Söderblom's Argument For Understanding Religions
analytical Essay
475 words
Why was it significant that men like Söderblom and Otto argued for understanding religions on their own terms?
The significance of Söderblom's and Otto's work stems from how they approached religion with earnest and the methods used for comparing the various forms of religion. Unlike previous comparativists, both men sought to understand the various religions of the world on their own terms. Th purpose of this method was to reach out and attempt to seize the "richness" found within them. In doing so, they hoped to better grasp their forms as well as be able to explain them in a manner that could be recognizable to any religious adherent. However,this method does have its flaws. It does not allow for the addressing of elements that a religions
…show more content…
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how söderblom and otto argued for understanding religions on their own terms. both men sought to seize the "richness" found within them. however, this method has its flaws.
- Explains otto's idea of the holy, the numinous, and how it differs from the 19th century theories.
- Explains otto's concept of ideograms, which allowed for a false image that could temporally replace 'ineffable' concepts.
In order to better understand these daily adherents, Otto theorized that symbols, metaphors, and figurative language were possible methods for conveying what word cannot. Otto would unify these various tools to develop the concept of ideograms. The ideogram allowed for a sort of false image that could temporally replace a concept that is too difficult to explain or wholly ineffable. Why this is important when speaking about religion is that the very concept of religion itself can be ineffable. Various depictions of gods and goddesses found throughout history range from simplistically mundane to stunningly incomprehensible. Take for instance Hinduism and Daoism. There are an astonishing amount of deities found within Hinduism and many have characteristics that are almost impossible to fully realize. With the help of ideograms, however, we can at the very least gain some insight as to whether the god is something within the realm of man or beyond it. With respect to Daoism, ideograms allow for the image of the dao to be better understood. The Dao is permanent, nameless, and exist entirely within a void of nothingness. It is empty, formless, and smooth for its emptiness gives it usefulness, its lack of distinction gives it possibilities and its smoothness prevents complete comprehension. The use of ideograms help make it intelligible through understanding specific areas and characteristics of the Dao that have no
Related
- analytical
- argumentative
- Geertz and Baptismanalytical essayReligions are broad in their scope of history, beliefs, and rituals, using many systems to support their individual ideologies. Rituals, such as baptism within Christianity and Judaism, are markers for the distinct values and meanings that are associated with specific doctrines, and can be viewed and interpreted in several different ways. Theorists often view religion with different outlooks, classifying the institution as having a social background or a cultural emphasis, such as what Clifford Geertz defined. Geertz focused on the importance of symbols in religion, their cultural perceptions, the meanings that are attributed to the act, and how it relates to the the society’s value systems. By applying his theory about religion as a culture to the baptismal ceremonies in Judaic and Christian religions, the ritual can be viewed as an important cultural symbol, signs of various cultural views, and as a reinforcement of an ethos.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how the ritual of baptism fits all of geertz's criteria to be examined as a symbol in the cultural systems of the population.
- Explains clifford geertz's view of religion as a cultural system and how it relates to the society’s values.
- Explains that geertz's definition of religion is a system of symbols that establish powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivations in men.
- Explains drees, willem b, harrington, hannah k, kilani, mondher, and pals.
1607 wordsRead More - Analysis Of Stephen Prothero's God Is Not Oneanalytical essayAs the world becomes increasingly more interconnected, differences among the many religions prove to be obstacles to the global society. In an effort to overcome these obstacles, religious authorities propose the essential sameness of all religions (that all religions point towards the same goal); however, this hypothesis oversimplifies all religions to an arbitrary base. On the other hand, Stephen Prothero’s, the author of God Is Not One, proposal for the acknowledgment of the differences preserves the multidimensional aspects of religions. By rejecting the hypothesis of a basic and similar structure of religion, Prothero allows for them to exist as complete entities; however, Prothero also creates false barriers that over differentiate religions.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how stephen prothero's proposal for the acknowledgment of differences preserves the multidimensional aspects of religions.
- Analyzes how prothero's "godthink" portrays all religions as focusing solely on a type of faith.
- Analyzes how prothero's argument preserves religions in their full form, but ignores the similarity of all human beings.
- Analyzes how prothero's refusal of any common basis between religions contradicts the fact that humans compose them.
707 wordsRead More - Clifford Geertz And Catherine Bell's Interpretation Of Religionanalytical essayIn the previous paper, I argued that only one of the two religious scholars actually had the ability to understand foreign religious practices. When it comes to Geertz and Bell, I believe both of them hold the stated ability by virtue of their beliefs. Geertz suggests that symbols are the basis of human behavior, and these symbols are made by man and can change meaning over time. For example, the swastika was a symbol of good fortune and well being in ancient Hinduism, yet society today associates it with Nazism, anti-Semitism, and racism in general. Geertz emphasizes the importance of defining symbols within the context of how they’re presented. This alone proves that Gertz’s theories depend on the ability to understand outside religious interpretations and practices. This is much the same for Bell too, except with Bell’s theories, she’s talking about power relationships. Within the relationship, one must consider all factors from every angle and how it affects the power relationship. By following Bell’s ideas and closely analyzing a power relationship, one might for example be able to analyze how the power relationship between the Pope and a Christian practitioner is different from say the chief of a Native American
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how clifford geertz and catherine bell define religion, their interpretations of ritual, and their ability to analyze the religious practices of other cultures.
- Analyzes clifford geertz's definition of religion, which is a system of symbols that establishes powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivations in men.
- Explains that geertz views ritual as the practice of constructing symbols in a controlled society, whereas eliade argued that symbols should be based on entities already on earth.
- Argues that geertz and bell's interpretation of religion and rituals aid or limit their ability to understand the religious practices of cultures other than their own.
751 wordsRead More - Tomoko Masuzawa's 'The Invention Of World Religions'analytical essayHe was able to form a list of five world religions that were known “to gather a particularly large number of confessors (Masuzawa, 306)” This requirement allowed Hinduism and Confucianism to be considered world religions. This is in direct opposition to Otto Pfleiderer who chose to analyze the quality or the “intrinsic nature of the religion” as opposed to the number of followers (Masuzawa, 200). Based on the conditions set in place by the nineteenth-century scholars, what Weber believed to be world religions were, in fact, national religions. This shows that depending on the aspects of the religions chosen to be analyzed, religions could be considered either national or
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how masuzawa's literary work, the invention of world religions, provides an accurate account of how the perception and analysis of these religious occurred in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
- Explains masuzawa's analysis of the different characteristics of a religion that have influenced its placement in the national or universal religion categories.
- Analyzes how masuzawa's scholars analyzed the ability of the religion to grow over time, taking into account the racial boundaries that a religion may put in place.
- Analyzes how max weber analyzed the quantity of people who followed a religion. this allowed hinduism and confucianism to be considered world religions.
- Analyzes how masuzawa's analysis emphasized the commonalities in practices and beliefs between religions such as christianity and judaism which are believed to have common origins.
- Analyzes masuzawa's depiction of how the categories of national and world religions have changed over time due to the different facets of the religion that the scholars of that time analyzed.
869 wordsRead More - Michael Sattler and the Anabaptist Movementanalytical essay1. The Schleitheim Confession, authored by Michael Sattler, served as a point of unification for the Anabaptist community during the sixteenth century
In this essay, the author
- Opines that michael sattler, the anabaptist, was the most misunderstood, least recognized, and largely undervalued of all the great reformers of the sixteenth century.
- Explains that little is known about the childhood and early adult life of michael sattler, since he converted to anabaptist beliefs from catholic doctrine.
- Explains that michael sattler left st. peter's shortly after its capture. he attended a discussion regarding the heated issue of adult baptism in zurich.
- Explains that hans kuenzi, an anabaptist from oberglatt, took sattler and margaretha into his home during the summer of 1526.
- Describes how michael sattler's departure from oberglatt marked the beginning of his very brief ministry. he was in strasbourg debating and teaching swiss brethren beliefs.
- Explains that sattler left strasbourg and headed to lahr to spread anabaptist ideals. felix mantz, the swiss brethren leader, was martyred.
- Explains that sattler delivered the schleitheim confession to the swiss brethren leaders in late february 1527, which addressed the issues of baptism, excommunication, lord’s supper, separation from the world, sword, shepherds, and oath.
- Describes how sattler and his wife margaretha, matthias hiller, and vert veringer were arrested by roman catholic authorities for holding to anabaptist beliefs.
- Analyzes how the martyrdom extinguished the life of a man who was the leader of radical movement for only short periods, but his influence is spread across the world.
- Narrates how sattler becomes prior of st. peter’s during the peasant's revolt. he is married to margaretha, a former benguine.
- Narrates how sattler comes to oberglatt (north of zurich), where he stays with an anabaptist named hans kuenzi.
- Narrates how sattler is baptized, and officially becomes part of the anabetist movement. he leaves oberglatt and heads to strasbourg, the stronghold of reformers martin bucer and wolfgang capito.
- Analyzes how sattler is the leader of the swiss brethren anabaptist movement. he delivers the schleitheim confession, an outline of seven articles agreed upon by the s.b.
- Narrates how sattler travels to horb, where he is arrested by roman catholic authorities.
- Analyzes the impact of the schleitheim confession on the anabaptists, the reformation, and modern christian thinking.
- Explains that the schleitheim confession was not the only written work of michael sattler.
- Explains that sattler rejected catholic dogma and accepted the doctrine of salvation by faith. the anabaptist tradition was an outgrowth of the reformed tradition.
- Explains that the schleitheim addresses seven major issues, including baptism, the ban, lord’s supper, separation, sword, pastors, and the oath.
- Explains that the schleitheim states that a person must fulfill three requirements before being allowed to receive baptism.
- Analyzes how the second article portrays the biblical example of excommunication wherein a member of the congregation who is lost in sin shall be warned twice privately and the third time be publicly
- Explains that schleitheim acknowledges that the lord's supper is taken in "remembrance of the broken body...and...the shed blood of christ."
- Analyzes how sattler viewed the christian community like a monastic community, but the swiss brethren wanted nothing to do with state affairs.
- States that the fifth article explains that a shepherd's ultimate role is to "take care of the body of christ."
- Analyzes how sattler rejects the use of the sword as a legitimate means to any end.
- Explains that the final article disallows the believer to take an oath. this doctrine comes from christ's words.
- Analyzes how the schleitheim confession became the core ideals for the swiss brethren community. the seven tenets, drafted by michael sattler, have helped shape the christian world.
- Explains that the schleitheim confession was a unifying and stabilizing force for the juvenile anabaptist movement.
- Explains that sattler's standards in the schleitheim confession have been adopted by numerous protestant denominations. the anabaptists' illustration of a biblical baptism is accepted by millions of believers in scores of countries.
- Concludes with four points to illustrate the value of sattler's life. the schleitheim confession served as a point of unification for the anabaptist community during the sixteenth century.
- Explains that the seven articles of the schleitheim confession have had massive influence on the evangelical realm since their authorship. sattler's steadfastness signifies him as a man full of conviction and faithfulness to christ jesus.
3030 wordsRead More - Enlightenment Attitudes Towards Religionanalytical essayScientific and philosophical innovations during the 18th century brought about a new breed of thinkers. Their driving forces of rational and reason shifted the religious temperament of the elite from “enthusiasts” to intellectuals. “They argued that there was no divine standard of morality, no afterlife to divert humanity from worldly concerns” (The Western Experience, pg. 657). They were radicals who sought to displace the authority of religion. Driven by reason, enlightenment thinkers naturally opposed superstition and attempted to replace religious mysticism with philosophical standards and scientific formulations. Their shift of focus highlighted reverence for the Creator and moral teachings of the Bible. By eliminating superstition they hoped to bolster the Christian religion (The Western Experience, pg. 660). Two philosophies of the new enlightened view of religion were toleration and deism, both of which sustained the faith of the educated elite. However, these philosophies displaced the authority of religion in society (The Western Experience, pg. 660). Never again would the teachings of Christianity be so readily accepted. French critic Pierre Bayle put forth the concept of religious tolerance in his Critical and Historical Dictionary. Typical of an enlightenment thinker, Bayle put the claims of religion to the test of critical reason. He concluded that many of Christianity’s sacred traditions were myth and its history noth...
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how enlightenment thinkers shifted the religious temperament of the elite from "enthusiasts" to intellectuals by arguing that there was no divine standard of morality.
- Analyzes how diderot escapes censorship while fighting the churches belligerence with its own words. voltaire championed deism, which unites religion and reason.
666 wordsRead More - To fully understand religion is near impossible. Although countless people believe there is a way to explain religion in a logical way (in my opinion) have failed to accomplish their goal. A complex subject, religion is difficult to understand, if based on philosophical thought, it is menial compared to logical reasoning. This doesn’t make religion wrong, or philosophy wrong; however, religion is a personal preference. With that in mind, I’ve tried to answer three questions deducing those which are pertinent in understanding philosophy and religion. In that case, beginning with the first question: What is the importance of philosophy?
In this essay, the author
- Explains that religion is difficult to understand, if based on philosophical thought, it is menial compared to logical reasoning.
- Analyzes how kant, bonaventure, and aristotle have valid opinions that best explain philosophy's importance.
- Explains that philosophy is both a mutual understanding of man and his relations as well as creating an argument that has validity.
- Opines that religion is wildly difficult, and such a broad concept, there is no perfect answer.
- Explains that religion is not scientifically provable in any way. it is a choice to believe in concepts unseen, without scientific knowledge of the subject that exists.
- Analyzes darwin's evolution vs. design and maimonides negative theology. darwin believes that religion has inconsistencies such as eyewitness credibility, lack of interpretation of ancient text, insufficient evidence, and human interaction rarely changes with increased religion.
- Explains that different opinions are what steers religion, including logical reasoning compared to theory. logistics is what gives more power versus a philosophical idea.
850 wordsRead More - Approaches to the Study of Religionargumentative essayThe sociological approach looks at religious belief and practice in relation to the society. Sociologists are interested in two themes, the centrality of religion in society and the diversity of forms it inhabits (Hamilton 1995/2001:1). It regards religion as a social fact subject to empirical observation, which produces empirical evidence (Dillon 2003:7). The sociology of religion is a product of the enlightenment, from which it inherited a tendency to dismiss religion as incompatible with rationality (Dillon 2003:6). This dismissal has had significant impact on the attitude towards religion and it is the basis for the most influential paradigm in the history of the field; secularisation. The secularisation theory claims that religion is or will be on the decrease in society. So profound was its impact that modern sociology often aims to account for the continued presence of religion in society and has generally held a rather negative view of religion as being an unworthy subject of study(Davies 2007:2).
In this essay, the author
- Explains the sociological approach to religious belief and practice in relation to the society. the enlightenment inherited a tendency to dismiss religion as incompatible with rationality.
- Explains that sociology is a theory guided by and aims to build theories. definition is contentious because different criteria lead to different patterns being indentified in data.
- Explains that substantive definitions are concerned with what a religion ‘is’. they possess specificity, which lends itself more readily to survey research.
- Explains that using the supernatural or sacred as a demarcation point corresponds with commonly accepted societal notions of religion.
- Argues that substantive definitions are unaccommodating to beliefs which do not prescribe to established cultural or historical norms. the conformation to historical standards is useful to sociologists who identify with modernisation and secularisation.
- Compares functional definitions with durkheim's definition of religion as a unified system of beliefs and practices, relative to sacred things.
- Explains that durkheim was raised in a religious rabbinic ashkenazi family and that in judaism there is an emphasis on communal responsibility illustrated in the binding qualities of prayer.
- Explains that the focus on society also leaves out individual spirituality. however, if personal spiritual beliefs are not classed as religion, what about those who participate in communal practices of a religion?
- Opines that functionalism's breadth is not an advantage; it can lead to almost any phenomena being labelled as a religion.
- Explains that for a functional definition to be valid, one must assume that society has certain functional needs. this implication is incompatible with the classical sociological idea that religion would disappear.
- Concludes that neither definition provides a wholly satisfying solution to the question of definition but it is not just scholars who are struggling to find an answer.
- Describes the works of davie, grace, and michele dillon on the sociology of religion.
1474 wordsRead More - Western Religionsargumentative essayReligion is known to be difficult to define as it transcends so many boundaries in human experience and from an academic perspective; it is difficult to find any distinction between the world religions 1, 2, 3. Ninian Smart approached religion as a religious studies specialist and instead of trying to define religion, he identified certain recognizable elements that religion in general possess and focused on studying them 3, 4, 9. He identified seven such elements or dimensions for the religion; practical and ritual, experimental and emotional, narrative or mythic, doctrinal and philosophical, ethical and legal, social and institutional and material dimension 3. The purpose of this paper is to use three of Smart’s dimensions and describe the three western religions. An example from each of the three religion pertaining to a chosen dimension will be provided and explained in the context of the religion and how it informs one of the core aspects of the chosen religion.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how ninian smart approached religion as a religious studies specialist, and instead of trying to define religion, he identified certain recognizable elements that religion in general possess.
- Explains that the first dimension chosen to describe the western religions is experiential and emotional dimension, which entails the subjective and human experience of the religion.
- Explains the narrative or mythic dimension of western religions, which entails stories amalgamated with devotional material which plays a central role.
- Explains that the ethical and legal dimension of western religions is the ten commandments, the canon laws, and sharia laws.
- Concludes that using smart's seven dimensions, we can better focus and understand a certain aspect of the religion and study it in depth.
- Cites harrison, victoria, cline, austine, and bruke, susan. "religion 101 examining the definition of religion and religious beliefs."
- Cites rennie, bryan's article, "rel 11- understanding religious experience and expression."
- Explains that ninian smart's seven dimensions or religions is accessed on 4 december 2013, 7.50 pm.
924 wordsRead More - Garhard Lenksi Religionanalytical essayGarhard Lenksi’s idea of sociocultural evolution corresponds to religion in various different ways. As a society evolves from one stage to another, that society’s values also change. This leads to new types of religions as well as changes in the amount religious inequality. The types of values that exists in a certain sociocultural stage determines the type of religion that the society will have during that stage.
In this essay, the author
- Analyzes how garhard lenksi's idea of sociocultural evolution corresponds to religion in various ways. as a society evolves from one stage to another, that society’s values also change, leading to new types of religions and changes in the amount of religious inequality.
- Explains that in a hunter-gatherer society, people are dependent on nature for survival. they believe in nature gods, and women and men can have the same religious positions.
- Explains that in a pastoral society, people use animals for major sources to make food and clothing. this causes the pantheon to consist mostly of animal gods.
- Explains that in an early agrarian society, people depended on farming for survival, and the majority of gods in the pantheon are related to agriculture. women were treated as property and lost their influence on religion.
- Explains that the mid-agrarian stage is very similar to the early agricultural stage, but theocracy begins to occur.
- Explains that people began to care more about conquering territories during the late agrarian stage. this expansionist tendency is reflected in the development of salvation religions.
- Explains that in an industrial society, there is less farming and more industrialization. the main difference between these two societies is secularism, which is found more in post-industrial societies.
- Argues that lenski's idea and religion can be used to create the implication that there will be a greater diversity of religions in the future.
- Explains that religions are closely related to sociocultural evolutionary stages, because they reflect the values of the society that they are found in.
542 wordsRead More