Clarissa's Identity

1504 Words4 Pages

Through two instances of the diamond image-- from Clarissa’s first reflective moment with Sally to the present moment, we can notice how Clarissa has shifted her identity from being a purely individual one to a more socially constructed one. After her youngster years when Clarissa spent more time in the domestic space and was not as affected by the outer world, she is supposed to enter the “symbolic order” which, according to Lacan, is the world of social interaction where a person further develops an autonomous identity through language, knowledge of ideological conventions, and acceptance of laws and dictates. However, as Clarissa enters the social order, she appears to be dissuaded to further develop a wholly autonomous sense of self. The …show more content…

Indeed, Victorian women are molded into the socially calibrated model of The Looking-glass self, a structural theory in which Cooley proposes that people shape their identity largely based on their understanding of how other perceive them, and the social environment thus serves as the “mirror” that reflects desirable images of themselves. According to Cooley, the stages of The Looking-glass self involves imagining how one looks to others, imagining how other are judging her, and finally developing herself through such possible judgement. A hypothesis can be formed here, that Victorian women must develop this looking-glass self by concealing socially or individually unacceptable impulses from their consciousness. In the case of Clarissa, she represses her rather primitive sexual feelings toward Sally for fear of social judgement, and must construct an identity reflective of the feminine qualities desired by the society. But Clarissa’s looking-glass self is quite problematic, because it is only a manifestation of her attempt to repress real emotions. All forms of repression, according to Freud, cause disease within the mind and body— they will gradually boil inside the beings and finally explode. Interestingly, Clarissa never “explodes” her repressed feelings …show more content…

Clarissa sees herself grow old and tends to lock her feelings inside the privately nurtured rooms of her mind, just as the lady who rattles alone around the rooms of her house. This solitary woman is both Clarissa's double, a reflection glimpsed in a figurative mirror that implies Clarissa's potential future, and a separate individual whose life beyond the frame of the mirroring window Clarissa does not have access to. As Clarissa sees her neighbor walking upstairs, she realizes beauty in this act of preserving one’s interior independence. “Let her climb upstairs if she wanted to,” Clarissa says, praising the woman’s autonomous and deliberate movements while being “quite unconscious that she was being watched.” By catching the woman who believes that she is unobserved, Clarissa witnesses the woman's true self, unaffected by any social frameworks that mold people into desired human subjects. The elderly woman's poignant representation of individuality coupled with a sense of serenity and isolation is something that Clarissa herself does not have in the moment. Furthermore, Clarissa also laments the power of love, religion, or any other socially shared conventions to crush one's critical thinking and try to convert people into believing a certain set of truths, thus

Open Document