Music Analysis Of 'Why We Build The Wall'

1318 Words3 Pages

It is impossible to read a piece of literature exactly the same as another person. Every internal voice reads with a different pace, tone, and attitude, which can slightly alter the interpretation of the same piece of literature. Music, however, has less of an opportunity to be interpreted differently. The vocal influxes and beat of music allow for an audience to understand the music in the tone the producer intends, rather than starting off with a blank slate and trying to determine a genre from just words. Of course, it can still present different meanings to different people, but overall, it limits the amount of interpretation done by the audience. Its genre is predetermined by the creator of the song, which causes the overall message to …show more content…

Anais Mitchell’s musical Hadestown exemplifies how the melodious aspect of music allows the message of “Why We Build the Wall” to change entirely when going from written word to a auditory experience. On paper, Mitchell’s song symbolizes a strong, united community that is confident about its decision to build a wall when they repeatedly sing, “We build the wall to keep us free” (Mitchell l.4). Their short, matter-of-fact statements show no wavering in their decision to build the wall or the reason they choose to build it. However, in the song, it is revealed through their tones and the slow, impending music they sing along to that their emotions are different from the words they are speaking. In unison, on paper, suggests a togetherness that is not heard when sung aloud. Instead, the unsettling tone of complete unison appears to be programmed into the singers can only be detected when performed aloud. No single voice stands above another, removing all sense of individuality, which contradicts the idea of freedom they are singing about. Furthermore, the monotonous tone of the voices does not give off a feeling of happiness, but rather they are trapped in a dystopia but too brainwashed to realize. The inflection in their voices does not change when singing about freedom or poverty, suggesting they have memorized a script rather than believe what they are saying. Mitchell’s songs, …show more content…

The slow beat of Mitchell’s “Why we Build the Wall” reveals the sadness of the song before the lyrics begin which prepares the audience for a sad song. Moreover, the end of the song adds to the feeling of impending doom the tone of the song creates. The slow rhythm continues for an uncomfortably long time after the singing ends at a constant rate, instead of fading out. The feeling of completeness a song typically presents allows the audience to be satisfied with the song, but “Why We Build the Wall” ends with a set of poorly strummed guitar notes that seem to be suggesting the song is not yet over. Then the song ends abruptly, leaving no feeling of resolution for the audience. Mitchell chose how her song was presented, and her choices as an artist presented her message how she wanted it to be seen, therefore controlling the effect the song has on

Open Document