Whether visitors have a moral right to access certain areas is a turbulent and much debated topic. I do not believe that areas of the planet should be restricted for those whom are adequately prepared and able to travel. However, I also understand the concerns and issues associated, especially from an environmental sustainability perspective. As a result, I am not opposed to introducing restrictions to limit the effects as well as capacity. In regards, to the case of whether tourists have the moral right to access Mt Everest, I again feel that if properly regulated any person whom are adequately prepared and able should be able to access Mt Everest. I believe the best way to navigate this issue is to place requirements upon tour operators and …show more content…
These are the best government agencies to take responsibility through the public sector as they have the knowledge of the area and the power to regulate policies, tour operators, and visitors. Thus, being the best equipped to implement regulations on a public resource, such as Mt Everest. The Department of Tourism for Nepal has already taken some action as an amendment in its proposed Tourism Act was approved. By banning foreign solo climbers from attempting Mt Everest is an attempt to reduce risks faced whilst climbing Everest. The Mountaineering Expedition Regulation has also delegated more power towards the Department of Tourism allowing the department to independently function. This announcement is hopeful in securing more jobs and ensuring the rights of Sherpas, Nepali climbing guides, who are often overworked, rushed and pushed beyond their capabilities into dangerous circumstances to keep clients satisfied. Perpetrating clients are often tourists who are motivated by their need for recognition travel to obtain status by proving to themselves and others they are capable of achieving something or are better than those around them (Ivanov, …show more content…
By restricting access, it may hurt the economy of surrounding areas and cause resistance with tour operators. Tour operators may place the responsibility solely upon the Nepal Government by emphasizing the economic and employment efforts evident that they, as businesses, are taking care of what they see as they’re responsibility (Hall & Lew, 2009). However, tour operators as stakeholders themselves must accept higher responsibility and actively work with government agencies for the strategic plans and policies to be effective. Whether knowingly or not, individual tourists are causing damage to resources they’re consuming, as stakeholders they have responsibility for the impacts of their purchasing decisions (Hall & Lew, 2009). I would recommend that the Nepal Government implement tighter permit restrictions, including how many issued per annum as well as limit of person per permit. Aiming to reduce numbers, this practice requires participation from stakeholders to be successful. The Nepal Mountain Training Academy (NMTA) has a center used for educational and training purposes. This center could be formed into attraction of its own with tailored Mt Everest exhibitions, as was similarly done with the International Antarctic Centre (IAC) in Christchurch, New Zealand. My personal experience highlights at the IAC were travelling in the Hagglund transport and experiencing an Artic storm. As a
Chapter 7: In chapter 7 Krakauer talks about how Everest has changed from a professionals trek to anyone's trek. He explains that many inexperienced people have climbed Mount Everest with the help of sherpas and guides. He also mentions about the determination of Everest and how in some instances in history people who weren't allowed into Tibet or Nepal but they snuck in and managed to climb and summit Everest
Everest in 1996. This became the deadliest expedition to ever climb with 15 people losing their lives. Krakauer explains his intrinsic motivations to accept this challenge and many of the mistakes that helped lead to the disasters of that day. He includes himself, and explicitly blames himself for at least one person's death. The experience affects him profoundly, and in addition to telling the story, the book focuses on how Krakauer is forever changed as a result of what happened. All of the clients have difficulty adjusting to the altitude, tiring easily, losing weight and moving slowly. The climbers' experience in mountain climbing and at high altitudes varies some of them are quite qualified, others very inexperienced and highly reliant on the
Climbing Mount Everest is a horrific and thrilling experience that 290 people have died attempting to complete. In the novel “Into Thin Air” written by Jon Krakauer, Krakauer goes through his own journey of climbing Mount Everest and how commercialized the climbing of Everest had really become. In his journey he explains how climbers have paid as much as $65,000 to join a guided group that would lead them to the summit. The author bluntly states that some of the novices were not qualified to climb Mount Everest. With this amateurity it only made the journey twice as much difficult and dangerous. Unfortunately, a terrible blizzard struck Mount Everest within minutes of them reaching the top. For all of the climbers on the mountain, the blizzard turned what was to be a successful climb for all concerned into a nightmare. Because of poor planning, several of the climbers found themselves in a desperate situation that they had no
Hall’s success rate was not only due to his attention to detail but his attention to safety and the knowledge that without the Sherpas, any attempt at guiding on Everest would be disastrous. Hall’s ability to plan and coordinate ensured that his clients had plenty of food and supplies and that they became acclimatized to the higher altitudes. Each base camp ...
On May 10th, 1996, a mountaineering expedition turned into a disaster when an unexpected storm hit Mount Everest and eventually took twelve people’s lives along with it. While some events are agreed on the disaster, what actually happened that night and the events leading up to it are heavily debated. This debate can be seen in the books Into Thin Air by Jon Krakauer and The Climb by Anatoli Boukreev where they disagree on crucial details leading up to the climb. Although Anatoli was the better climber, Jon Krakauer’s account is more credible due to his knowledge on the subject, great character, and determination to show the most honest account of the story possible.
Have you ever wanted to prove to everyone that you are a hard worker that is willing to give up everything to go on an adventure? If this is you than Everest is the perfect place for you. A great deal of Everest’s dangers are expressed in his book which should either inspire you to try this journey or sway you away from the treacherous mountain. In the story, “ Into Thin Air,” by Jon Krakauer a true story is told of a dangerous voyage up and down Everest. The climb up was arduous and long according to Jon, but the climbers sacrificed everything to get to the top, which most of the climbers achieved. However, emotions shifted when a storm swooped in and killed many of the climbers that were stuck on the summit, around 12-19 in total. The devices
Climbing Mt. Everest is an accomplishment that only a limited number of people can say they have accomplished. Despite statistics that illustrate most fail or die trying, numerous people are drawn to the mountain each year and truly believe they can be among that elite group. In the spring of 1996, Jon Krakauer, a journalist for the adventure magazine Outside and a passionate climber himself, was offered the opportunity to climb Mt. Everest. The original offer was to join an Adventure Consultants team led by Rob Hall, a respected and well known guide, climb to base camp and then write a story on the commercialism that had penetrated this incredibly risky but addicting sport. Without much hesitation Krakauer accepted the offer but not to just go to base camp; he wanted the top. The expedition started out as predicted but an unexpected storm the day of the summit push turned this expedition into the most devastating expedition of all time. Krakauer was changed for life; an article on the commercialism surrounding the mountain would no longer suffice. Into Th...
First of all, climbers should not be able to have rights to rescue services because, when the mountain rangers are saving others they are putting their own lives at risk. In a newspaper article it said,
Many climbers are infatuated with reputability. In a number of cases, self-esteem is easily influenced by external opinions. Western society and its expansive economy have left an unparalleled impact on the nation’s collective psyche; many feel that wealth and peer-determined success are the keys to happiness. Baker and Simon point out, “risk taking in a remote and spectacular environment can provide the material for constructing personal reputation and status” (185). Impressionable minds aspire towards social acceptance in order to find some sense of release; mountain climbing is an ideal activity for those looking to impress. Without a defined sense of self-actualization, individuals cannot add true meaning to their lives. Additionally, a credible claim to being first can inspire emotional security. Individuals seek claims on merits distinguished by narrow categories of self-identity (Simon 190). The first woman and cancer survivor were inspired by self-discovery on their Everest expeditions. Many climbers feel that: “Getting to the top of any given mountain was considered much less important than how one got there: prestige was carned by tackling the most unforgiving routes with minimal equipment, in the boldest style imaginable” (Krakauer 23). Psychologically, the gesture can add positive reinforcement to one’s individuality. An individual’s cultural
These experienced climbers have the worst job of all, with an astonishing “annual fatality rate of 4,035 per 100,000 full-time” over these past ten years(Morrow 2). Apart from having to guide tourist climbers many times during the season, they have to carrying necessary equipment for them making the trip even more hazardous. For example, they drag across the ice large “loads of fuel, food, ropes, oxygen and tents for clients”(Morrow 3}. That’s not all, the Everest climbing company and the Nepalese government make a fortune each year with their tourist attraction, and give Sherpa a pity amount of their earnings; and these climbers put themselves at risk each time. To prove it, “Hardly any this money is received by the Sherpa themselves”, even though their lives are in danger; if anything happened to a Sherpa they will leave “their family in economic crisis”(Morrow 3). The Sherpas have little to no life insurance benefits, they can be killed and their families would barely be taken care of. This can seen when an avalanche cost the lives of 13, and in response to a strike it “would only provide a pittance of 40,000 rupees, or $US410”(Morrow 1). Moreover since tourists are the ones paying and Sherpas, they are better suited and occupied while
Climbing makes for a difficult expedition, you need to give up the wrappers when you was ascending. You need to give up the heavy things, you need to give up your wrappers, and you need to give yourselves. Sometimes we need to give up our lives to climb the mount Everest. According to snow storm, the energy, the oxygen and the people who desired prove themselves the spring’s 96s expedition to mountain Everest was destined to be the most tragic.
The magnificent Mt. Everest; a scenic natural location that has been a place famous for mountaineering for years. However, people have been debating whether or not Mt.Everest should be closed down temporarily for safety precautions or if the dangers should be supported. I am an opponent towards mountaineering because of the dangers involving both the people and nature involved.
Everest is an unbelievable mountain that has taken the lives of a number of the greatest climbers in history. It was my job to ensure that clients make it up that treacherous mountain safely. My name is Rob Hall. I was the main guide and cofounder of a climbing company called Adventure Consultants. My friend, Gary Ball, and I used to be professional climbers. Together we succeeded in climbing to the highest summit on each of the seven continents in seven months. This was our greatest achievement. After this, we decided to start our own company guiding clients up large mountains. In May 1992, we successfully led six clients to the summit of Everest. Unfortunately, Gary died of cerebral edema in October 1993 during an attempt on the world’s sixth-tallest mountain. He died in my arms and the next day I buried him in a crevasse. Despite the pain that his death had caused me, I continued guiding for our company and eventually led thirty-nine climbers to the summit of Everest.
Given the recent Everest tragedy over the weekend with the biggest loss of lives to date, this case study rings particularly poignant. It’s hard to think of a higher-staked situation than making a summit bid for Mount Everest. The responsibility in such a trek weighs heavy on the leader, but does not need to fall on his shoulders alone. Had Fischer been more willing to share credit, fostering a team-oriented environment, he might still be around today to bask in the glory of his ambitious undertaking.
Mount Everest, the world’s highest point at 29,035 feet, is a special trophy among high altitude mountaineers. Standing atop the world’s highest point a hypoxic climber clad in a fluorescent down suit is above everything else on the planet, for a moment that individual can reach farther into the sky than any other. Arms raised in a victorious salute, a climber feels like they have conquered something that few others ever have, and justifiably so. The summit is usually the final fruition of months, sometimes years of planning, weeks of travel and acclimatization, and days of endless plodding at a feeble, learning-to-walk pace.