Takaki The Harmful Myth Of Asian Superiority Summary

668 Words2 Pages

In Takaki’s The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority, he clearly and effectively states that the belief that Asians Americans are a “model minority” is not true and racist. This fallacy has caused harm to this culture and is a negative comparison with other minorities. His purpose was to inform the reader that even “good” stereotypes can damage ethnicities. Takaki’s essay was effective, however he lacked a counter argument which made him seem biased. Takaki starts of the essay by explaining the harsh comparisons that the mainstream media made “If Asian Americans can make it, many politicians and pundits ask, why can't African Americans?”(1). He states that those comparisons “pit minorities against each other”(1) which is true. Takaki then explains that the comparisons are not fair since they are not taking into account the hardships that the African Americans have endured. Some being; racism, and the economy. Soon after, Takaki begins to use an abundance of logos all throughout his essay to prove his point, and that conveys his passion for his writing. He begins by showing statistics comparing the earnings of Asian Americans to Caucasians and proves that the Asian Americans that do earn more than Caucasians have “more workers per family”.(1) He goes into details by explaining that even the Japanese Americans which have been praised for their “upward …show more content…

In 1988, Koreans in the New York metropolitan area earned only 68 percent of the median income of non-Asians”. More than three-quarters of the Koreans that had an education and had prestigious careers, became no more than shopkeepers once they arrived in the United States. Tataki made it clear that Korean shopkeepers did not make a lot of money for example, “Korean shopkeepers do not actually earn very much:17,000 to 35,000 a year, usually representing that income from the labor of an entire

Open Document