Ruiping Fan and Benfu Li’s Journal Article Regarding Telling Patients their Health Status

Ruiping Fan and Benfu Li’s Journal Article Regarding Telling Patients their Health Status

Length: 1228 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Should a doctor tell the truth directly to the patient regardless of the family’s wishes not to do that? Or in contrast, should the doctor simply tell the truth to the patient prior to his or her family? Ruiping Fan and Benfu Li’s journal article primarily focuses on whether or not a physician should tell truth to the patient. From a personal opinion, patients have the right to know their state of health. To be honest with a patient, despite his or her family's wishes, before telling the family ultimately depends on many things, such as the patient's age, medical conditions and circumstances, and religious beliefs.
First of all, if the physician is talking with a middle-aged man about his state of health before talking with his family, the patient might result in depression, can regret or even feel the need to give up treatment. If the doctor is talking with an elderly patient about his or her condition, it is likely that the older patient will choose not to pursue the treatment because his or her life is lived and there is no purpose to agonize and hurt relatives in the process of treatment. A possible exception is if a doctor’s patient is a child. For a doctor, it is not necessarily important to be completely honest directly with the young patient without talking with family first. This is mainly because the child is not very educated to understand the severity of their condition or the potential outcomes. In addition, the child cannot make decisions independently. It is important for a physician to talk with a child’s parents or guardians prior to discussing the child’s condition with the child itself. This allows the physician be certain that after a diagnosis, the child will be less likely to be psychologically traumatized. ...


... middle of paper ...


...However, this just worsens the situation because the patient may unknowingly transmit the disease to others.
To conclude, I think that physicians should tell the truth directly to the patient, even against family requests. Yes, there are some exceptions, of which are associated to the patients’ age, disease, and religious beliefs that makes doctors respect family wishes. Ruiping Fan and Benfu Li say that Confucian Chinese practice encourage doctors to hide the truth from the patient if his or her family thinks that it should be hidden. They say that it “…is most important for one [patient] to know everything and make medical decisions by oneself, but to have the love and interdependence of family members” (pg. 71). In agreement, a patient is entitled to know his or her condition, despite family wishes, but should also receive the support and care from their family.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Telling the Truth to Patients about their Medical Situatin Essay

- Does the doctor must tell the truth directly to the patient regardless of the families' wishes. Or maybe the doctor should tell the truth first to the patient and just after that to the family. Ruiping Fan and Benfu Li’s article tries to arguing if the doctor should or should not tell the truth to the patient. In my opinion, patients have the right to know their state of health. To tell the truth despite families wishes, and to tell the truth to patient before telling to family depends on many things, such as the patient's age , disease , religious beliefs, and etc....   [tags: Sate of health, medicine, medical privacy]

Better Essays
1009 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Working With Mental Health Patients

- Introduction: Angela Burke who was a patient admitted to the psychiatric ward for suspected mental health issues required care. When working with mental health patients, it is necessary to use a patient centered care approach which emphasizes on each individual’s personal preferences and needs (Bromley, 2012). The main goal of this is to empower patients so that they can participate and become active in their care and allowing them to have a sense of control of their life (Bromley, 2012). For this to happen, it is essential for Authorised Mental Health Practitioners (AMHPs) to work together in collaboration using the NMBA’s Nursing Practice Decision Making Framework Tool in order to develop...   [tags: Health care, Patient, Cognitive behavioral therapy]

Better Essays
2654 words (7.6 pages)

Health Care For Patients With Adults With Diabetes Essay

- It enables one get patient-specific healthcare, especially patients with diverse, beliefs, such as mode of childbirth and attention. Having a say in one’s health care allows that patient to have the right to access quality and their preferred type of health care. With current technology and access to information, patients can learn about an ideal care for their particular condition. After which they can easily opt for that which they feel is appropriate for them (Pearson et al., 2005). According to Alan et al....   [tags: Health care, Illness, Patient, Medicine]

Better Essays
967 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Experimental Trials in Pediatric Patients

- Health professionals have an immense responsibility to their patients to perform their jobs ethically. In order for a person to be able to perform their job within ethical standards, it is important to be able to define ethics and what that term encompasses. Ethics is a set of moral principles that shape a person’s behavior and actions. Regardless of whether they are religious or based on the moral codes of a society, these principles help us determine what is right and what is wrong. However, sometimes knowing if something is right or wrong is not always an easy task....   [tags: Health Professionals, Patients, Responsibility]

Better Essays
1206 words (3.4 pages)

Ethics On Truth Telling The Truth Essay

- Ethics on truth telling: to tell the truth or not to tell the truth The specific issue in questions is whether a nurse should keep the truth from their patient about their illness by respecting the wishes of the patient family or abiding by The Code of Ethics for Nurses and revealing the truth to the patient. The Code of Ethics for Nurses expresses the values and ethics of the nursing profession by stating that: Patients have the moral and legal right to determine what will be done with their own person; to be given accurate, complete, and understandable information in a manner that facilitates an informed judgment; to be assisted with weighing the benefits, burdens, and available options i...   [tags: Physician, Patient, Ethics, Nursing]

Better Essays
715 words (2 pages)

Mental Health Patients Are Stigmatized Essay

- Mental health patients are stigmatized, even in the most developed nations. Even in these developed nations there is often a lack in proper access and education for underprivileged populations. One way the burden of mental health issues can be measured in Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY); one DALY is thought of as one year lost of “healthy” life. (WHO, 2016) The sum of these DALYs are described by the World Health Organization as being “The gap in the current health status and an ideal health situation where the entire population lives to an advanced age, free of disease and disability.” (WHO, 2016) In Africa, investments in mental health care have been low, and for the most at-risk p...   [tags: Health care, Public health, Poverty, Health]

Better Essays
2178 words (6.2 pages)

An Environment Of Safety For Patients, Their Families, And The Health Care Providers

- The eagerness to promote an environment of safety for the patients, their families, and the health care providers as well as promoting compliance, led me to dig deep into the issue. This also promotes advocacy, being a voice for those patients who are unable to express their concerns and their rights due to disability or medical condition. Determining the barriers and needs that prevent the inappropriate use of physical restraint by a series of data collection through observation, chart audit, and informal questionnaires was compiled....   [tags: Patient, Health care, Health care provider]

Better Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

The Quality Of Resilience That Influence Health Care Workers And Patients

- This essay will discuss the quality of resilience, it critical elements, and its effects; assessing its effectiveness in promoting reasonable and sincere responses to psychological and physical trauma. The first section of this essay will inspect and define the concept of resilience, showing its place in the realm of general health care while maintaining its individuality as a characteristic of personal psychological well being. The following section will dictate the risk and protective factors both innate and imposed that encourage or prevent a resilient character arising as a result of physical or psychological trauma....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Patient]

Better Essays
1131 words (3.2 pages)

Inpatient Hospital Stays: Communication between Physicians and Patients Source Review

- Effective communication between the physician and patient must include communicating in a clear simple manner, communicating with family members, communicating the plan of care, communicating results of tests and procedures performed and communicating findings, good or bad, in a manner appropriate for the situation. Sources: Arthur D. Fisk, et al. "What factors lead to healthcare miscommunications with older patients?" Journal of Communication in Healthcare 2.2 (2009): 103-118. Health Business Elite....   [tags: Health Care, Communicating with Patients]

Better Essays
1944 words (5.6 pages)

Health Care For Patients With Chronic Conditions Essay

- Assignment #1 What is wrong with healthcare today, using the material you have learned in this class. Why is it difficult to care for patients with chronic conditions. (if you want to share a family example, that would be ok) Do you feel EMRs/EHRs help or hinder the care of chronically ill patients. As we have discussed in the previous class, there are many factors that affect healthcare in the US, such as tobacco use, alcohol use, smoking , obesity, high Blood Pressure, etc. Undoubtedly, these factors can cause issues in the system and the system needs more time, costs and effort to face these issues besides chronic diseases....   [tags: Medicine, Health care, Health, Health economics]

Better Essays
1185 words (3.4 pages)