Essay on The Case Of Twin Brothers Dale And Mike, A Failed Suicide Pact

Essay on The Case Of Twin Brothers Dale And Mike, A Failed Suicide Pact

Length: 746 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In order to uphold the ideal of protecting and preserving the rights and liberties of American citizens, our criminal justice system was created to bring justice to those whom a wrongdoing has been committed against. Justice is rooted in protecting those rights and determining a punishment that is fair and appropriate based on the circumstances of the crime. In the case of twin brothers Dale and Mike, a failed suicide pact resulted in Dale panicking and shooting his brother killing him instantly. I will be determining whether justice has been served, the appropriate charges as a prosecutor, and the applicable sentence Dale should serve based on his crime.

Justice is defined as protecting natural and legal rights and punishing wrong using fairness (Hill, G. & Hill, K., n.d.). Our learning materials define justice as the “principal of moral rightness, or conformity of the truth ” (Schmalleger, F., 2013). I agree with the formal definition, but would likely add punishing wrong using fairness that is variable based on the mitigating or aggravating circumstances. In the case of Dale and Mike, justice was served in the sense that it is unlawful to harm or murder another.
In Illinois, voluntary manslaughter was redefined on July 1, 1987 to 2nd-degree murder, though it is still regarded as manslaughter (Haddad, J., 1988). In the case of Dale, he would likely be charged with second-degree murder, which carries a sentence from four to twenty years in prison. The elements are the same as determining first-degree murder, except the defendant would need to prove that mitigating circumstances that led to the death of Mike. It is evident the first element of murder can be proven, which is Dale did commit an unlawful killing of a human ...


... middle of paper ...


...ther human being, whether unintentionally or intentionally with or without malice or malice aforethought, is still a grievous crime. But our system of justice wants to ensure that the punishment fits the crime. Therefore, in the case of a death of a human being, elements or components must be met to determine whether there is malice, malice aforethought, or absence of malice. In addition, it examines the mitigating or aggravating circumstances that resulted in the death of another human being. I feel in the case of Dale and Mike that Dale’s intense emotions caused him to act in an irrational behavior. He loved his brother, there was no malice, nor was Dale a depraved individual. Therefore, I feel the charges of premeditated, 1st-degree manslaughter (2nd-degree murder in IL) was fair and appropriate, but did feel he could serve his time a minimum-security prison.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Pact Essay

- The Pact Some of the things that Rameck, Sam, and George, the three boys in The Pact, were tempted with have occurred with my friend named Paul. Things such as temptations involving drugs, family issues, and the ways of life of the family. Paul's parents both dealt and did drugs, this made it hard for Paul to deviate from this kind of life. As time progressed he soon picked up the “family business” and started heading down the wrong path in life. These temptations to follow in the path of Paul's parents footsteps were very much the same as the temptation in which George, Rameck, and Sam had, which were the constant pressure from society and family....   [tags: Pact Essays]

Better Essays
623 words (1.8 pages)

The Pact Essay

- The Pact With Teacher Comments To say that I have a personal connection with any of the authors of “The Pact” (Books should be underlined or in italics, but not in quotatations) would be a stretch at best. From the time before my very first breath, my life has been completely different. Throughout the years, my life further diverged, until you examine our (maybe use “my” instead of “our” – makes the connection to yourself) college years. Despite the differences, many similarities can be found just by taking a look at events, rather than situations....   [tags: Pact Essays]

Better Essays
1322 words (3.8 pages)

Richard Posner 's Not A Suicide Pact Essay

- Richard Posner published a book Not a Suicide pact: The Constitution in a Time of National Emergency in 2006. In this book, he argued that the U.S. government would batter to adjust the balance of civil liberties and national security though he knew it is hard. And U.S. government used to give weight to national security excessively in my opinion. I think, however, the U.S. government has to protect civil liberties no matter what happen. Since the Posner’s book was published approximately nine years ago, he would conclude protection of American civil liberties is more important at this moment....   [tags: George W. Bush, United States Constitution]

Better Essays
1150 words (3.3 pages)

Lisa Frazier's The Pact Essay

- Lisa Frazier's The Pact My father's family lived in New Jersey when my dad and his three brothers were just blooming adolescents. Their parents were the product of the cocktail generation, and the Irish tendency towards alcoholism was augmented by that social niche. Despite the arguments and drinking, Mary and Jack wanted to make sure their children got the best possible education. The boys were sent to Catholic schools, and once they graduated were forcefully directed down a collegiate path....   [tags: Lisa Frazier The Pact]

Free Essays
1378 words (3.9 pages)

Essay about The Pact

- The Pact The novel The Pact which was read over the summer by Penn State students was considered interesting to some and dull to others. I personally enjoyed the book since I could relate to the book in more ways than one. The story takes pace in an inner city setting with three young men who become doctors and plan to give back to the community in any way they possibly can. The three young men are known as Sam, George and Rameck. Each of these characters posses a different personality which contributes to the book as a whole....   [tags: Pact Essays]

Better Essays
1746 words (5 pages)

Essay on The Pact

- The Pact There is not much that separates our kind from lower species of life. Our intellect, communication skills and opposable thumbs are a few of the many advantages to being a human. Human’s ability to construct a deep and rewarding lifelong friendship is no less incredible than any of the previously mentioned traits. These friendships are an integral part of our lives each and everyday, and friendships that last can certainly help lead to ones success later on in life. I have had many very close friends in my life and they all have helped me in their own way....   [tags: Friendships The Pact Essays]

Better Essays
914 words (2.6 pages)

The Pact Essay example

- The Pact Assignment I found it difficult to relate with the book, The Pact, for near the first half of the story. The three boys, Rameck, Sam, and George all grew up in impoverished neighborhoods in New Jersey. They were surrounded by drugs, violence, theft, prejudice, and death. None of the 3 had a father figure within their home while growing up and discovered that it was extremely difficult to find any positive role models within their area. As kids, Sam and Rameck both caved under the peer pressure and became entangled in immoral activity....   [tags: Pact Analysis Essays]

Better Essays
2240 words (6.4 pages)

Lives on the Boundary by Mike Rose Essay

- Lives on the Boundary by Mike Rose The book Lives on the Boundary, written by Mike Rose, provides great insight to what the new teaching professional may anticipate in the classroom. This book may be used to inform a teacher’s philosophy and may render the teacher more effective. Lives on the Boundary is a first person account composed of eight chapters each of which treat a different obstacle faced by Mike Rose in his years as a student and as an educator. More specifically in chapters one through five Mike Rose focuses on his own personal struggles and achievements as a student....   [tags: Education Boundary Mike Rose Essays]

Better Essays
1216 words (3.5 pages)

Friendship in The Pact Essays

- Friendship in The Pact Friendship is a huge part of everyone's life, whether they know it or not. In some way shape or form everyone needs relationships. In the book The Pact, friendship is huge. Three boys George, Sam, and Rameck become best friends and you could say that they save each others lives. Not physically but in a sense that without the pact they made there lives might not be where they are today. I can relate this book to a very good friend of mine that got caught up in a bad situation....   [tags: The Pact Relationships Essays]

Free Essays
826 words (2.4 pages)

Friendship in The Pact Essay

- Friendship in The Pact Works Cited Missing Friendship can lift you up, strengthen and empower you, or break you down, weaken and defeat you” (32). In The Pact, George, Rameck, and Sam lifted each other through the hard times. They helped each other reach their dreams, even though they had their rough times. George, Rameck, and Sam all lived troubled lives while growing up. They all suffered with financial problems, and judicial problems. Their friendship helped them succeed and eventually gave them a more stable live style....   [tags: Personal Narrative Pact College Friends Essays]

Free Essays
981 words (2.8 pages)