In Recreating History: Challenges in Balancing Accuracy and Emotiveness

1567 Words4 Pages

When working with early music, modern performers face challenges regarding stylistic and historical accuracy, given limited information on past performances, as well as notable differences in instruments available, technique, and performance practice. Furthermore, they must decide between different approaches that may better reflect the historical sound or intention of past performers, or choose to blend such extremes, creating varied interpretations.
Such challenges manifest explicitly when modern performs attempt to recreate medieval music, such as Gregorian chants. While modern scholars have deciphered most of medieval notations, chant melodies were primarily passed down through oral transmission, while the manuscripts simply served as reminders (HWM 37). Therefore, the exact way in which these chants were sung cannot be recovered. Modern iterations of chants usually preserve the tradition of employing all male voices, and exude appropriate solemnity in execution, even throughout intricate, melismatic passages meant for skilled soloists to heighten the glorification of God.
The limited accessibility to period instruments from the medieval era also contribute to the challenges in modern performances. Clues to historical performance practice, however, can often be found in contemporary art, such as pictures that illustrate the use of vielle, or fiddle and tambourines in instrumental accompaniment to medieval dance (WT 49). Passages accompanying Raimbaut’s works in chansonniers also suggest that troubadour songs such as his Kalenda maya are rooted in dance music, such as the estampie (WT 49). This type of information gives modern performers clues such as appropriate tempo and prominence of the singers. In a live performance by T...

... middle of paper ...

...but laugh[ed] and talk[ed] through the whole performance, without any restraint” (WT 196-197). Historical writings such as this enlighten the historical function of such performances. Modern performers can hence draw conclusions that inform their execution. In this case, for instance, one can assume that past singers must exaggerate their dramatic effect and vocals to fight for the attention of their audience.
Indeed, by considering the social and historical background of early music, modern performers can derive further clues to past performance practice beyond available scores, period instruments, and knowledge of historical techniques and styles. Using such knowledge, modern musicians can rise above challenges such as vague notation and lack of actual recordings to create informed, intent-driven performances of early music that reflect the contemporary context.

More about In Recreating History: Challenges in Balancing Accuracy and Emotiveness

Open Document