The Relationship Between The Jews And Muslims During The Time Of Muhammad

The Relationship Between The Jews And Muslims During The Time Of Muhammad

Length: 1446 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A major point of debate between historians is over the relationship between the Jews and Muslims during the time of Muhammad in Medina. Some historians such as Fred Donner argues that Jews as well as other Monotheists were part of Muhammad’s early community of faith. Other historians such as Johnathan Berkley disagree with this argument and argues that Muhammad’s early followers and the Jews was two separate entities constantly in confrontation, and questions if one could practice Judaism while being a part of Muhammad’s believers. Fazlur Rahman is another historian that disagrees with Donner’s notion and argues that the early Muslims and Jews was two completely distinct groups. By analyzing each historian’s argument as well as primary sources like the Quran it’s clear that Donner’s conclusion is the most accurate; that while Muhammad’s group may have conflicted with Jewish tribes, Muhammad’s community of believers was inclusive of Jews as well as another monotheist.
Donner has good evidence proving that other monotheist such as the Jews were part of Muhammad’s early community of faith. One of Donner’s arguments supporting this theory is that since Muhammad’s message was so similar to the apostles of the two other main monotheistic religions, it’s plausible to believe that Jews and Christians could have been part of Muhammad’s movement. Donner uses a passage from the holy Quran to prove that Muhammad’s movement was inclusive of Jews, “There are many among the people of the book those who believe in God and what was sent down, to you and sent down to them” (Q:3;199). The Quran’s validating of other monotheist peoples suggest that they also have been believers and their righteousness made it so they could be a part of Muhammad’s ea...


... middle of paper ...


...ther Monotheist were a piece of Muhammad 's initial group of confidence. Different students of history, for example, Johnathan Berkley can 't help contradicting this contention and contends that Muhammad 's initial devotees and the Jews were two separate elements always in a showdown and inquiries on the off chance that one could rehearse Judaism while being a piece of Muhammad 's adherents. Fazlur Rahman is another antiquarian that couldn 't help contradicting Donner 's idea and contends that the early Muslims and Jews were two totally unmistakable gatherings. By breaking down every history specialist 's contentions and in addition essential sources like the Quran obviously Donner 's decision is the most exact; that while Muhammad 's gathering may have clashed with Jewish tribes, Muhammad 's people group of adherents was comprehensive of Jews and another monotheist.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on How come so many Jews in Albania Survived?

- Adolf Hitler was dedicated to wiping out the European Jews. So how come so many Jews in Albania survived. How come most of the 200 native Jews and 400 hundred Jewish refugees in Albania were saved and able to be free. How come the Jewish population before World War II was smaller than it was after the war. This is because so many Albanian Muslims helped the Jews of Albania escape while countless others hid them in their homes. Thanks to the besa code (which means to keep the promise, and the promise orders hospitality and the protection of guests as if they are members of one’s family), many Jews were able to escape with the help of Albanian Muslims....   [tags: albanian muslims, jews, hitler]

Better Essays
687 words (2 pages)

Early Interactions between Muslims, Jews, and Christians Under Islam Essay

- ... Under the Umayya, Cordoba had always flourished. As a whole, al-Andalus underwent an economic revival as the population increased and failing areas in the countryside were broadened and reformed (Menocal) (27). During the Caliphate of Cordoba, Abd al-Rahman III managed to launch the capital into its finest state of economic prosperity. Moreover, it was reinforced as one of the most prominent cultural bastions of its time. This was largely due to the coexistence of various religions and cultures, a product of the religious tolerance that at least Jews and Christians were supposed to be guaranteed under Islam....   [tags: religious beliefs, political relations]

Better Essays
1971 words (5.6 pages)

Differences Between Muslims And Christians Essay

- 1. There are many differences and similarities between Muslim, Jews and Christians. One similarity that all three religions share is the belief in one god, although, Muslims refer to God as Allah. (242). All three religions have places where they go to pray and worship their god along with gathering with others of their faith for various other reasons (247). A Mosque is what the Muslims call their house of worship, a church is where Christians worship and a synagogue is where members of the Jewish community worship (247)....   [tags: Islam, Judaism, Allah, Muhammad]

Better Essays
1182 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about Civilization on Muslims: Stereotypically Wrong

- Stereotypes consistently find their place in society. Every single facet of humanity has faced scrutiny for beliefs, practices and ideals. Henrik Ibsen addresses such issues in his play, A Doll’s House, as he discusses the role of women during a villainous time in history. The story’s protagonist, Nora, seeks to break stereotypes about her gender. She defies the majority, stating, “Before all else, I’m a human being, no less that [anyone else].” Over the course of humankind, all groups of people have faced labeling and branding for various reasons....   [tags: stereotypes, religion, Christianity]

Better Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

The Golden Age for Jews Essay

- The Golden Age for Jews was an age of great prosperity along with fluctuating tolerance. The Golden Age is a period in Jewish history when the Jews were living under Islamic Rule. The Golden Age started in about year 711 and went till approximately 1066 CE. Most of the prosperity in this age came through Islamic ruled Spain where many Jews lived. In this era the Jews had protection from being proselytized by Muslims through a set of laws called the Dhimmi laws. The laws provide a certain amount of toleration towards Jews living under Muslim leaders....   [tags: islam rule, dhimmi laws, christianity]

Better Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Muslims Essay

- Muslims I first became interested in learning about Muslims when I met a young man in a Speech class of mine. He was dark skinned, dark haired, and extremely handsome, so I decided to get acquainted with him. I asked him his name and he asked me if I wanted his real name or his made up name. I was a little confused and I asked him what he meant by that. He told me he was a Muslim and his "real" Muslim name is Sadat and his made up name is Danny. I was quite intrigued by, but a little confused by all of this, so I thought I would look further into the subject....   [tags: Muslim Islam Religion Essays]

Better Essays
1403 words (4 pages)

Jews ' Persecution Through The Holocaust And Their Survival Essay

- Schindler’s List: Jews’ Persecution through the Holocaust and Their Survival Jews, a religious group of people originating from Israel, have lived in Europe, including Germany, for about 1500 years (Carr; Shyovitz). As Jews moved away from Israel, agriculture was no longer their main form of breadwinning. They have become more educated and many acquired skilled professions. In Europe, Christians were not allowed to lend money and the Jews have become the main money lenders. The knowledge, skills, and money lending abilities that Jews possessed allowed them to become extremely prosperous....   [tags: Nazi Germany, The Holocaust, World War II]

Better Essays
1895 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on Treatment of Jews Under the Spanish Islamic Empire

- In 610 CE, Muhammad first founded the religion known as Islam. It soon spread out through the Middle East, North Africa, the Mediterranean, and Spain. Once Muhammad died, new Muslim leaders took over the Islamic Empire. Known as caliphs, they ruled the Muslim community instead of Muhammad. When Islam reached Spain, the Jews living there were affected in a positive way. The Jews of the Muslim world led a fair and comfortable life under the Caliphate, however, once the Caliphates were gone, the Jewish golden age was terminated....   [tags: religious tolerance and collaboration]

Better Essays
1596 words (4.6 pages)

The Tribulations That The Jewish People Faced During The Past And Present I Reflect On Their Indomitable Courage

- When analyzing the tribulations that the Jewish people faced in the past and present I reflect on their indomitable courage. The fact that Jews still hold on to their faith and values served as a powerful message to both Jews and non Jews, One of the things that I value a great deal about the Jewish people is how they highly value education. For instance, my mother’s boyfriend’s father worked three jobs in order for his son to pursued an education at Columbia and Princeton. At times, I wondered how far Black youths and society at large would be if education is placed at the forefront....   [tags: Antisemitism, Judaism, Jews, Halakha]

Better Essays
1006 words (2.9 pages)

Problems Between Jews and Christians that Caused the Holocaust Essay

- In Elie Wiesel’s interview with Ronald Eyre Elie spoken of the existing problem between the Jews and the Christians that caused the Holocaust. This problem dealt with the “Victims” (Jews) and the “Killers” (Christians). Wiesel claimed that the Christians were the reason for this tragedy known as the Holucoaust. Given what is known about each master story: God is love (Christanity),and God is Just(Judaism). An explanation of the credibility of Wiesel’s statements is needed.. Through defining the Christian master story, that there was nothing done to prevent the holucoust, and that the problem exists today can explain Wiesel’s statements....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
464 words (1.3 pages)