Reasons For The Failure Of The Dieppe Raid

1324 Words3 Pages

In the summer of 1942, there wasn’t much leverage against Germany, but the Allies wished to make some headway. The Soviet Union pushed for a second front against Germany. Idle Canadian troops were clamoring for battle. Even Winston Churchill wanted a glorious victory against Hitler’s forces. Little reason existed for the Allies not to make a move. Thus, in this Pre-Normandy time, a plan of attack was devised. It would be 9 hours of constant hell. Many troops would be lost, no invasion goals will be accomplished, and the lessons that were learned might be the only thing to salvage this plan from being a complete failure. This catastrophic plan would be known as The Dieppe Raid. The casualties are the biggest factor at looking at how bad the …show more content…

Dieppe was originally setup to test the effectiveness of amphibious assaults against Hitler’s Fortress Europe. If successful, it could also be used as a starting point to form a 2nd front against Germany. The main goals for the actual mission of the Dieppe Raid were to go in, sabotage and destroy the port, and get out under cover of darkness. This didn’t happen. 5 beaches were delegated to different Allied troops to take, much like D-Day. Of these beaches, only 1 British Commando force faced any success. All other beaches (including the main Canadian infantry) faced massive resistance, large casualties, and no success against the Germans. Even with the one success, the Commando force was only tasked with taking out static defenses in one section of the beach. This can aid the main invasion, but it doesn’t overturn its loss. Part of the goal of destroying Dieppe was also taking multiple prisoners back to be questioned and pressed on German operations. No one else but the successful commandos took any prisoners, and they only took 4. Many accounts say no German POWs were taken at all. This is yet another failed aspect of The Dieppe Raid. Of course, the most major and important goal was to open a 2nd front against Germany to take a load of the U.S.S.R. As the Dieppe forces were completely annihilated (except with the one British Commando force) this obviously …show more content…

Over 1/3 of the participating Allied troops were lost and these troops physically accomplished nothing to put pressure on Germany and open up a second front. There was one good thing to take from this experience however. In fact, multiple good things, in the forms of the mistakes and lessons that the Allies would learn from and consider in their future planning. The Dieppe Raid was a physical failure, but it failed for many, easy-to-see reasons. For one, The Dieppe Raid was poorly planned and poorly prepared. There was very little preparation to actually make sure the raid succeeded. No distractions were placed, no intelligence was gathered on German positions, and the timing was absolutely atrocious. The timing was a real kicker. Many of the attackers arrived late on the scene. The Germans had gotten warning of the incoming attack, as one of their ships clashed with an incoming Allied ship. The late arrival just gave the Germans even more time to harden their defenses for the incoming assault. The misaligned timing lead to an uncoordinated attack, which lead to a failed raid. This would be one of the lessons that would be the more famous and successful D-Day. Lots of Intel was gathered before D-Day, there was an entire operation dedicated to misleading the Germans, and the timing was refined to an absolute tee to keep the enemy overwhelmed. This wasn’t the only

More about Reasons For The Failure Of The Dieppe Raid

Open Document