Evaluating A New Employee Selection Procedure Essay example

Evaluating A New Employee Selection Procedure Essay example

Length: 1111 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Introduction
We are aware that an organisation’s most important resource is its people and as the airline industry faces rapidly expanding competition (PwC US, 2014), one way of keeping the competitive advantage reasonably lies in the talent they can acquire and retain (Woods & West, 2010). Psychologist have found that workers differ in productivity and therefore in value (Schmidt & Hunter, 1981). A good assessment and selection process can add a great amount of value to an organisation, or if not done correctly, the differences in value per employee can amass to a loss in billions (Schmidt et al., 1981). In this case, the unstructured interview, a poor selection method, is used. The company also relies on external recruitment services and has difficulties retaining its staff, as there is a high turnover. Long tenure employees are underperforming and line-managers seem to deal inappropriately with staff. The aim of this report is to outline a new employee selection procedure that can attract and retain those that fit best with the varying roles in this organisation. Moreover, the objective is to leave a fair, ethical and rewarding experience with the applicant. The analysis is based on the company’s archival records, the incumbents, supervisors and external analysts.

Selection Process Methods and Design
Job-analysis
The accurate job analysis (JA) is recommended as the first and vital stage of the new robust selection process and requires skill and expertise. It systematically collects and analyses any job-related information (Ash, 1988) affects all subsequent selection decisions (Morgeson & Campion, 1997). It forms the foundation for all human resource activities, and its purpose can range from performance appraisal to job redes...


... middle of paper ...


...(Woods et al., 2010). Managers are likely to analyse and interpret, organise and execute, enterprise and perform and lead and decide, competencies which are all highly related to overall job performance (OJP) (Bartram, 2002). Following the trend, this suggests that OJP ratings are primarily influenced by task performance, rather than by the contextual competencies, and therefore task-focussed assessment by a competency framework is recommended. However, it is very important that the personnel who conduct the assessment are properly trained, so that a clear link to the competencies is evident and each criterion is assessed more than once. Using a combination of tools is recommended to achieve an accurate assessment: an application form, a SJT and a GMA test are suggested for pre-selection and a competency-based panel interview for the final decision making process.


Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Improvements to the Selection Process Essay

- The Uniform Guidelines state a statistical test can determine whether the use of selection procedures lead to adverse impact. To conduct a test, the number of minority applicants selected is divided by the number of minority applicants. Then, the number of non-minority applicants selected divided by the number of non-minority applicants. My organization should apply the Four-Fifth Rule by calculates the ratios of each group and evaluating whether the minority group is at least 80% of the most favorably treated group....   [tags: Diversity, Minorities, Roles]

Better Essays
1100 words (3.1 pages)

IMPACT OF RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION ON ORGANIZATIONAL EFFECTIVENESS Essay

- 2.1 Recruitment and Selection Schein (1976) discussed that human resource functions are to well defined and well connected to the needs of organization, not only the needs of individuals. Many times the hiring is a system of short run replacement and is not watched for long run functionality. Ahmad and Schroeder (2002) more deeply discussed that usually in the process of hiring, organizations use to focus on the technical skills of the employees, not the behavioral traits which fruits to a short run benefit, not in the long run....   [tags: Business Management ]

Better Essays
1630 words (4.7 pages)

Evaluating Employee Responses, Knowledge, Attitudes, Behavior And Impact On The Organization

- Case Study One Question 1[Answer] A proposal to evaluate the exercise should contain evaluating employee responses, knowledge, attitudes, behaviour and impact on the organization. A number of subjective and objective methods can be used in grouping. The evaluation should also contain a cost-benefit analysis use the simple formula: revenue – cost = profit. Question 2[Answer] A low-cost method contains evaluating employee responses and attitudes directly follow their training. An expensive program would include associating training scores with job performance some months after the training....   [tags: Human resource management, Management]

Better Essays
1097 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Evaluating The Selection Process Is A Method For Selection

- In the world of fierce competition between businesses, some of the utmost important decisions that organizational leaders are faced with are decisions related to the projects they agree to undertake. Every organization has to determine how to make their product or service stand out, this typically leads to project proposals. The majority of organizations have a process, some formal and some informal, to select and prioritize projects. Once a project proposal has been submitted to the organization, there are various factors that need to be considered before the project is to officially begin....   [tags: Net present value, Project management, Cash flow]

Better Essays
872 words (2.5 pages)

Evaluating The Selection Process Of An Organization Essay examples

- In a world of fierce competition between businesses, one of the utmost important decisions that organizational leaders are faced with are decisions related to the projects they agree to undertake to better meet organizational goals. Every organization has to determine how to make their product or service stand out, this ordinarily leads to project proposals. The majority of organizations have a process, some formal and some informal, to select and prioritize projects. Once a project proposal has been submitted to the organization, there are various factors that need to be considered before the project is to officially begin....   [tags: Net present value, Project management, Cash flow]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Use Of Selection Procedure For The Project Team Essay

- BIM Use Selection Procedure After determining the goal of the project, the project team must be identified the task that will be done by using the BIM. The uses of BIM should be for the purpose of better result and overall for the success of the project. In this connection, the project team must select the task in which they will use BIM by using the appropriate selection procedure. The Project team will develop a BIM selection worksheet which includes BIM use, Value to project (high, medium, low), value to responsible party (contractor, facility manager, designer), capability rating (1,2,3), additional resources or competencies required for implementation of the project, notes and decision...   [tags: Project management, Management, Team, Project]

Better Essays
745 words (2.1 pages)

Sexual Selection and Natural Selection Essay

- Selection is the functional relationship between phenotypes and fitness. Natural selection is the production of organisms according to their physical attributes whereby off springs of the younger generations takes the strong, desired and inheritable aspects of their parents. They become more adapted to the environment although some does well than others according to their individual traits which are attributed to their phenotypes (Sinervo, 1997). According to Charles Darwin, fitness can be described in three different forms of selection which interferes with the mean of phenotypic traits in a population....   [tags: Natural Selection, Evolution Essays]

Better Essays
538 words (1.5 pages)

Natural Selection And Genetic Selection Essay

- “Animals are adapted to their conditions in subtle and marvelous ways (Boyd, R., & Silk, J. 1997:2).” It is commonly recognized that Darwin identified adaptations through Natural Selection: traits that are advantageous to survival will be retained in the population through reproduction. Natural Selection further indicates that traits will survive when they are most beneficial to an individual’s fitness. While Natural Selection and Mutation effectively explains adaptive fitness qualities and variance among populations, it fails to explain species beautiful ornamental traits that are not necessarily beneficial to fitness....   [tags: Natural selection, Charles Darwin, Male, Sex]

Better Essays
1164 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on International Market Selection

- I. INTRODUCTION The international business development has heightened the importance of international market selection (IMS) of companies, especially for their exporting strategy. However, not many companies really comprehend the geographical, social, economic characteristics of foreign countries in comparison with their home countries (Cavusgil, 1985). This fact has challenged many studies to create the optimal approach for IMS. The major question is: Which foreign market should a company enter....   [tags: Market Selection, Internal Values]

Better Essays
3006 words (8.6 pages)

The Jury Selection Procedure in the English Legal System Essay

- The Jury Selection Procedure in the English Legal System The theory behind modern day trial by jury can be traced back some eight hundred years, to the sixty-three clauses of the Magna Carta (1215). One of these clauses reads; “ No free man shall be arrested, or imprisoned, or deprived of his property, or outlawed, or exiled, or in any way destroyed, nor shall we go against him or send him against, unless by legal judgement of his peers, or by the law of the land.” The Magna Carta gave English nobles and freemen the right to trial via a panel of their peers....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)