Don Manuel Play Analysis

1063 Words3 Pages

Don Manuel is presented as the perfect man, kind, selfless, gifted, and compassionate, at least in part to show the villagers' conflation of their love of him and their devotion to their religion. In one of my favorite musicals, Jesus Christ Superstar, the character of Judas pleads with Jesus to quell the movement growing around him, saying "You've begun to matter more than the things you say." In much the same way, Don Manuel matters more to the people than the things he says, so much so that they fail to notice that he doesn't actually believe the things he preaches to them, specifically concerning the afterlife. This is especially interesting considering Christianity's simultaneous worship of a perfect human being in the form of Jesus Christ …show more content…

He is the perfect priest, but a poor apologist, and when questioned by both Angela and Lazarus individually, his true convictions are easily revealed. Even so, he maintains this act to the point that the only hint he gives to the general populace about his lack of belief in an afterlife is his avoidance of condemning people for acts such as suicide that the Church has very clear positions on. This is not to say that his lies and omissions have no impact on him; eventually, his duality wearies him both physically and mentally. In accordance with his vocation, Don Manuel uses religion and faith as a useful tool to comfort and shelter the masses, even allowing them to devote themselves to him to the extent that they view him as almost Christlike both before and after his death. This raises the interesting question if anyone would rather their leaders and role models be honest with them, no matter how uncomfortable, instead of lying to them in the vein of protection and comfort, because the actions of Don Manuel, Angela, and Lazarus certainly lend evidence to support the …show more content…

He understands that the villagers' faith and religion is at least partially sustained by his example and presence, and is unwilling to compromise that, but he also fails to consider the concepts of choice and true conversion. This is interesting, because much the same as Don Manuel must have become disillusioned with the ideas that he was socialized to believe in in the form of the Catholic faith, others certainly can replicate that process in reverse, difficult though it may be. He also benignly takes advantage of his position as part of the "religion that made them", as he knows he is a vital part of the villagers' faith, an example for them to trust and follow. While Don Manuel probably believes as Lazarus does that the villagers keep faith because it is the path of least resistance as well as the only way they know, there is always the possibility of true belief. Don Manuel even advocates letting the people believe everything rather that confuse them into doubting and possibly believing in nothing, as he does so desolately. He seems to only deem Angela and Lazarus worthy of and intelligent enough to be truly honest with. Although his intentions are good in trying to protect and sedate the people, it is interesting to think of how much more good he could have done in being honest, perhaps helping

Open Document