Critique Of Action Research

2084 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The effect of technology in education

Introduction I have chosen to critique “Using Math Journals to Enhance Second Graders’ Communication of Mathematical Thinking” by Kathleen Kostos and Eui-kyung Shin. This action research project seeks to create change to further improve the quality of second grade students’ communication in mathematical thinking through the use of writing in math journals at the local level.
Research Problem
Within the narrative of the study the research demonstrated the importance for mathematical communication in education today. Several principles from the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics demonstrated what math programs should allow students to do in regards to the subject of math. Through these principles math programs also need to prepare …show more content…

The purpose of this action research study is to build understanding of important mathematical concepts and to also lay a foundation for local second graders in the classroom to effectively communication their mathematical thinking so they can explain how and why they use a mathematical concepts to solve a problem (Kostos, K. & Shin, E. 2010). This solution is supported by sufficient evidence which is given in the research of the study and within the literature review. The research question derived from the research purpose states the following, “how the use of math journals affected the second grade students’ mathematical thinking through math communication”. The use of math journals is an innovation that is considered at the outset of the project. This research question is in alignment with the purpose of the research that addresses the research problem. Through this question the researcher addresses the local issue of mathematical communication or lack thereof in her second grade …show more content…

At the later part of the study the same math assessment was given again which used a pre- and post- assessment method for collecting data. Second the student’s math journals were collected and their progress in developing mathematical communication skills and their mathematical thinking were examined. Throughout the study students wrote in their journals on an average of three times a week. Student interviews were conducted as a third type of data collection. Eight students were chosen randomly to conduct the interviews. Through the interviews the teacher-researcher was able to gather insight regarding the students’ perceptions of using the math journals. The fourth type of data collection was the teacher-researcher’s reflective journal. Through this journal the teacher-researcher recorded conversations down, made general observations, recorded ideas and also problems that may have occurred throughout the study. This was later used for

Show More
Related

  • Importance Of Mathematical Creativity

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    Mathematical creativity is a concept which involves a creation of an innovative problem-solving way and its application to a mathematical problem. Thus, one of the main goals of mathematical creativity is to get to the roots of both original and practical thinking. As the high-school years in academic students’ lives involve a great amount of challenges, there is a significant need to develop both originality and practical skills through mathematical thinking. Therefore, this research makes an effort to take an insight of creative personality traits, correlation and stereotypes in mathematical creativity in the case of high-school students. Through the studies of literature, application of the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking (TTCT), and by distributing the questionnaire to 100 high-school students from Lithuania, this research showed some significant findings. It was noticed all students are mathematically creative and the reason behind this lies in their ability to be imaginative, humorous, energetic in taking up new activities, and explicit in storytelling. Yet, it was found that the students with greater achievements tend to stick more to the reality. The relation between creativity and mathematics was also found not only in

    Read More

  • Assessing Mathematical Standards in Grades K-12

    1948 Words  | 4 Pages

    Introduction The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) has developed detailed academic standards to direct learning goals for K-12 students. This paper will address the importance of having standards included in mathematics and how these standards can improve mathematics instruction in the classroom. This paper will also examine traditional mathematics programs versus constructivist-type programs and discuss how they address these standards and address the limitations of both types of programs. In addition, this paper will also summarize the author’s observations of an 8th grade math classroom and discuss the following observed in the classroom: (a) objectives and standards used in the lesson; (b) differentiated instruction and methods used by the teacher during the lesson; (c) the use of technology during the lesson; (d) manipulative objects, supplies and handouts used by the students; (e) identify the types of assessments utilized by the teacher during the lesson; and finally, (f) the author will explain if any changes could be made to the lesson.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Mathemacy In Mathematics

    1593 Words  | 4 Pages

    Mathematics is its own language, and no matter what language a mathematician speaks, his ideas will be understood by all dialects. Since mathematics is a language, it has its own discourse, and has its own unique way of reading and writing. The Board of Studies Teaching & Educational Standards NSW ([BOSTES], 2016) explains how students should develop an understanding and fluency in mathematics. However, a few methods outlined by BOSTES (2016) to achieve this fluency are inquiry, exploring and communication. This presents problems for low level literacy and EAL/D students since the main issues they face with learning is that they struggle with forms of communication, whether it be written or oral.

    Read More

  • Mathematical Thinking Essay

    877 Words  | 2 Pages

    (Shatnawi, 1982). Ma’Moon, Mohammad. Mubark tested the above six aspects in the students in the year 11 scientific stream in Jordan .Finally, six aspects of Mathematical Thinking were identified by the study: Generalization, Induction, Deduction, Use of Symbols, Logical thinking and Mathematical proof (Ma’Moon, 2005). In the study, Mathematical proof was the most difficult aspect, while Logical thinking was the least difficult. Using multiple regression analysis, all six aspects were found to be important for Mathematics Achievement. Mathematical proof and Generalization were the most important aspects, Use of symbols and Logical thinking were next in importance, and Deduction and Induction were the least important aspects. Approximately seventy per cent of the variance in Mathematics Achievement was explained by the six aspects of Mathematical Thinking, gender, and school

    Read More

  • Math Anxiety Essay

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    In conclusion math anxiety can impact a student in many ways and its very important to help children be comfortable with math. There are long and short term effects to developing math anxiety. This paper has gone over the history of math anxiety, how it begins, the relevance of it, Prevention and management and possible interventions. This topic is important to school psychologists for many reasons. As school psychologists we should look out for students that have math anxiety and also work with teachers to make sure it doesn’t

    Read More

  • Importance Of Math Essay

    1135 Words  | 3 Pages

    Math may be deprecated by the general population, and the general concept of math may lie hidden from many students, but nevertheless, math is the foundation of the modern world. People that deal with math in their everyday lives need to emphasize the importance of math. People need

    Read More

  • Internet Access in Ghana

    1275 Words  | 3 Pages

    S. D. J. &. N. Sherrod, "Developing Science and Mathematics Integrated Activities for Middle School Students," InternationalJournalof MathematicalEducationinScienceandTechnology, 2009.

    Read More

  • Mathematics and Science: My Favorite Subjects

    535 Words  | 2 Pages

    My pedestal quality lies in the area of mathematics. It polishes my academic armor and sharpens my sword of educational merit. Mathematics is the backbone of my academic figure. Arithmetic and functions come like breathing and a math challenge is always appreciated; however, in no way is my prestige in math providing even the smallest level of interest for me. In fact, mathematics to me is comparable to a wrench in a toolbox: useful when needed, but otherwise useless. Nevertheless, my understanding of this subject provides exceptional resources to students in need.

    Read More

  • Math Problem Statement

    889 Words  | 2 Pages

    Teaching how to solve algebraic equations by using the properties of equations would be futile if the students do not possess the clear understanding of why they are performing those actions. Today, teachers are realizing that writing during a math lesson more than just a way to document information; it is a way to deepen students’ learning and a tool for helping students develop new perspectives. They are starting to realize that utilizing writing as a tool is a key to success in other disciplines, as well as in mathematics. According to a study conducted with 9th grade algebra class by Dr. David K. Pugalee (2004), it was found that using writing in mathematics classes might have a positive effect on problem solving skills because students are organize and describe their ideas so that this could help them develop problem solving skills in mathematics

    Read More

  • My Philosophy of Mathematics Teaching and Learning

    1307 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a secondary subject, society often views mathematics a critical subject for students to learn in order to be successful. Often times, mathematics serves as a gatekeeper for higher learning and certain specific careers. Since the times of Plato, “mathematics was virtually the first thing everyone has to learn…common to all arts, science, and forms of thought” (Stinson, 2004). Plato argued that all students should learn arithmetic; the advanced mathematics was reserved for those that would serve as the “philosopher guardians” of the city (Stinson, 2004). By the 1900s in the United States, mathematics found itself as a cornerstone of curriculum for students. National reports throughout the 20th Century solidified the importance of mathematics in the success of our nation and its students (Stinson, 2004). As a mathematics teacher, my role to educate all students in mathematics is an important one. My personal philosophy of mathematics education – including the optimal learning environment and best practices teaching strategies – motivates my teaching strategies in my personal classroom.

    Read More

  • Usefulness of Mathematics Education

    1347 Words  | 3 Pages

    There has been much discussion over the years about the usefulness of mathematical studies. Everyone seems to have a different viewpoint on the issue. Some believe that mathematics has little use in the working world and so is not a subject that should be taught at higher levels in secondary school. Others argue that mathematics does serve a profound purpose, albeit one that is subtle and not obvious in the vocational world. G. H. Hardy and Underwood Dudley, two great mathematicians of the twentieth century, have differing views, and our current Secretary of Education Richard Riley has his thoughts as well. So who is right? Who has a stronger argument? Here we will take a closer look at what is the main objective of all mathematics instruction.

    Read More

  • Mathematics In Mathematics

    1103 Words  | 3 Pages

    The study of mathematics is important in the education of a child. This is because mathematics is applied to everyday activities of an individual. Ezeh and Ugwuany (2013) cited Yusuf (2009) who reported that mathematics is not only considered important in its own right as a field of study and research, but also essential to every field of intellectual endeavor and human

    Read More

  • Importance Of Attitude Towards Mathematics

    962 Words  | 2 Pages

    The existing literature also depict that through the years, researches continue to focus on the importance of attitudes toward mathematics. The earliest was Mager (1968), who enumerated the sources of influence on subject matter tendencies which include the conditions that surround a subject, the consequences of coming into contact with a subject, and the way that others react toward a subject. This author considered that, indeed, teachers play an important role in cultivating attitude toward the

    Read More

  • Scheme of Work and Assessment

    1774 Words  | 4 Pages

    Johnston-Wilder, S. (2011) Learning to teach mathematics in the secondary school : a companion to school experience, 3rd ed. ed., London: Routledge.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Maths

    1020 Words  | 3 Pages

    Today math plays a major role in technology and sciences. Science and math were initially found together, and they are best adapted together now. Yes, We need a new way to teach math. This paper includes the drawbacks of present way of teaching math in various countries especially in America and suggest some modern and smart ways of teaching.

    Read More

More about Critique Of Action Research

Open Document