Islamic Criminal Justice Essay

Islamic Criminal Justice Essay

Length: 1321 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Comparative Criminal Justice System

Criminal Law has and will continue to be a fluid and ever-changing aspect of humanity, and yet the distinctive base of religious belief is still a foundation for a variety of laws today. While the separation of church and state is in effect, history states a wide range of laws have been established based on religious beliefs and ideals, the Bible for one, and currently the Qur’an, which is the basis for Islamic Law. It is the only true form of law in the present time that is not backed by a Government because it is a form of law based completely on religion. The two primary sources of the Islamic Law stem from the Shari’s and the Sunnah, the Shari is the law defined by God, or Allah, and told directly to Gods’ prophet on Earth, Muhammad. The Sunnah, the second factor in Islamic Law deals with the issues not addressed in the Qur’an, yet is still in the word of the Prophet. “In a few Islamic countries, including Iran, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Sudan, it is proclaimed as the basis for all law, including the harsh Islamic criminal law based on the ideal of retribution” (Fairchild & Dammer 2001 P. 61). Also stated in the text Comparative Criminal Justice Systems by Fairchild and Danner is the four distinct types of schools in the belief of Islamic Law:
“There are four major schools of Islamic Law, derived from religious leaders living in different areas and facing different problems in the two centuries following the death of Muhammad. These schools are Hanafi, Hanbali, Maliki, and Shafi’i. The main differences between these schools are in matters of emphasis, whether on tradition, judicial reasoning, or the elaboration of the Qur’an” (2001 P.62).
Therefore in the following paper the obj...

... middle of paper ...

...w, but in Afghanistan it is just the opposite it is difficult to try to change Islamic Law especially in a country where many individuals truly believe in Islamic Law. Islamic law does not exist in very many countries but in Afghanistan those who follow the Islamic laws keep it alive and well which will make it difficult for the government if they wish to change anything within the Islamic laws of Afghanistan.

Dammer,Harry R. & Fairrchild, Erika. (2001). Comparative Criminal Justice Systems. (2nd Ed.)

Lau, Martin. (2008). Islamic Law and the Afghan legal System. Retrieved on December 12, 2008

Reiber, Ney. (2008). Islamic Law, Shariah. Retrieved on December 12, 2008 from:

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Between Criminal Justice System

- Punishing methodology initiated aeons ago therefore, making a norm to inflict pain on an individual. Imprisonment is a popular form of punishment used in society. However, “there are major differences among criminal justice system in duration of prions sentences and prison condition.” (Dammer and Albanese, 202, 2011) For example the way prisoners are treated in England and Wales would be different to the way they’re treated in Nigeria and how the laws are applied. Each country practises the justice system differently to maintain civilisation while striving to create peace and balance within their society....   [tags: Prison, Criminal justice, Common law, Punishment]

Strong Essays
1106 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Different Types Of Criminal Justice

- There are many types of criminal justice used in the world. Each and every country uses different ones to maintain civilization while striving to create peace and balance within their society. The justice system is also used to create a social code of conduct in society and jurisdiction. Every country’s justice system attempts to achieve well-preserved system through punishment and deterrence by creating a notion that forces individuals to abide the law of their country. Nations used several distinctive methods of punishments to individuals that go against the social norms....   [tags: Common law, Law, Prison, Criminal justice]

Strong Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Prejudice And The Criminal Justice System Essay

- Prejudice in the Criminal justice system We are not all treated equal where equality is required to assure the law is upheld. One of the flaws in our criminal justice system is how prejudice is often present in trials, and prevents suspects from having a fair trial. In “Serial”, a podcast about a first generation American teenager of Muslim religion named Adnan who was charged with the murder of his ex-girlfriend, prejudice is shown very strongly. At his bail hearing the prosecutor led the court to believe that Adnan 's extended support from his Muslim community would do anything they could to help Adnan escape the country and the justice system, ultimately getting away with murder....   [tags: Jury, Criminal law, Islam, Discrimination]

Strong Essays
1106 words (3.2 pages)

Islamic Religion: Shariah Essay

- The most recent catchword nowadays is ‘Shariah’. As a number of countries struggle to pass statute to suppress Shariah, an overvalued anxiety and continual misperception encircles the word ‘Shariah’. The majority of people who converse zealously in opposition to Shariah do not, actually, comprehend it and frequently degrade it to just a penal code. This paper illustrates the comprehensive principles of Shariah and its universal method. It further stresses misunderstandings about Shariah to level out the apprehensions at present encircling this subject....   [tags: Prophet Muhammad, islamic countries]

Strong Essays
1804 words (5.2 pages)

The Justice System Of The Islamic Law Essay

- The justice system of the Islamic law is rather based on philosophical principles which are considered alien, if not unconscionable to many observers. The practices of the Islamic law should be examined within the socio-religious philosophy of the country and in the spirit of true theoretical inquiry. According to the textbook that would be an inaccurate assumption due to the fact that it is a violation against the human right. Reichel (2013) explained “That would be an inaccurate assumption because when a murder has occurred, it was not God’s rights that were violated but the right of a human being” (p....   [tags: Jury, Common law, Inquisitorial system]

Strong Essays
867 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Terrorism And The Criminal Justice System

- The criminal act that was committed on September 11th, 2001 was an act of terrorism. Terrorism is defined as violence that is targeted towards an undisclosed victim or victims, without them having knowledge that a specific attack is bound to happen, thus making them unprepared for combat. Our textbook, Criminology and the Criminal Justice System states that “the use or threat of violence directed at people or government to punish them for past action and/or to bring about change of policy that is to the terrorist’s liking” (Criminology Pg....   [tags: September 11 attacks, Al-Qaeda, Osama bin Laden]

Strong Essays
1678 words (4.8 pages)

Saudi Arabian Justice System is Based on Islamic Law from the Quran Essay

- ... The Shari’ah Courts are broken into three different categories. The first one is, Courts of the First Instance, the second is, Courts of Cassation and the third one is, Supreme Judicial Council. The second justice system is Board of Grievances, this court hears all the cases that involve the government. The third justice system consist of various committees within the government that address disputes, such as labor issues. Saudi Arabia enforces the harshest Islamic law next to Afghanistan. As cruel as the system might seem, the deeper the trouble that lies in the country....   [tags: grievance, punishments, sharia]

Strong Essays
600 words (1.7 pages)


- THE PLACE OF ISLAMIC LAW IN TANZANIA MAINLAND. Introduction: Islam is one of the Universal religions of the world. As a religion, Islam is governed by an assortment of divine laws known as shariah of which its sources are mainly attributed to the divine revelations in the Holy Qur’an and traditions of the Prophet (P.B.U.H). This package is what forms the basis of the spiritual, economic, political and social guidance of Muslims. Thus, all the laws of Islam have to be annexed to and borne of the Holy texts....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Free Essays
3729 words (10.7 pages)

The Evolution of the Islamic Legal System Essay

- EVOLUTION OF LEGAL SYSTEM ACROSS THE WORLD : ISLAMIC LEGAL SYSTEM The development of law was started before history was recorded with laws advanced one by one as question were settled actually, the improvement of standards in the public area originated before both courts and the composed law for many years, standards and practice legitimate frame work alone requested human excercises the force of standard law is found in the way that it is reflected in the behaviour of individuals to each other the furher a social order moves far from standards and private law frameworks the more terrific the requirement the requirement of laws correctively upheald by the state Since we are discussing the...   [tags: supression, regulations, rights]

Strong Essays
611 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Islamic Roots of the Millet System

- Even though this might seem paradoxal to those most keen stereotypes of the contemporary popular image of Islam as hermetic and sectarian, the pattern of drawing people together while protecting the individuals’ freedom of beliefs is part of the anthropological DNA of the religion. Within its a context of emergence and expansion and with regard to the inner endless subdivisions of the Islamic faith, the principle of pluralism was naturally forged. One of the best illustrations of its institutionalization can be found in the previously discussed Millet System established in the Ottoman Empire that doubtlessly contributed to making this regime “highly legitimate” for Muslims as well as for n...   [tags: Ottoman empire]

Strong Essays
1018 words (2.9 pages)