Euthanasia: The James Rachel and Sullivan´s Arguments Essay

Euthanasia: The James Rachel and Sullivan´s Arguments Essay

Length: 1424 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Sullivan versus Rachel’s on euthanasia I will show that James Rachel’s argument is logically stronger than Sullivan’s argument. I will present examples given by both authors regarding their arguments and also on their conclusions about it. I will explain both of the author’s logical strengths and weaknesses in their arguments. I will give the examples given by both authors on how they prove their arguments to be true and later I will decide whose argument is stronger based on their strengths and weaknesses. I will give one of Rachel’s main strong arguments and one of Sullivan’s very weak arguments. I will also show if both of the author’s premises follow from the conclusion. And at the end I will give my opinion on my personal reasons on whose I think makes more sense in presenting their arguments.
In Sullivan’s argument he shows that active euthanasia is wrong for many reasons. I will tell you his most important reasons he uses to prove his conclusion. Sullivan’s conclusion to his argument on active euthanasia is saying that active euthanasia is not permitted, that it’s wrong. He defends the American medical association because it says that active euthanasia is the killing of a human life, with lethal injection, which the AMA does not approve of because it’s wrong according to them. Moving forward, the reasons why he says that is because he says that moral intention is more important than the action basically he’s saying that intention is more likely to determine whether an act is correct or wrong. For instance like euthanasia according to him it isn’t wrong to let the patient die because your intentions aren’t bad, your intentions aren’t to kill the patient. With active euthanasia your actually doing something according to ...

... middle of paper ...’s argument. I have shown that intention has nothing to do with how active euthanasia is being performed and I have shown that James Rachel’s has great examples on explaining that there is no difference in passive euthanasia or active euthanasia. Thirdly I have shown that James Rachel’s premises follow from his conclusions not just from the conclusion itself. Also I have given one of his main weaknesses in his argument. Moving forward to Sullivan I have explained how his reasons make no sense according to James Rachel’s. I have also shown Sullivan’s main weaknesses and one of his strong points against Rachel’s. I also gave some of Rachel’s weaknesses but after all I think that I have proven that Rachel’s argument is stronger than Thomas Sullivan for many reasons. Lastly, I have given my own ideas and theories of which argument I think is better.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Euthanasia: Utiliarianism and Morality of Death Essay

- ... This is where medical ethics are introduced, hospital protocols, and the patient’s community and personal religious views. Passive euthanasia is the term coined to withholding or withdrawing medical treatment that would otherwise prolong the life (AMJS 73). Here is where the term euthanasia can become blurred and where family members think health care workers are killing their family members. In some situations, that is completely true. Relating to our discussion in class, when I terminally extubated a patient due to her religious practices which inhibited her from receiving blood products; ironically, that being the only thing that could have saved her in the end....   [tags: moral philosophy, the right to die]

Strong Essays
1943 words (5.6 pages)

The Moral Permissibility of Legalizing Active Euthanasia Essay

- The Moral Permissibility of Legalizing Active Euthanasia To date, in the united States of America, active euthanasia has been seen as unacceptable in legal terms. However, the issue is not so clear in moral terms among the public, and especially among the medical community. In fact, nearly half of the doctors in the United States say that they would prescribe active euthanasia under certain circumstances. The law that prohibits active euthanasia restricts many people from doing what they feel morally justified to do....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1436 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Arguments For And Against Euthanasia

- Euthanasia is the practice of ending an individual's life in order to relieve them from an incurable disease or unbearable suffering. The term euthanasia is derived from the Greek word for "good death" and originally referred to as “intentional killing” ( Patelarou, Vardavas, Fioraki, Alegakis, Dafermou, & Ntzilepi, 2009). Euthanasia is a controversial topic which has raised a great deal of debate globally. Although euthanasia has received great exposure in the professional media, there are some sticky points that lack clarity and need to be addressed....   [tags: Euthanasia Pros and Cons]

Strong Essays
1956 words (5.6 pages)

Euthanasia in Australia Essay example

- Although euthanasia is a complex and controversial subject, under certain conditions people should have the right to decide to end their own lives. Is euthanasia murder or mercy. We need to understand what Mercy, Murder and Euthanasia are before we can form any opinion. (Oxford dictionary) Mercy / (say mersee) Compassionate or kindly forbearance shown towards: an offender, an enemy, or other person in one's power; compassion, pity, or benevolence. Murder / (say merduh) Unlawful killing of a human being by an act done: with intention to kill or to inflict grievous bodily harm....   [tags: Argument for Euthanasia]

Strong Essays
1842 words (5.3 pages)

Euthanasia Devalues Human Life Essay

- “Euthanasia is the practice of ending the life of a patient to limit the patient’s suffering. The patient in question would typically be terminally ill or experiencing great pain and suffering. The word “euthanasia” itself comes from the Greek words “eu” (good) and “thanatos” (death). The idea is that instead of condemning someone to a slow, painful, and undignified death, euthanasia would allow the patient to experience a relatively good death.” The technical definition of euthanasia is the act of ending life painlessly, often someone suffering from an incurable illness....   [tags: Arguments Against Euthanasia]

Strong Essays
2070 words (5.9 pages)

Rebutting Arguments to Legalize Euthanasia or Assisted Suicide Essay

- Rebutting Arguments to Legalize Euthanasia or Assisted Suicide      This essay focuses on several of the most common arguments in favor of the legalization of euthanasia or assisted suicide - and rebuts them. The language is simple, or, as they say, in layman's terms so as to be easily understandable. The sources are from professional journals, internet websites, and news outlets.   The first common argument favoring euthanasia or assisted suicide is this: "Since euthanasia and assisted suicide take place anyway, isn't it better to legalize them so they'll be practiced under careful guidelines and so that doctors will have to report these activities?" That sounds good but it doesn't wor...   [tags: Euthanasia Physician Assisted Suicide]

Strong Essays
1719 words (4.9 pages)

Euthanasia is Moral Essay

- Recent debates over active euthanasia, "killing" a terminally ill patient, in Holland, has raised the question whether euthanasia is immoral or a simple human right. Doctors seem to have no doubt. They made an oath. The definition of Euthanasia depends on whether it is active or passive. Active Euthanasia I only allowed in Holland, and it means that the doctor takes direct measures to put a patient to sleep, whereas passive Euthanasia only involves stopping pill consumption, or stopping treatment....   [tags: Argument for Euthanasia]

Strong Essays
2629 words (7.5 pages)

Euthanasia Essay

- Euthanasia is an action that result in the death of a person. There are four types of euthanasia, such as voluntary active euthanasia, nonvoluntary active euthanasia, voluntary passive euthanasia, and nonvoluntary passive euthanasia. Among the four types of euthanasia, voluntary active euthanasia or VAE is the most controversial ethical issue in the United States. It is the killing of a competent patient who decided to end his/her suffering by ending his/her life with the help of the physician....   [tags: Philosophy, Immanuel Kant]

Strong Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Euthanasia Essay

- Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide Individual cases presented to justify legalizing physician assisted suicide fail to deal with underlying medical failures to control pain, creating an illusion of control over death, and not acknowledging the thousands of patients murdered inappropriately. This is an interesting and a very controversial issue in today’s society. Euthanasia has negative sides, it can hurt society, and everyone needs to learn more bout it. The word Euthanasia is Greek in origin....   [tags: Euthanasia Essays]

Strong Essays
2837 words (8.1 pages)

Euthanasia Essay

- Euthanasia A considerable portion of society supports euthanasia an instrument of preserving dignity in the terminally ill, bringing peace to the incurable, and closure to their families. Some Americans believe to maintain the democratic values upon which the Unites States stands in balance, they must possess the right to determine the applicable time to end a person’s life.(Chapman 209) The more widely help opinion comes in the form of opposition. The majority strikes out against euthanasia, targeting it as an instrument of the divine, a tool that humans, above democratic values and inalienable rights, dare not employ themselves lest they suffer the wrath of imposing on Almighty God....   [tags: Free Euthanasia Essay]

Free Essays
672 words (1.9 pages)