Although such powers seems to enshrine the rule of the law in Hong Kong, it is superficial as some previous inquiries were deemed to be politically motivated and more importantly, Hong Kong does not have democratically elected Legco. In summary, the judiciary is more suited to handle such inquiry.
The Privileges and Inquiry Powers of Legco:
Article 77 and 78 of the Basic Law provides members of Legco “shall be immune from legal action in respect of their statement at meeting of the Legco” and “shall not be subject to arrest on their way to a meeting of the Legco” respectively. In addition, article 73(10) stipulates that Legco can “summon, as required when exercising the above-mentioned powers and functions, persons concerned to testify or give evidence”.
Section 4, 5 and 10 of the PPO correspond to article 77, 78 and 73(10) of the Basic Law. However there are related provisions under the PPO that are not provide for in the Basic Law, which include ordering attendance of witness by summon under section 10, examining witness on oath under section 11, compelling attendance by issuing warrant under section 12 and setting offences punishment under section 17-20. There is a doubt that those PPO’s provisions could be unconstitutional.
The Rule of Law:
There are two conceptions of the rule of law. The formative conception focuses on the predictab...
... middle of paper ...
...lly that PPO is exercised arbitrarily on the influence of functional constituencies’ self interest and DAB’s pro-government altitude.
Another argument against inquiry concerns judicial fairness as such inquiry may trigger public trail if the summon entity is subject to be trail later on.
It is arguable that the privilege and inquiry power of the Legco are part of the judiciary function. It is more thorough and efficient for the judiciary to handle through judicial review.
In conclusion, the current system of privilege and inquiry power of the Legco is not compatible with the formative rule of the law. Indeed such inquiry is better handled by the judiciary. As such inquiry has been exercised arbitrarily, it may not be worth for Legco to maintain such power as Hong Kong citizen is expecting substantive rule of law in Hong Kong not the formative version.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- When giving our presentation on the Inquiry Model to the class, our objectives were to define what the inquiry model is, inform the class about the importance of inquiry, identify the outcomes of inquiry, explain how it differs from other approaches, and explain the benefits. We felt like going over these aspects would give the class a clearer and better understanding of the topic. Our opening statement was giving the class a clear-cut definition of what the Inquiry Model means. It contains many different things in the definition.... [tags: Inquiry-based Learning]
1141 words (3.3 pages)
- Separation of powers is an act of vesting the legislative, executive, and judicial powers of government in separate bodies. (Losco and Baker 2013, pg 23) The United States is focused on this thought of discrete branches of government with distinct responsibilities. Power is divided in the U.S. government in two significant ways. Originally, power is distributed amongst the state and national government, and following, power is shared between the three branches of national government. Separation of powers, hence, refers to the division of government accountabilities into discrete branches to limit any one branch from exercising the primary functions of another.... [tags: Separation of powers]
1478 words (4.2 pages)
Evaluating the Argument that Powers and Privileges of Parliament Increased Steadily at the Expense of Royal Power
- Evaluating the Argument that Powers and Privileges of Parliament Increased Steadily at the Expense of Royal Power During the period 1529 - 1640 the parliament in Britain altered dramatically. The sources provide a valuable insight into the argument that the powers and privileges of parliament increased steadily at the expense of royal power. To assess the role of parliament there needs to be evidence from the sources to suggest that parliaments powers and privileges were increasing between 1529-1640.... [tags: Papers]
819 words (2.3 pages)
- The doctrine of the ‘separation of powers’ is a concept that concerns the system of governance, it suggests that there should be an appropriate distribution of power between the different principal institutions of the state . The separation of powers emphasises the functional independence of these branches, and especially that their subsequent actors do not possess powers attributable or assigned to other institutions . This concept is popularly construed with the tripartite division proposed by Montesquieu in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), which details the need for distinction and independence between the executive, legislative and judicial branches, so to effect benefits such as a safegua... [tags: Separation of powers, Presidential system]
1262 words (3.6 pages)
- This essay will examine why the absolute separation of powers in the UK constitution is neither practical nor achievable. There are three distinctive branches in the UK constitution, and they are the legislative, executive and judiciary. By dividing the power into three branches, it reduces the possibility of abuse of power. When all power is held by one single body, it might lead to tyranny and hunger for power. The legislative branch in the UK constitution is the parliament. The parliament in the UK consists of the House of commons and the house of lords.... [tags: Separation of powers, Law, United Kingdom]
1493 words (4.3 pages)
- Should Psychologists Have Prescription Privileges. The debate over the right of clinical psychologists to prescribe psychoactive medications is certainly not new to the scene. In fact, the debate spans over the past two decades with strong arguments on each end of the spectrum. While opponents to the issue question, among many other things, the qualifications of psychologists, advocates on the issue stress the important public needs that are not currently being met in our mental healthcare system (Lavoie & Barone, 2006).... [tags: mental health, comprehensive services]
1012 words (2.9 pages)
- A government must have a method for citing specific powers to its elected members. The U.S. Constitution is one such document that enables a system of separation of power and checks and balances through the creation of three governmental bodies. First, is the Legislative branch which encompasses congress; who makes the laws. Then, there is the Executive branch which includes the President and his or her executive office which enforce laws. Lastly, there is the Judicial branch which includes the courts who interpret the law.... [tags: Separation of powers, Law, Constitution, Judiciary]
839 words (2.4 pages)
- Education privilege is a huge controversy in our time. To whom the privilege apply to, and to what extinct someone should go to earn a fine label in society. These are couple of the arguments that can go on for while without anyone indicating a final answer to it. Margaret A.Miller in “The privileges of the parents” argus about how important parents education and how it will affect their children. Putting out an idea that might not be so popular among people with Bachelor degrees or further education.... [tags: Higher education, College, High school, Education]
1157 words (3.3 pages)
- The stages of scientific enquiry have been developed and refined over time, to add consistency of approach and structure to systematic investigation. These processes; stimulus, curiosity, enquiry, initial investigation/observation, initial perception, initial hypothesis, experimentation, observation and recording, drawing conclusions, evaluation of initial hypothesis, formation of new hypothesis and re-experimentation, are perceived as a sequential flow of enquiry. However, in reality they are less well defined, due to sub-sequences and adaptations necessary to accommodate changing requirements.... [tags: science inquiry skills, education]
1494 words (4.3 pages)
- Despite the intentions of the framers of the Constitution and the subsequent roles laid out for the president therein, the President of the United States of America has assumed roles and powers that somewhat challenge these intentions. Since the forming of the Union there has been a continuing struggle over the powers of the president and whether he should take a reserved legalist position or a more activist role. The legalist and activist positions are embodied perhaps no more deservedly in Presidents Taft and T.... [tags: Politics]
1497 words (4.3 pages)