Plutarch And Xenophon On The Lycurgan Reforms Essay

Plutarch And Xenophon On The Lycurgan Reforms Essay

Length: 1235 words (3.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Plutarch and Xenophon on The Lycurgan Reforms
The one thing we know for certain about Spartan society is that we don’t know much about it. Very few documents and artifacts about the Spartans have been discovered, but the ones that have tell us everything we know. Two of these works are Plutarch’s On Sparta and Xenophon’s Spartan Society. One of the main things these two accounts focused on was the Lycurgan reforms. Through their stories and writings Plutarch and Xenophon had both some similarities and differences when talking about the political, economic, militaristic, and social reforms. One of the main differences when comparing these two writings is how Plutarch gives a historical account of Spartan society and tries to keep objectivity in his writings, while Xenophon appreciates the Spartan society and often makes it evident he is using it to criticise the Greek society of his time.

When talking about the differences between these two writing styles one important thing to keep in mind is that Xenophon lived during the fourth century BC and Plutarch lived in the first century AD. This means that these two writers had different contexts and intentions when creating their account. One thing that they both talked about was how the political aspect of Spartan society was changed by the Lycurgan reforms. The biggest of these reforms was changing the role of a king. The two kings were no longer excused from normal citizen activities. Plutarch gives an example of this with the story of King Agis. “King Agis returned from the campaign and wanted to eat at home with his wife instead of at the communal mess and called for his portions; the polemarchs would not send them. The next day he did not carry out a required s...


... middle of paper ...


...ly become the most powerful and most famous state in Greece” (Spartan Society, 1). Their shared admiration of Sparta is very reasonable. The Spartan city state was thriving due to the Lycurgan reforms; it was something completely new to Sparta that captured the eyes of many.

When taking into account how Xenophon lived during the fourth century BC and Plutarch lived in the first century AD, it is interesting that they can actually have some similarities in their historical accounts. The biggest of these being that they both admired Sparta greatly, and could not help but to adore their glory. But there are far more accounts that show their differences. When talking about the political, economic, militaristic, and social reforms Plutarch stayed objective while Xenophon clearly showed his appreciation for Sparta, and used that view to critique his Greek society.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Xenophon and Aristophanes: The Results of a Husband’s Desire for Control

- Xenophon and Aristophanes: The Results of a Husband’s Desire for Control In Greek society women had little control over their lives. A husband wanted to be able to control his wife so she would run his household as he saw fit, so she did not damage his reputation, and so he knew the paternity of his children. A husband wanted the girl to be closely controlled by her father before she married for the same reasons. Aristophanes’ comedies and Xenophon’s Oeconomicus contain very different depictions of a Greek citizen woman’s life before she is married and during the time shortly after she is married....   [tags: Xenophon Aristophanes Power Papers]

Free Essays
1809 words (5.2 pages)

Education and the Examples of the Chile and Canada Reforms Essay

- 1. The overarching objective of educational policy-makers in developed nations is to make sure each child gets a good education, so that each child is more prepared to contribute to the economy and uphold the economic prosperity. This is why many reforms are in place to better educational systems as stated in a 2012 article by Bensimon, Alicia, Dowd, Longanecker, and Witham. They indicated that, “The nation is in an era of policy reform aimed at improving the productivity and effectiveness of higher education”(Bensimon, Dowd, Longanecker, & Witham, 2012)....   [tags: Students, Reforms, Policies]

Strong Essays
1077 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Plutarch: A Greek Philosopher

- Plutarch was a historian from Chaeronea, which was a Greek area of Boetia and lived in the time of C.46-120. Plutarch is known in history for being a famous writer who started his studies somewhere around the age of twenty under Ammonius who was a Platonist philosopher in Athens. It is not known what Plutarch studied under his mentor Ammonius but it is thought that maybe Ammonius influenced Plutarch in his religious ways. Plutarch spent so much time in Athens that he became a Citizen of Athens, some even say he served as governor of Greece but this hasn’t been confirmed....   [tags: Theory, Writer]

Strong Essays
674 words (1.9 pages)

An Apologia of Xenophon Essay

- “Anabasis” is the Xenophon’s account of the expedition for Cyrus against Persian and the marching home of Greeks. The Greek title of Xenophon’s work, “Anabasis”, referred to a march up country, away from the coast. The title applies only to the first of its seven books. It all ends with the death of Cyrus at the Battle of Cuxana. The Greek mercenary soldiers were left stranded in the “barbarian” world. The rest of the books involves with tales of the Greeks’ discipline, leadership and courage during their journey home....   [tags: The Greeks, Military, War]

Strong Essays
1089 words (3.1 pages)

Plutarch's Life and Legendary Writings Essay

- ... Frank William Walbank, a scholar of ancient history, tells readers many things about Plutarch and the life he lived. Plutarch was a “biographer and author whose works strongly influenced the evolution of the essay, the biography, and historical writing in Europe”(Walbank). One of his most recognizable and known books is Parallel Lives, which is where “Plutarch’s popularity rests primarily…designed to encourage mutual respect between Greeks and Romans”(Walbank). Parallel Lives was “written as a moral influences upon the reader, illustrates diverse virtues through the medium of pairing a famous Greek personality with a correspondingly famous Roman personality”(Smith)....   [tags: ethics, skills, education]

Strong Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Ethnographic Interests of Xenophon

- Xenophon, the son of Athenian wealthy family, was exiled because of his assistance for the enemies of Athenians. He claimed that he was yearning for a thrilling adventure; as a result, he decided to join Cyrus’s expedition against his brother Artaxerxes, the Persian King along with the Greek mercenaries. Though Anabasis is more about the record of the Greeks’’ struggle and hardship during their retreat in the hostile territory, Xenophon writes Anabasis as his interest of ethnography. Ethnography is a study of human cultures....   [tags: Greek Military, Tactics, Athens]

Strong Essays
1292 words (3.7 pages)

Plutarch's Life Essay

- Plutarch was a well-known historian, biographer, and essayist. Also, Plutarch was a Greek scholar, and today is considered to be a Middle Protanist. Clyde Curry Smith, a professor at the University of Wisconsin, tells readers “Plutarch was born sometime around 46 A.D. in Chaeronea, Boeotia”(Smith). Plutarch was born “around the Roman imperial administration of Claudius I”(Smith). It is also believed that Plutarch died around the age of 74, “sometime after 120 c.e.”(Smith). Along with being a historian and essayist, Plutarch was also a priest, ambassador, mayor, and magistrate....   [tags: historian, greek scholar]

Strong Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

The Validity of Plutarch Essay

- The first century AD gave birth to Plutarch of Chaeronea. He was born into the Greco-Roman world during the Pax Romana, a time of peace that which had not been seen in all of the country's history. Plutarch, coming from an upper-class family, was able to get a good education and find a purpose to his life1. Philosophy was his calling and he was brilliant in his work. An aficionado of the works of his forefathers in thought (from Zeno to Plato), Plutarch used their systems to take his knack for observing the behavior of men and formulating the proper way to live....   [tags: World Literature]

Strong Essays
2268 words (6.5 pages)

Xenophon´s The Economist Essay examples

- Xenophon, (430-c.354 BC) Athenian peer of Plato and fellow student of Socrates, is known for his philosophical writings including Anabasis, Cyropoedia, and Memorobilia. Xenophon wrote extensively on the domestic economy in his Economist and defined the duties of a wife therein (the overseer of the home and children) and marriage as a “partnership ordained by the gods.” Not much is known about the life of Xenophon after his education. It is, however, recorded that Xenophon served as a mercenary in Cyrus’ army....   [tags: domestic economy, economics, labor]

Strong Essays
1242 words (3.5 pages)

Project Plutarch Essay

- Project Plutarch The chronometer superimposed over the edge of Floyd Garcia's vision displayed the year 28, A.D. This was the farthest projection yet, by nearly a thousand years, and at this temporal distance the computers were having trouble keeping up with the uncertainty calculations. This made the scene quite nauseating as Floyd adjusted the Virtual reality goggles and wiped the sweat from the place where the cushioned rim was held firmly against his cheeks by the tight elastic headband. Maybe the queasiness also had something to do with anticipation....   [tags: Short Stories Science Essays]

Free Essays
3475 words (9.9 pages)