Evaluation of Two Models Of Memory

1417 Words3 Pages

Evaluation of Two Models Of Memory

In this essay 2 models of memory will be described and compared. They

are the Atkinson and Sniffrin model of memory, the Multistore model,

and Crain and Lockhart model, the Levels of Processing Model. Models

of memory are primitive diagrams of human memory to help understand

the flow of information and how it is stored. In order to evaluate

those 2 models appropriately it is important to understand how old

they are.

The Multistore Model of Memory by Atkinson and Shiffrin is a very

primitive model although it does try to explain how the memory works

quite well. It recognises 3 memory stores – the Sensory Memory Store,

the short-term memory store and the long-term memory store. The

environment makes available a variety of sources of information. The

information comes in through the sensory system – through one of the

five human senses. For a brief time it gets stored in the sensory

memory store; 2 seconds for auditory and 0.5 second for visual

information. It is an exact copy of the stimulus, although it lasts

for a very short time. The experiment done by Sperling in 1960, where

he showed a quick image to the participants and asked them to write

the answers down, supports the theory of existence of the Sensory

memory store, as participants could only remember 36% of the image on

average. According to the model, if attention is paid to an external

stimulus, an internal thought, or both, then it is stored in the

short-term memory. It is mostly stored in auditory form, however other

types of encoding are also possible. Short-term memory is also called

working memory and relates to what we are thinki...

... middle of paper ...

...n

order to transfer it to STM and LTM. However, the multistore memory

shows that in order for the information to get transferred to LTM, it

has to be rehearsed, whereas the Levels of Processing model shows that

it is enoungh for the input to trigger some kind of association on

semantic level for it to be transferred to LTM. The Levels of

Processing does not show any Memory Stores or where the memory is

stored, so it is quite limited, whereas the other model does show 3

memory stores. The levels of processing model is very limited as it

does not show where information is stored and how it is forgotten. I

think the multistore model, although very simplistic does give a

better understanding about the human memory that the other one. It is

a very good model for the time it was made and it is based on reliable

evidence.

Open Document