To Helen Tone

411 Words1 Page

Body Paragraph 3 (Tone)
Edgar Allan Poe and Hilda Doolittle both use tone to convey their perspective and opinion on the Helen of Troy. In Poe’s “To Helen”, he makes several allusions to the “glory that was Greece and the grandeur that was Rome” when describing Helen’s beauty. These descriptions refer to the significance of the classical period, where the architecture, arts, and philosophies developed would help shape the rest of civilization. Poe uses a formal and admiring tone when he compares Helen to cultures that are still held in high respect in modern times, deeming her an embodiment of the impact from this specific era. He also references Psyche, a character of Greek mythology in the third stanza, saying “The agate lamp within thy hand! …show more content…

Poe equates it to Helen’s endless love for Paris, the Prince of Troy, for whom she left Greece behind and continued to stand beside during the treachery of battle. Poe creates a tone of awe towards Helen’s perpetual beauty and devotion, creating that feeling in his word choice and allusions to Helen. On the contrary, H.D. uses a harsh tone, condemning Helen with bitter hatred. In the second stanza of “Helen”, she tells of “past enchantments” suggesting Helen’s endless loyalty to Paris was a frivolous fling, extending her anger to Paris and Troy for their protection of an immature and unfaithful woman simply because of how she looked. In the third stanza, H.D talks of “past ills” where she displays her bitterness at Helen’s decisions and choices. Helen chose to leave her husband, her duty as Queen, and chose to have the blood of thousands on her hands all for the pleasure of a pretty man. H.D finds these “past ills” evidence towards Helen’s treachery and betrayal of Greece, and finds no point in her prominent worship by people like Poe despite Helen’s beauty. These statements create an air of betrayal from H.D., who’s allusions to Helen’s relationships as idle and immature things show how this horrible cause of a 10-year war created

Open Document