Reflection Paper On Field Experience

1428 Words3 Pages

I completed my field experience observing third grade at Centennial Elementary in Nampa. While any chance I get to work with students is rewarding, this particular field experience seemed like a waste of time, in my opinion, as there is not a proper English Language Learning class in place. The teacher, Mrs. MK, I observed was great with the students. However, I felt there needed to be more emphasis on background building as I learned from the SIOP model discussed in class. I was incredibly surprised at the curriculum content of the ELL program at Centennial. Also, I was baffled that the teacher did not hold a teaching certificate merely a district certification much like that of a Para Professional only a slight bit higher. Granted she is …show more content…

The speech program is a resource program for all ethnicity students (including Caucasian) who struggle with speaking English clearly. Much like the English Learning Language program, these groups organized according to grade level meet four times a week for forty-five minutes. That being said, I feel with better screening throughout our school district we would find the need for an ELD program and perhaps more who also qualify for ELL assistance. Just within Centennial Elementary, I am aware of students who are bilingual, family’s primary language is Spanish and the student struggles with their reading and writing. These said students are not receiving any assistance. I cannot imagine any parent knowing about programs available to assist their child 's learning and turning them away; especially knowing they are free. In reading an article written by Alison Bailey, she notes, “The cost of “missing” the right students in the initial survey process is extremely high” (Bailey, Lessons from AZ 's EL identification issues: How guidance could strengthen process, 2011). Thus supporting my feelings about screening all bilingual students whose primary home language is something other than English. An additional statement made by Bailey, “It seems the more tolerable ‘measurement error’ surely must be to have too many rather than too few students initially thrown into the …show more content…

When observing all three third grade classes at Centennial Elementary, only two of them were using effective scaffolding instruction. One of these third-grade teachers is also bilingual and was able to assist ELL students also in their Spanish language that was helpful for these few students. Two of the three teachers had their version of “Text talk time” a video created by the Teaching Channel. Mrs. C, one of the third-grade teachers mentioned above has what she calls, “carpet time.” With this, she will discuss the topic of the week, standards taught for the week, and classroom objective. With the first read, she will read the entire story, stopping to discuss or analyze with the class what she has read. When one of her students has a connection or clear understanding of what she is teaching they, use a hand gesture of two circles connected. Also, if a student is not grasping the concept or objective, they will give her thumbs down telling her to re-teach or explain the emphasized concept. The other part of this observation that is troubling to me is that Mrs. B, the other third-grade teacher who was not using adequate scaffolding for her ELL students also has some of the lowest achieving ELL students in reading and writing within her class. I wonder how many other teachers within Centennial Elementary are not using proper scaffolding techniques to help their ELL students succeed.

Open Document