Plato believed that his “ideal city” would be successful. With different tears of quality of life, and the ways of classifying people, he believed it would work out. However, if you really look at the structure of his ideal city, and of our modern day society, it simply would not work. Though you can also find many similarities between his ideal city and our modern world today, which in some ways his ideal city could possibly work.
The foundation of Plato’s ideal city was to have different classes of people. The producing class, auxiliaries, philosophers, kings, queens, and so on. The producing class is the largest class. This class basically included everyone. From artists to farmers, this class was the vastly large class. It did not, however, include the warriors or the rulers of the ideal city. The next class of people were the auxiliaries are basically warriors. They were there to defend the city and make sure no others were trying to invade it. They were basically the police, except the would have authority over the police in modern day society. They were meant to keep peace in the ideal city and make sure that others were doing the same. The last, but definitely not least class, were the guardians. The guardians were basically the rulers of the ideal city. Another name for these rulers were “philosopher kings.”
The problem with classifying people into different categories, would be that it was based on their talents and jobs. If you are to classifying someone based on that, I believe the world would become very chaotic. Just like having rulers, these people would have a distinct power over others just because of their job title. But if you think about our society today, there is still unspoken discr...
... middle of paper ...
...ltimately more powerful than the others and would make decisions in their own favor, without thinking of the other classes. That is why you can not elect the elite, because they will just do things in their own favor, without considering the other classes.
Ultimately, Plato’s society would be able to function for a certain amount of time. With people being taught that that is the only way to do things, they would go along with it for a while. Classes would mind their own business and go about their work, not feeling their doing the best they could be. But after a while people would catch on that this is not an ideal, efficient society. The lower classes would revolt against leaders that make poor judgments and against leaders who abuse their power. Eventually the societies lack of change would be the downfall and after the people revolt, there would be nothing left.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- One of the mainly electrifying essentials of contemporary period is the urbanisation of the globe. For sociological reasons a city is a comparatively great, crowded and lastingly community of diverse people. In metropolitan areas urban sociology is the sociological research of life, human interaction and their role in the development of society. Modern urban sociology creates from the work of sociologists such as Max Weber and Georg Simmel who put forward the economic, social and intellectual development of urbanisation and its consequences.... [tags: Modern urban sociology]
2825 words (8.1 pages)
- Plato's Vision Of The Ideal State As Presented In The Republic The concept of questioning meaning of life, the universe and everything has become debauched in modern society. But there is an exigency for and a value in the procedure of reasoning through aspects of our experience beginning with moral principles to existence. It can, for ordinary peoples as much as for professional philosophers, enlivening, vivid, and developmental. Plato is one of the most influential thinkers in human history. His philosophies have made a far-reaching impact on the human societies and have laid the foundation of many avenues of knowledge.... [tags: selfishness, utopia, God]
1275 words (3.6 pages)
- During the nineteenth century, France experienced many changes that affected its society in many profound ways. Industrialization transformed the economy of France from a primarily agricultural economy to a primarily industrial economy. Politically, the revolution of 1848 deposed the monarchy permanently, replacing it with a new republic, which itself would be replaced by a new empire headed by a descendant of Napoleon Bonaparte. Culturally, the rise of Louis Napoleon led to the reconstruction of Paris as a fully modern city, and artists transitioned from classical forms and subjects to increasingly more experimental subjects and forms, including depicting the bourgeoisie and the working cla... [tags: art, society, revolution]
2382 words (6.8 pages)
- City on a Hill American exceptionalism is an idea that goes back as far as the American Revolution. American exceptionalism to me is the idea that we as Americans owe it to the world to be the shining example of what can be accomplished if we work to make ourselves the shining example of the successful life for the rest of the world. We must also actively share our exceptionalism, our ideals with the rest of the world. From an early age the idea of American exceptionalism has influenced me in believing that the American way was the primary and only possible way for prosperity.... [tags: United States, Nationalism, Vietnam War, Cold War]
896 words (2.6 pages)
- Manila Overview A perfect blend of past and future at same platform, the chaotic and sprawling conurbation of Philippines, Manila has gained its fame for hidden cultural values and traditions beneath the modern and populated society. The sparkling Philippine epicentre has been under the good books of Europeans from years for successful struggle from many historical events including World War II. The transformation process is still visible at the fabulous ruins and historical sites of Manila even now.... [tags: india, festivals, culture]
579 words (1.7 pages)
- Amateur City, a city filled with confusion and intolerable human behavior. In this detective fiction novel, Katherine Forrest demonstrates the social, sexual and power dynamic of each character which all leads to the curious homicide of Fergus Parker. In Forrest’s Amateur City there are multiple analysis regarding the characters of the “Modern Office” also including the detective Kate Delafield. Amateur City portrays a huge hierarchy of the predominant human society in which the class of race, ethnicity and gender are all divided in the image of Forrest’s characters.... [tags: Literary Analysis, Katherine Foster]
1629 words (4.7 pages)
- History_Educational Influences Marina City as a modernist urban solution was possible by Bertrand Goldberg because of his formal architectural training as well as his early practice and interaction with key architects. Exposure to architectural, socioeconomic, and cultural context that shaped modernist architecture developed him as an architect. Influence began early from his physics teacher, George Vaubel, which inspired him with a lifelong love for logic and “reasoning backwards”. Goldberg studied at the Cambridge School of Architecture and Landscape then at the Bauhaus in Berlin and lastly at the Armour Institute of Technology in Chicago.... [tags: modernism, Bertrand Goldberg, architecture]
1313 words (3.8 pages)
- Niccoló Machiavelli wrote The Prince in order to set forth certain guidelines the ruler of a state must follow in order to rule successfully. During Machiavelli’s time the world was filled with monarchies and other forms of government that act differently from the common democracy that is in the world today. Could a political book written in the 16th century still have value in today’s politics. In order to answer this question, this paper will take an in depth look at Barrack Obama, to determine whether he is following the guidelines Machiavelli has created.... [tags: Comparing Machiavelli and Barrack Obama]
2776 words (7.9 pages)
- Plato was truly inspired by his teacher, Socrates; in fact he was so inspired that he wrote a full dialogue with ten books full of Socrates wisdom. He also wrote many other dialogues using the language of Socrates, the most significant one to the modern day would be The Republic. The reason why is because it follows the idea of justice and an ideal city. These ideas discussed have been tried to be put to use several times in the past and still in the present. Unfortunately, the human nature of this generation is so coherently bad that it has not been successful so far.... [tags: Plato, Mind, Soul, Virtue]
1004 words (2.9 pages)
- Plato and John Rawls give to us an account of a moral community in which they both presupposed different views of the human person as order to such community. In this paper, I will attempt to examine what this moral political community is according to Plato and John Rawls. My thesis will support Plato's idea of moral political community which is better than John Rawls because it presents a community with order and a concern for the well being of all not just one. According to Plato in the words of Socrates, " I assume that if a community has been found properly, it has everything it takes to be good." The keywords from this phrase being "found properly" and "has eve... [tags: essays research papers]
1548 words (4.4 pages)