Similarities Between I Have A Dream And Letter From Birmingham Jail

963 Words2 Pages

During his lifetime, Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. wrote and delivered speeches about inequality in America. Two of those writings, his famous “I Have a Dream” speech and his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” had similar themes but were written for different audiences. Both works were pleas for people to listen and take notice of what was going on around them. While the “I Have a Dream” speech was delivered to an audience of 20,000+ civilians and civil rights marchers in Washington D.C., the “Birmingham Jail” letter addressed a smaller audience of religious leaders. In 1963, Dr. King was invited by the Southern Christian Leadership Conference to bring his message of nonviolent street protest to Birmingham, Alabama. Birmingham had the reputation …show more content…

As the protests progressed, a group of white clergymen denounced them in an open letter to the Birmingham News. Expressing a fear of violence, they demanded an end to the demonstrations against segregated lunch counters, restrooms and stores, calling them "unwise and untimely." These men were among the most prominent religious leaders in the state of Alabama, representing Methodist, Presbyterian, Baptist and Roman Catholic churches, as well as Reform Judaism. After King was jailed on a charge of parading without a permit, he wrote the "Letter from a Birmingham Jail" to answer the clergymen. It was reprinted in several magazines and served as pre- and post-publicity for the March on Washington. The letter brought attention to the Birmingham movement and added to King's fame. If the "I Have a Dream" speech showcases Martin Luther King Jr.'s oratorical skills, the "Letter From a Birmingham Jail" exhibits the depth of his intellect. To make its points, imagery from each of the religions is used to make the point that segregation relegated black Americans to "the status of things." Despite the clergymen's pleas for moderation and patience, King knew that the struggles of black Americans could not …show more content…

He begins his speech by uniting and addressing the audience. Next, a brief lesson on the background of the speech is presented, and then he moves on to the main idea. He uses metaphors (“We’ve come to our nation’s capital to cash a check.”) He argues that when the Founding Fathers wrote the words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to every American. This note was a promise that all men,black men as well as white men, would be guaranteed the “unalienable Rights” of “Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” He goes on to explain the situation and his goal: “to make justice a reality for all of God's children.” If not granted these goals, he promises for neither rest, nor tranquility in the nation. However, he pleads for a dignified, disciplined, and a peaceful approach to revolting. Now, he begins to persuade action and shifts his argument to the blacks in the audience-- issuing a call for dignity and discipline, not

Open Document