategy might be impossible to answer. That being said, Tanner argues amongst many theories which have developed over what the Confederacy could have done to win the Civil War, the strategy commonly referred to as Fabian would not be a prosperous endeavor for the Confederacy due to the southern geography, people and through the Confederacy’s generals....   [tags: Confederate States of America, American Civil War]

Strong Essays
1057 words (3 pages)

Clausewitz's "On War": Useful Insights for Twenty-First Century Warfare Essay

- Amongst military theorists and practitioners who studied war, its origin and implications, Carl von Clausewitz assumes a place among the most prominent figures. With his book On War, he demonstrated his capability to provide thorough historical analysis of the conflicts he experienced, and as a philosopher he reflected on war itself. Today, Western armies conduct warfare in a dynamic environment composed of multiple threats in which civilians form a substantial part. Studying Clausewitz provides current military and political leadership useful insights to understand twenty-first century warfare....   [tags: Military Science]

Strong Essays
1394 words (4 pages)

Essay about The Civil War Unfolded And How The South

- Many historians have studied the way the Civil War unfolded and how the south could have possibly won if the southern generals executed Fabian warfare. This war technique has the offensive army retreating deeper and deeper into their territory, thus causing the defensive army to have longer supply lines and exhaustion sweep the soldiers. Although this is a major topic of discussion, Robert Tanner does not agree with the notion the Confederate nation could have won using this tactic. This is because the southern population did not have a unifying reason war was erupting, nor did the southern army have generals who took advantage of union troops when they showed weakness, and the confederate...   [tags: Confederate States of America]

Strong Essays
1013 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Terrorism as a Strategy

- INTRODUCTION Terrorism is one of the major ways to carry out violence either to prove a point or just to cause harm. Since 9/11, terrorism has been on the increase and the lack of a firm definition does not help solve the issue. To understand the ultimate purpose of terrorism, this essay will be looking at the concept of terrorism and why violence has to be used to prove a point in a state. It will also be looking at how many states are able to maintain their stand after a terrorist attack (using US and 9/11 as an example) as well as the destabilization it has caused in the state....   [tags: using violence to prove a point]

Strong Essays
782 words (2.2 pages)

How The Above Elements Affect The Outcome Of War Essay

- Throughout history, wars have not always been a linear or predictable process. When looking at current international events, it appears that Israel is having a difficult time defeating Hamas in Gaza Strip. The United States –the world’s main power– is also struggling to find a successful exit solution from both Iraq and Afghanistan. These examples provide evidence that a perceived superior power must not assume they have the ability to win a war, even against a perceived weaker power. Powerful states do not always defeat weaker powers due to the influence of a myriad of factors which either promote or inhibit winning....   [tags: United States, World War II, Iraq War]

Strong Essays
1701 words (4.9 pages)

War After Napoleon to World War Two Essay

- WAR AFTER NAPOLEON TO WORLD WAR II After the defeat of Napoleon and the French Empire, the world looked favorably upon options for peace. The greatest sea power of the time was Britain, and with the goal of controlling the free trade, the island country looked to make the waters more advantageous. The British government realized that a countries wealth was not going to be possessed by an expanding empire, but by the profitable growth of commercial trade. The oceans were looked at as a boulevard to other markets for supplies and for sales....   [tags: WWII World War 2 Essays]

Free Essays
1673 words (4.8 pages)

On War by Clausewitz Essay

- One of the most studied military strategist or theorist is Clausewitz. His work, “On War” has stood the test of time, used widely to analyze and study conflicts in the twenty-first century. “War is a continuation of `policy'—or of `politics'—by other means" (Bassford, pg 199), the most famous Clausewitz quote, often used to justify conflict but to the contrary, most often misapplied during conflict. “On War” is written as if war is an art, however, Clausewitz does offer guidance on tactics and military objectives, which by description, war is a science too....   [tags: communism, vietnam war]

Strong Essays
1720 words (4.9 pages)

Essay about Clausewitz

- Clausewitz Clausewitz advocates attacking enemy “schwerpunkt” or centers of gravity. How does this compare with Sun Tzu’s prioritization for attacking important elements of national power. Which theorist provides the most useful guidance for determining the object of a strategy or strategies. Introduction Clausewitz’s attack of enemy centers of gravity and Sun Tzu’s prioritization of attack of important elements of national power provide contrasting approaches to the development of effective strategy....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1173 words (3.4 pages)