Garibaldi's Criticism Of Teen Pregnancy

1047 Words3 Pages

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the leading national public health institute in the United States, illuminates to the world, “ In 2013, a total of 273,105 babies were born to women aged 15 – 19 years [in the US]” (About Teen Pregnancy). Although the statistic was taken in 2013, the relevance of it, to this day, is monumental. If an individual hears of a teen pregnancy, compared to the past, it would have little to no effect. For example, The Scarlet Letter, written by Nathanial Hawthorne in 1850, follows the life of a woman, who happens to be a mother, while she hides herself in shame, withdrawn from society because she has a child. The novel’s views juxtaposed with today’s views on teen pregnancies are substantially different. …show more content…

He repetitively utilizes “urban schools” in his work, which broadly generalizes “schools like mine” (Garibaldi 634-635). This degrades his writing because he fails to prove that other schools have the same “intractable problem” (Garibaldi 635). His work hasty generalizes the population of schools across the nation, not specifying if the problem is eminent in urban schools, which are, for example, either contain more Hispanic or Caucasian races. In Gerry Garibaldi’s “The Pregnancy Trap,” the logical fallacies of oversimplification and hasty generalization, in addition to his drought of views and statistics cause his work to severely fall in credibility. However, his first-hand experiences promote his writing because personal experience is reliable. His lack of facts reduces the trustworthiness of his piece. Simplifying and generalizing important information, also contracts from the reliability of his work. Due to the logical fallacies, absence of outside point of views, and deficiency of statistics, society may not accept his

Open Document