The White People 'And Bruno Bettelheims' Use Of Fairy Stories

1649 Words4 Pages

Fairy Stories are thought of as influential works that are known to create fantasized magical worlds that the reader can dive into. They have changed with the times and have been adjusted over the years so they can be more sensible for children. Fairy Stories are diverse in their plots and their orientations; yet, they are all structured in the same manner. They generally tell a tale and at the end of the story the reader is left to ponder the moral of the story. In his essay “On Fairy Stories”, J.R. R Tolkien is wary about the influence of fairy stories and explained that there are many ways to interpret and incorporate the tales into our lives while Bruno Bettelheim author of “Use of Enchantment” believes fairy stories are an essential component …show more content…

In Tolkien’s work “On Fairy Stories” he stated that “Fairy Stories were plainly not primarily concerned with possibility, but with desirability. If they awakened desire, satisfying it while often whetting it unbearably, they succeeded” (19). His statement suggests that fairy stories are fundamentally meant for a diverse audience and, regardless of age, if the reader benefits and finds an innate love and comfort in the story then it is a successful work of literature. Machen’s story “The White People” detailed the imagination and the influence of childhood stories that a young girl heard from her nurse. The girl created a world of her own. She found thrill and comfort in the stories told by her nurse and though she was frightened sometimes, the stories were very important to her. This fact is proven in the short story shortly after the nurse was scolded by the father for telling her stories when the girl stated “I would never whisper a word of what [the nurse] told me and if I did I should be bitten by the great black snake that lived in the pool in the woods” (Machen 133). As a child, she exposed herself to the harsh punishment of becoming aware of one of the scariest creatures she knew just so she could continue her story telling sessions with her nurse. This reiterates Tolkien’s claim that successful fairy stories have a great influence on the reader. The child’s whole world …show more content…

Bettelheim’s “Use of Enchantment” he explains how important fair-tales are for a child’s development. Children are willing to believe whatever they are told and they are inclined to see the good in all that they experience, making them vulnerable to influences of all kind (Tolkien 12). A child’s personality and thought process is developed over time based on the way they perceive the world. In Bettelheim’s essay, he stated, “To offer a child rational thought as his major instrument for sorting out his feelings and understanding the world will only confuse and restrict him” (119). This statement suggests that a child’s mental growth and personality advancements are dependent on many factors. The girl in Machen’s story was told about a princess that practices witchcraft and ended up killing her suitors. Growing up on fairy tales with a lack of maternal care could have given the girl the wrong notion about the moral of the story. She could have interpreted the story in different ways, either thinking that the acts of the princess were wrong or that she could do whatever she wanted and not get caught otherwise she too would face a punishment like the witch princess. This notion explains the fact that children need to be nurtured and directed toward the positive aspects of life. They need to be taught the difference between right and wrong not just with the use of fairy

Open Document