Essay On Parental Authority In This Be The Verse

800 Words2 Pages

Although an authorities intentions may be good, individuals will inevitably challenge an authority if it is excessively restrictive or abusive, in order to achieve individuality and freedom. This is particularly evident when examining the restrictive parental authority evident throughout Peter Weirs The Dead Poet Society in which the students challenge the authority to obtain their freedom and individuality. Furthermore, this concept is also presented in Philip Larkin’s This Be The Verse, which is written in a manner that warns the reader of the restrictions of parental authority despite the good intentions at its core. Throughout both texts this fundamental idea of challenging a restrictive parental authority to achieve individuality and freedom is clearly portrayed using various techniques. …show more content…

In contrast Neil is often viewed from a high angle shot, particularly when around his father. This establishes the restrictive control of the parental authority from the early scenes of the movie. However as the story progresses Mr. Keating instills his motto of “Carpe Diem – Seize the day” upon his students, teaching them to think as individuals so to retain their freedom. In doing so Mr. Keating disregards the traditional teaching methods of the school and goes against all the students had been previously taught. Peter Weir shows this by contrasting Keating’s unconventional first lesson with a prior montage of the ordered and systematic previous classes. To the viewer this establishes Keating as an unconventional teacher but it also takes its effect on the students. This can be seen when Neil, tired of the restrictions imposed upon him, challenges his fathers’ direct instructions by performing in the local play. In lying to his father and continuing with the play he succeeds in challenging the restrictive authority. Whilst his fathers instructions to quit the play

Show More
Related

  • Examples Of Transcendentalism In Dead Poets Society

    671 Words  | 2 Pages

    By reading the Bible, a direct instruction of living life by His word, Christians can find this comfort and happiness. To the boys attending the poetry class, Keating is a source of the same comfort. Because of Keating’s helpful instruction and caring attitude towards the boys, his character resembles the wise image of God. Keating often has to advise the students to practice free will with caution because of society’s dramatic responses to transcendental actions. In one scene, Neil is confronted by his selfish father, who stringently demands his son to not take part in the school’s play. Later, Neil goes to Keating for advice on what choice to make and explains that he is the only person who Neil can really talk to about his true feelings. Keating then tells Neil to honestly tell the narrow-minded father about what he really wants to do with his life. This advice follows the importance of self-reliance. “Insist on yourself; never imitate. Your own gift you can present every moment with the cumulative force of a whole life's cultivation; but of the adopted talent of another you have only an extemporaneous half possession” (Emerson). Neil should be proud of his talent and stay persistent against his father in order to live a life of nonconformity. Just as society denied God’s words before the

    Read More

  • Dead Poets Society Transcendentalism Analysis

    771 Words  | 2 Pages

    He wants to live his life the way he dreams it to be but, the shadow of his father is present in everything he does. Neil showed resistance to conformity when he protested his dad’s decision to not let him edit the school newspaper. His father tells him that “you do as I tell you” (Dead Poets Society: Final Script). It his horrible that Neil’s father runs his life. Neil does not like this, yet he does not know how to approach his father on the issue. Neil then decides to express his feeling to Mr. Keating. Keating reminds Neil that he is not a slave to his father. Mr. Keating tells him that he should choose to live life the way he wants to. Neil finally acts on his desire to be an actor, and performs in a play. As he performs, he realizes that acting his passion, and wants to pursue it avidly. Even though he receives praise from others, his father still disapproves. His father sees acting as a superfluous endeavour. After a performance, he tells his son “You're going to Harvard and you're going to be a doctor.”(Dead Poets Society: Final Script). After this confrontation, Neil realizes that he will probably never please his father. Rather than comply with his father, Neil commits

    Read More

  • Transcendentalism In Movies

    547 Words  | 2 Pages

    Neil Perry is another young man who realizes that his life is being planned out in front of him. He feels that he has no voice in his life. Their English professor, Mr. Keating, radically changes the lives of all of these students.

    Read More

  • Dead Poets Society And Fahrenheit 451 Comparative Essay

    732 Words  | 2 Pages

    Keating is very adamant about how his students need to be their own person in a society that tells them not to. He is a huge inspiration to his students, especially Neil, and impacts all of their lives in a unique way. Neil has a father which represents society as a whole on the youth of today. He tries to force his son down a one-way street and for many years Neil complied, but once Mr. Keating opened his eyes to poetry and the beauty of life Neil had a new view on things. He always tells them to find their own voice and to express it to the world, and he tells them how poetry is a profession of emotion. The students recreate the Dead Poets Society as the story goes on and Mr. Keating gets a quote from poetry which compares life to this powerful play to which people can contribute a verse to. He asks them what will their verse be. He is encouraging the students to speak out and be their own person to make a change in the

    Read More

  • Childhood In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    1691 Words  | 4 Pages

    It is not always easy to steer a child towards the right path, sometimes they do as they please, and sometimes it is the parents that make a mistake. No sons or daughters truly understand their parents’ choices until they have reached maturity. For example, Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley’s novel Frankenstein can be interpreted as a metaphor of a kid defying his parents’ wishes and going into a teenage crisis asserting his rights over them. If the novel is deconstructed we can identify the different stages of the creature’s life mirroring the stages towards adulthood; First there is the first actions of the child and how the parent reacts to it, in second there is the learning phase where he acquires awareness of his surroundings and consequences of his actions and third is the child’s revolt against the authority figure as he attains maturity and finally the reconciliation between father and son as the wrong is being atoned for.

    Read More

  • Dead Poets Society Transcendentalism

    566 Words  | 2 Pages

    He believes that acting is his true passion and wants to see how far he can go, Mr. Keating, his English teacher tells him to follow his dreams and not to care about how his dad feels. Neil joins the theater in school and takes part in a play. Neil is finally able to show his potential that he had to hide beforehand. This is showing human potential, the transcendental belief that people have potential to be anything they want to

    Read More

  • Dead Poets Society Coming Of Age Essay

    520 Words  | 2 Pages

    The secondary focus is a struggle, Neil’s struggle in particular, which is both against his parents and within himself. “Dead Poet’s Society” presents the heavy topic of suicide. Through Neil’s character, we as an audience are exposed to the morbid thoughts and emotions that many young adults unfortunately face. Neil, like many of the other boys, is introduced as being reluctant and unwilling to go against the authority roles in his life, primarily his father and his expectations. As the film progresses, he begins to search for himself and ultimately goes against his father’s wishes as he pursues his love of theatre. When he learns of his father’s disapproval, it leads him to

    Read More

  • Parent and Son Relationship in one of Nye, Naomi Shihab´s Poems

    638 Words  | 2 Pages

    The author uses imagery, contrasting diction, tones, and symbols in the poem to show two very different sides of the parent-child relationship. The poem’s theme is that even though parents and teenagers may have their disagreements, there is still an underlying love that binds the family together and helps them bridge their gap that is between them.

    Read More

  • Control In The Glass Menagerie And The Fish By Lila Zeiger

    1049 Words  | 3 Pages

    In both texts there are similar ideas being shown about the alteration of a child’s identity when their parents are overbearing and controlling. Tom, the victim of an over-controlling parent gets frustrated about the current condition

    Read More

  • Similarities Between One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest And Dead Poets Society

    1002 Words  | 3 Pages

    Consider McMurphy and Mr. Keating, both characters are very similar in a multitude of ways. Neither of them is in charge as they are both under their respective antagonist, either being Nurse Ratched or Principle Nolan. However throughout the progression of each plot, they both teach and inspire either the patients or the students to become individuals. McMurphy gave the patients the ability to seize back the power from Nurse Ratched through showing them the way how, and teaching the patients that they are their own person and have their own rights. Mr. Keating teaches the students how to be outside the box, as shown when in class he strays from the regular methods of teaching and shows the students a truly out-of-the-box concept about life, “Carpe Diem.” Towards the final moments of the plot, both characters achieve a full commitment to their cause that eventuates in self-sacrifice. McMurphy is lobotomized and Mr. Keating is fired from Welton Academy. However similarly in both plots, after both characters sacrifices themselves they pass on what they have learned and allowed others to beat their struggle for independence. Chief leaves the institution and the students stand up against Principle Nolan with what they believe in. Weir and Kesey use these characters to inspire and support those who struggle for independence and use their characterization as a technique to do so.

    Read More

  • Dead Poet Society: The Blame for Neil Perry's Death

    677 Words  | 2 Pages

    Mr Perry uses blackmail, pressure and authority to get his way over his son’s life and is otherwise to blame for Neil’s death. He sets Neil limits as to how he can live his life. When Mr Keating inspires Neil and the rest of the senior English class, it gives Neil the idea that he does have the power to stand up to his father. This leads Neil into committing suicide when his father forbids him from Acting and moves him into a Military Academy. Throughout the film Neil is shown to be under pressure to complete difficult aspects of life, placed on him by his father. Mr Perry guilt trips Neil into carrying out tasks he wants him to complete. His father does not seem to take in what he is doing to his son, placing the blame on Keating.

    Read More

  • Dead Poet’s Society: Cause of Neil’s Death

    651 Words  | 2 Pages

    The character Neil’s father dreadful, excessive parenting led to Neil’s death. Although strict parenting is beneficial, overdoing it has dire consequences. In this case it leads to the death of Neil Perry. Parents not communicating with their child results in a bad connection between the parent and the child with a higher chance of blatant disobedience. How Neil’s father treats him when throughout his life causes his disobedience and later demise.

    Read More

  • Unique Perspective to Teaching: Dead Poets Society

    986 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Dead Poets Society, John Keating becomes the new English teacher at Welton Academy, an esteemed school rooted in tradition, after attending as a student years ago. He teaches using an unconventional style which is different from the traditional English curriculum, and in the process, he exposes the students to a new perspective on the subject and principles for living life. Keating encourages free-thinking and condemns the textbook which prevents the students from thinking for themselves. Other individuals, including the principal, Mr. Nolan, disagree with his unconventional method of teaching and prefer that he follow a traditional method of teaching through an English textbook. The lessons that Mr. Keating presents the students reflect the transcendentalist beliefs of Ralph Waldo Emerson found in “Self-reliance” and influence the students to become more independent thinkers.

    Read More

  • Dead Poets Society Analysis

    1077 Words  | 3 Pages

    His love for teaching is very similar to that of Socrates himself. Keating’s practices challenge the traditional authoritarian ways of Welton Academy, like Socrates who lives out of his own individual beliefs. A major scene from the movie is a discussion between Keating and Nolan. Nolan questions Keating about the incident he observed in the courtyard. “Oh that,” Keating says. “That was an exercise to prove a point. About the evils of conformity.” “John, the curriculum here is set,” Nolan tells him. “It’s proven. It works. If you question it, what’s to prevent them from doing the same?” “I always thought education was learning to think for yourself,” Keating replies. Keating intentionally reflects on the famous Socrates teachings. Socrates “did not believe that knowledge or wisdom could be transmitted from a teacher to a student because he believed the concepts of true knowledge were present, but buried, within the person’s mind” (Ornstein, Levine, Gutek, Vocke, 2004,

    Read More

  • Creativity In Dead Poets Society

    1000 Words  | 2 Pages

    Keating goes above and beyond at developing the minds of his students, including helping Todd find the poet within himself, and supporting Neil when Neil’s father didn’t want Neil to act. Overall, Mr. Keating and his actions pushed the ideas of creativity and self-thought throughout the film.

    Read More

More about Essay On Parental Authority In This Be The Verse

Open Document