Gender Inequality And The Legal Profession Essay

Gender Inequality And The Legal Profession Essay

Length: 1426 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

According to Porter, “A ‘discourse community’ is a group of individuals bound by a common interest who communicate through approved channels and whose discourse is regulated. A discourse community shares assumptions about what objects are appropriate for examination and discussion, what constitutes ‘evidence’ and ‘validity’ and what formal conventions are followed (38-39).” These five texts collectively constitute a community of discourse through their application of common language norms, characteristics, patterns and rhetorical strategies. All of the authors are writing about corresponding ideas and discussing their identical goals; the prevalence of gender inequality in the legal profession and the unjust consequences derived from it. Similarly, all five sources intentions are to oppose the standard viewpoint that gender inequality has diminished and provide evidence to support this claim. Their ideas of remedying gender inequality in the legal profession overlap as well as contradict one another.
A discourse community is said to be resistant to internal criticism and self-scrutiny because all ideas that severely contrast the values and beliefs within the community are defined as being on the outside, as demonstrated in the texts. “The Discourse itself defines what counts as acceptable criticism” (Gee 162). All of the articles use similar rhetorical strategies by describing a problem in shared thinking; the common conception that the women’s equality dilemma has been resolved since formal regulations were instituted and women’s number have increased in the profession. Within both Brenner and Rhodes articles, both writers use a common language norm by referring to this conception as the ‘no problem’ problem. Furthermore, both ...

... middle of paper ... bias is in fact widely present among a law student sample” (41). Yet there is another layer to this, the recognition of opposition within the text is a strategized rhetorical use, it essentially denies and corrects a conventional way of thinking. The authors deny that the opposing views are conventional and then correct this way of thinking by arguing their claim and providing evidence to support it.
These texts help us to understand the essence of a discourse community. They all use a distinct way of writing applied with distinctive ways of interacting, thinking, believing and interpreting the gender inequality issue. However, these distinctions are not entirely distinct, there are no precedents defining how a community should act or think, alternatively it is the communities interpretation to determine what is denoted correct within their discourse. Included

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Gender Inequality And The Sexual Exploitation Of The Female Body Essay

- Gender Inequality and the Sexual Exploitation of the Female Body in Contemporary Global Society This anthropological study will define the issue of gender inequality and the sexual exploitation of the female body in contemporary global society. The physicality of female sexual exploitation is often defined by the commercial identification with the female body as an object for purchase. Prostitution is one form of the subjective identity of women as being submissive servants of a dominant patriarchal hierarchy in American society....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Gender studies]

Better Essays
1181 words (3.4 pages)

Gender Schema Theory And Psychoanalytic Theory Essay

- The following paper explores two different theories, gender schema theory and Psychoanalytic theory, which seek to explain sex and/or gender. Both theories that will be depicted throughout this paper has its own orientation towards what gender is, where it is located, and what this means for every day. Ryle (2013) claims the gender schema theory is constructed on the frameworks of both cognitive development and social learning theory which seeks to explain how individuals become gendered in society....   [tags: Gender, Gender role, Gender studies, Role]

Better Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Inequality For Women During The Nineteenth Century Essay

- Inequality for Women Women in the nineteenth century lived in a time period where their lives were defined by gender. Men and women were always viewed differently in every aspect of their lives. At the beginning of the century, women were allowed just a few of the legal, social, or political rights that men were allowed to partake in that are now taken for granted. Women were not allowed to vote, sue someone or be sued, they could not vote, could not testify in a court case, they had limited control over personal property after they were married because their husbands took the roles of their fathers who used to have control of their property, and they rarely were granted custody over their...   [tags: Marriage, Family, Husband, Middle class]

Better Essays
1689 words (4.8 pages)

Inequality Essay

- Inequality In any society, actions taken in the name of the nation state need to be seen as ‘just’ in order to preserve legitimacy. When they are not seen as just then we get discontent and then often challenges to the authority of the state. We could argue that in simple terms, society is held together in part, by a type of social contract whereby individuals agree to abide by state law in return for the protection of the state. In order for this to work however, the majority of people would need to believe both that the law is generally beneficial to them, and that the administration of the law is fair and just....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
3076 words (8.8 pages)

Social Inequality And Gender Inequality Essay

- It is safe to say that one must experience some sort of inequality at least once in their lifetime. Inequality is arguably the biggest threat to people in society today and almost any human being can acknowledge the fact that the increase of inequality is an pressing issue. While there are discernible inequality issues such as Economic inequality, Healthcare inequality, Income inequality, Educational inequality and many more, Social inequality and Gender inequality are matters that surround us everyday, yet are not being treated enough of as an issue where change needs to be brought about....   [tags: Gender, Stereotype, Economic inequality]

Better Essays
1779 words (5.1 pages)

Essay on Gender Inequality in the Accounting Profession

- RESEARCH: This formal report will utilize mainly online resources will attain information on gender inequality. These sources will include scholarly articles and reports, journals, statistics on the relevant topic, and some print sources that can be accessed from the internet. BACKGROUND: For centuries there has been gender discrimination and inequality, most often towards women. At one time or another, in many different counties, there have been laws that denied women the right to go to school, to travel, the right to hold property, to enter certain occupations, and many others....   [tags: Flexible Schedules, Professional Conduct]

Better Essays
2010 words (5.7 pages)

Essay about Inequality in American Society from 1815 to 1860

- One of the greatest barriers between women and equality during the antebellum era was the doctrine of separate spheres. The doctrine coined two distinctive spheres: the one of men and that of women. Men, physically and mentally stronger, were considered to be suitable for the world politics, work and war. Women, on the other hand, with the nature of being soft and delicate, were linked to domestic tasks such as cooking, cleaning and motherhood. Prior to the Antebellum period, as most American families led a harsh and tough farm life where field work and domestic chores were closely related, the distinction between the two spheres were marginal and women were also considered to be just as vig...   [tags: Underground Railroad]

Better Essays
2455 words (7 pages)

Gender Inequality in Australia Essays

- With a Queen as the head of the Monarchy of England, Quentin Bryce as Governor General for Australia and Julia Gillard as elected Prime Minister for Australia; it is an easy assumption that gender inequality in Australia is dead and buried. Wrong. That assumption would be like saying that that because Barack Obama is the elected president of America, racism no longer exists on its soil. Racism and Gender inequality follow extremely similar lines however the line of gender inequality is not always clear....   [tags: Gender Inequality Essays]

Better Essays
1656 words (4.7 pages)

Gender Inequality Of The Workplace Essay

- Gender Inequality in the Workplace The Gender inequality issue has been around for many year and it affects many people regardless of gender and race. Most people think gender inequality is a specific female problem, but some males also experience it. The research done may seem that the workplace is unequal, but that 's the case. Some of the so called "proof" about female gender inequality is miss used and misunderstood. There is gender inequality in the workplace, but the workplace can be gender biased based on different factors....   [tags: Gender, Male, Female, Economic inequality]

Better Essays
1544 words (4.4 pages)

Gender Inequality in the 1970s Essay

- There is no upper limit to the risks men are willing to take in order to succeed, and if there is an upper limit for women, they will succeed less.” (Clay Shirky, 202) Shirky, the author of “A Rant about Women” argues that women must become more aggressive and demanding to ultimately achieve their goals. No matter how society reacts, men take on any action, bypassing the “Golden Rule” to achieve their goals and desires. On the other hand, women lack this procedure in their search for self-promotion, as Shirky argues....   [tags: women, solutions, stereotype, gender inequality]

Better Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)