Essay about Thomas Rid’s Arguement on the Impossibility of Cyber War

Essay about Thomas Rid’s Arguement on the Impossibility of Cyber War

Length: 851 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the article, Thomas Rid’s main argument other than the contention that cyber war will not happen is that cyber war is completely misplaced if not entirely misunderstood. He argues that the concept of cyber war is not in tandem with the historical definition and understanding of what constitutes ‘’war’’. Rid’s definition of war, borrowed from Carl von Clausewitz, is that war must constitute three elements: violence, instrumental and political. (Rid, Cyber War Will Not Take Place, 2012) Therefore, his main argument against the possibility for cyber war is premised on the idea that cyber war can never have or express the above three elements. He further argues that at best, cyber war can achieve some of the above criteria such as violence but only through intermediaries; however, he does not see how cyber war can meet all the three criteria.
To provide evidence for his argument, Rid first establishes the meaning of war based on history after which he thoroughly examines contemporary events that have been largely referred to as embodiments of cyber warfare. For example, he cites the cases of Georgia, Estonia and Siberian pipeline explosions as incidences that have been considered cyber war. (Rid, Cyber War Will Not Take Place, 2012) However, he goes on to analyze each case as to whether they embody any of the three elements that define war. For instance, in the case of Georgia he argues that despite the war rhetoric by the international press, there was no actual violence that could be directly linked to the cyber-attack itself. In addition, there was not political attribution as no one accepted responsibility and no one was conclusively adjudged responsible. (Rid, Cyber War Will Not Take Place, 2012) He therefore concludes that ...


... middle of paper ...


...nfluence while for Israel it would be to ensure their internal security. As the Chinese economy attempts to catch up with the US economy, they are under increasing pressure to bolster the technological capability of Chinese enterprises resulting in increased espionage activities. On the other hand, the US attempts to sustain its economic and military power and espionage will play a critical role. The U.S. has virtually limitless resources in advancing their cyber capabilities, both to protect economic interests and domestic security. In the case of Israel, their geopolitical positions necessitated the need to use any means possible to ensure their national security and espionage and sabotage will continue to play a critical role in threat. Israel’s cyber capability has been refined to become one of the most effective counter-intelligence programs in the world.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Thomas Jefferson And The Civil War Essay

- Thomas Jefferson Thomas Jefferson was born on April 13,1743 in Shadwell, Virginia. He was born into a family that had status, wealth, and tradition of public service. Jefferson was the third child in the family and grew up with six sisters and one brother. Thomas Jefferson was well educated; he attended private schools and at the age of seventeen he attended the College of William and Mary. Thomas Jefferson was interested in being a scientist, after learning that there was no opportunity for a career in science in Virginia he then studied law....   [tags: Thomas Jefferson]

Better Essays
909 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Cyber Security as an International Security Threat

- Cyber Security as an International Security Threat National and International Security is a sum of the actions taken by countries and other organizations that can guarantee the safety and well being of their population. It is vital for a nation to pre-emptively discover what issues could affect their security, and take action to prevent any detrimental or harmful events from happening. With the development of technology and the transition into a more technologically savvy society, cyber security has become one of the most prevalent and important economic and national security issues that the United States will come to face....   [tags: cyber terrorists, cyberspace]

Better Essays
2186 words (6.2 pages)

Military Cyber: An Evolution In Command Relationships Essay

- United States Cyber Command is less than four years old. The merger and stand down of the Joint Functional Component Command for Network Warfare (JFCC-NW) and the Joint task Force for Global Network Operations (JTF-GNO) formed the bulk of the new organization. 9 This new construct integrated offensive and defensive cyber capabilities in one organization resulting in efficient and effective planning and execution of cyberspace operations. United States Cyber Command is tasked with operations to defend DOD information networks and to conduct full spectrum military cyberspace operations across all domains....   [tags: United States, Cyber Command]

Better Essays
1417 words (4 pages)

Essay about Cyber Warfare : The New Frontier

- Andrew Massung Mr. Wyse ENC 1101 15 October 2015 Cyber Warfare: the New Frontier Since the beginning of time, mankind has waged war against each other. Over the years warfare has evolved, from fighting with sticks and stones to using gunpowder and launching missiles. The newest, and possibly most destructive, type of warfare is cyber warfare. Cyber warfare has the possibility to be more devastating than nuclear warfare. The world is in another cold war, except this time countries are battling for cyber supremacy....   [tags: Nuclear weapon, World War II, Cyberspace]

Better Essays
1366 words (3.9 pages)

Catastrophic Telecommunications Cyber Attacks Are Impossible Essay

- At this juncture, it may be somewhat difficult to accept the proposition that a threat to the telecommunications grid, both wired and wireless, in the United States could potentially be subject to a catastrophic cyber attack. After careful research on the subject, it appears the potentiality of an event of such magnitude, which either disrupts one or the other grids for a long period or destroys either, is both theoretically and realistically impossible. It may be that proponents—those who advance such theories—equate such “doomsday” scenarios as if a cyber attack would or could be of the same magnitude as a conventional or nuclear military strike....   [tags: Telecommunications Cyber Attacks]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Cyber Attacks Essay

- On April 27, 2007 cyber-attacks began crippling key infrastructures of banks, ministries, and newspapers. These attacks took place, in part, because of a statue. This statue is not just a two-meter tall man holding a helmet; this individual represents and symbolizes the lives lost in the Second World War. The statue has been under a lot of speculation and has torn the population of the country in half. Some believe the status is a symbol of Soviet, formerly Nazi, while some see this statue as symbol of Soviet victory over the Nazis and Russian claims Estonia....   [tags: Cyber Crime]

Better Essays
1170 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about Cyber Attacks on the Government’s Transportation Grid

- Breaches and Security Implications by Penetration of the Western Interconnection’s Traffic Control System and its Effects on Modern Day Life Year after year, a number of films are released involving computer hacking of some sort along with cyber-villainy. As entertaining as they are, the validity of these possibilities is not explored. Many of these films center revolve around a chaotic vehicle-related scene where a form of the government’s transportation grid is compromised. The breach typically involves traffic control....   [tags: Cyber Terrorism, Cyber Terrorists]

Better Essays
3307 words (9.4 pages)

Utopia - The Impossibility of Perfection Essay

- Utopia - The Impossibility of Perfection "The latter end of [this] commonwealth forgets the beginning." ?William Shakespeare, The Tempest From Plato's The Republic to Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto, the search for a perfect social state has never stopped; its ultimate goal of achieving a human society that exists in absolute harmony with all due social justice, however, has proved to be woefully elusive. The pure concept of a utopia can be theoretically visualized as a perfect geometric circle: one that is seamless, all-inclusive, yet impossible to draw out in reality....   [tags: Utopia Essays Utopian Perfect Essays]

Better Essays
1675 words (4.8 pages)

Cyber Bullying Essay

- Cyber bullying is a wide spread health issue. It is the act of sending cruel, insulting or embarrassing material to others using technology. Cyber bullying occurs usually off school property unlike normal bullying. Cyber bullying typically starts at the ages of 9 though to approximately 14, after 14 years of age it develops into harassment, or is considered as sexual harassment due to the age of the actors (Aftab PowerPoint communications,2006).Cyber bullying affects different aspects of one’s health; mentally, emotionally and physically....   [tags: Cyber Bullying Essay]

Better Essays
1336 words (3.8 pages)

Cyber-terrorism Essay

- "It is now clear that cyber threat is one of the most serious economic and national security challenges we face as a nation," President Obama has said in one of his addresses to the nation. He would go on the say that "We know that cyber intruders have probed our electrical grid, and that in other countries cyber attacks have plunged entire cities into darkness." (Net Security.org, 2009) When the president of the United States puts this much emphasis into a subject it shows how important it is and how big of an impact it could have on the nation....   [tags: cyber attacks, 2015]

Better Essays
1013 words (2.9 pages)