Argumentative Essay: The Use Of Tracking Devices In Schools

911 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Student record tracking systems research proposal

To track or not to track, that is the question. Tracking devices in student IDs has been a topic of discussion all across the US. Some schools have implemented the tracking devices in the student IDs just this past year. Whether people agree or disagree with having the tracking devices, the subject has gone to a judge. The use of tracking devices has a wide range of views on it, from people completely against them for every possible reason, to people that want them for safety and security. Some argue that it is an invasion of privacy, or it goes against their religious beliefs. Others argue that it will help keep students safe, and they can be used in an emergency.
Tracking devices should be used in student IDs in schools.
The safety of students in the main argument for the people wanting the tracking devices. “School personnel can …show more content…

Then having the student coming in without a pass saying they were in the office at the time. With the tracking devices, a teacher could locate the students before they show up late to prove they were actually where they said they were. “...locating kids who are not in their chairs to answer 'present,' but are in the building - in the counselor's office, in the cafeteria, in the hallway, in the gym - if we can show they were, in fact, in school, then we can count them present.” (Garcia). When a student comes into class late, you have to wonder if they are telling the truth about where they are. During homeroom, when a student says they are going to a teacher’s room, the homeroom teacher could in fact verify that the student went to the room they said they were going to. This would also help out the teachers that forget to email another teacher that they have a student in their room. Having the tracking devices in the student’s IDs would greatly help the teachers in times when there is a lot going on. With every argument, there is another

Show More
Related

  • Limiting Students Online Speech

    865 Words  | 2 Pages

    Grabber- We are all privileged to live in a free nation, where we can do what we desire. But, what if one day you were told that your school can monitor your every action on the interweb and can punish you for your online activities on and off campus? Well, certainly many students would protest without hesitating, for that they would no longer have privacy.

    Read More

  • Search And Seizure In Schools Essay

    1500 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ideally schools in the United States are considered by both parents and students alike to be “safe-havens” where parents can trust their children to learn and remain safe during the day and where students can feel safe in a well-maintained learning environment. However within this fully regulated government service, there are often debates over proper classroom environments, teaching tactics, and privacy issues. Today the main privacy issue in public schools is where to draw the line between keeping the school safe and maintaining the privacy of the students (Boomer par. 19). Searches and seizures in schools are not recent issues; however they are becoming more public now than in recent years.

    Read More

  • Parents using hi-tech to track kids

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    To begin with no technology is 100% secure, if the kids’ location can be visible to hackers, this information can be used to harm them. In the Article, Irvine mentions “Parents are notified by text message, e-mail, or phone” about their kids activities at school. This information is also risk as emails can be hacked, Imagine it can be used to kidnap kids of a rich or high official for ransom. Privacy is a serious matter, and hackers can also use technology to commit crimes against such families. Irvine says, “High-tech methods to track everything” are available, that's means that there is always someone watching. Irvine says, “Big Mother” or “Big Father” who is watching, but it can also be “Big Kidnapper” or “Big Sex Offender.” In other words, their kids will be under surveillance of many unknowns. Also anybody might forget their phone in public places and what if some crazy person got it? That person can use this information and see all the communication and find out where the kids are going. As a result, these devices can be tools for hackers to use to harm the kids...

    Read More

  • In the School System, Student's Safety vs. Student's Privacy

    1144 Words  | 3 Pages

    In today's school system, there have been uproars about the student's privacy and safety at the schoolhouse. Some parents feel that their child's safety is more important because of the rules that the school has set forth to maintain a safe environment. Others feel that their child's privacy should be taken seriously because they should be treated more like an adult. In recent news, there has been concerns about the student's safety that cause some to get injured or killed; while, student's privacy has cause the police to get involved. The school system should be concerned as well as, aware about the student’s privacy and safety at their prospective school.

    Read More

  • School Security: Safe but Subtle

    2072 Words  | 5 Pages

    In light of recent acts of violence in the nation’s schools, school safety and security have become a hot topic. However, the issue of school safety goes beyond student violence. It includes property damage, theft, and anything else that concerns the overall well being of schools. While it is important to create a safe environment in schools it is also necessary to make sure students feel comfortable in this atmosphere. The security can not be so overbearing that it becomes a negative tactic that gets in the way of the students main objective, learning. Barely noticeable cameras, ID cards, and security guards without uniforms can help generate this safe, but comfortable learning environment. On the other hand metal detectors and mini police forces may be a little too reminiscent of George Orwell’s novel, 1984, or even modern prisons. School security should not be overbearing or obtrusive where it gets in the way of a comfortable environment that is conducive to learning in the nation’s schools.

    Read More

  • Cracking Down On Skipping Class By Douglas Belkin Summary

    990 Words  | 2 Pages

    If a student decides to skip class knowing that they are being tracked and knowing that the school will inform their parents of their location, it is embarrassing. College students get caught up in the new found freedom they never had and make poor decisions like skipping class. College is the place to make and learn from mistakes without having anyone telling you what to do and how to fix it. Using high-tech trackers defeats the purpose of learning from mistakes and removes the choice students can make towards a certain class. For example, if a student needs a mental health day and decides not to attend class, their parents would immediately know and will most likely argue and lecture the student.

    Read More

  • Cell Phones in the Public

    824 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this article, Kieffer describes the concept of the whole "Bring Your Own Technoogy" initiative that schools are leaning towards in our society today. Basically, as schools are adding more technology, they are considering allowing students to bring their own devices to save money. Later on in the article, Kieffer pulls examples from schools in the northeast Mississippi area that have already banned students from using cell phones on campus. This article suits my topic well because it provides a good proposal for why schools should allow personal devices on campus.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Locker Searches

    972 Words  | 2 Pages

    It’s important not to overlook the fact that young people’s privacy is equally as important as anyone else’s. The fact that they’re young students increases the need for student privacy, as our minds can be more vulnerable and fragile. Privacy can ensure feelings of safety and comfort. The first and one of the most important reasons locker searches shouldn’t be conducted is because of how it affects student trust. When students are informed their lockers can be searched at any time, it may give them the impression that they’re not trusted and are doing something wrong, even if that student is completely innocent.

    Read More

  • 4th Amendment

    654 Words  | 2 Pages

    To start off, when the schools that use technology in their classrooms they gather data on the students’ academic progress this may include students’ tests scores, over-all grade and the students’ attendance records and when share it with other school districts it may violate the students’ 4th amendment rights. The 4th amendment was made to protect or to enforce the people right to privacy, by giving the people (in this case the students) the right to be safe in their person, home, papers and

    Read More

  • Arguments Against Student Searches

    438 Words  | 1 Pages

    Having student searches is against the fourth amendment. What makes it even more irritating is that it’s legal. According to the law made in 1980, it takes away your fourth amendment in school if there is probable cause. Trust is also a big thing, if teachers trust their students, they can make it more free and interesting. When students trust their teachers they are more dedicated to learning. But when student searches are present students can’t trust faculty anymore. Additionally, people for student searches believe that it reduces illegal substances brought to school. People against student searches think it breaks trust. Student searches aren’t necessary to promote student safety.

    Read More

  • Anderson On Surveillance In Schools

    829 Words  | 2 Pages

    Opposition to surveillance in schools is characterized by accusations that surveillance methods infringe student rights. While very few oppose increasing security in schools, especially in the wake of seemingly constant school tragedies, many argue that the application of security measures is unfair and misdirected at mundane issues, resulting in the amplification of prejudices and the creation of an oppressive school ecosystem that places school administrators on an authoritative pedestal with the ability to abuse power. This leaves stakeholders searching for the right balance between security and freedom, and trying to find out where technology meant to be focused on protecting students goes wrong. Melinda Anderson’s report for The Atlantic

    Read More

  • 1984 Argumentative Essay

    1237 Words  | 3 Pages

    Northern Arizona University set up these electronic scanners outside of classrooms so that they can monitor who actually shows up to class. They have to scan their ID and when the light turns green they are marked present. It bothers a lot of people because they feel like college is a time where they finally get to make decisions on their own. The students feel like it is very unnecessary because it shouldn't matter who shows up to class, it matters that you take part in the class discussion and actually learn. “ Rather than focusing on, ‘Did they scan their car?’- the more important thing to think about is what they are doing in the classroom” (University Attendance Scanners Make Some Uneasy). Paying for classes will not stop kids from skipping. A lot of people drop out of college before they even get a chance to finish it. “About 3 in every 10 students drop out after the first year” (University Attendance Scanners Make Some Uneasy). If putting this system in front of every class motivates people to show up to class and do their work then they hope that the dropout percentages will decrease. “ THe stronger a student’s grade performance in the first year, the far more likely they are to persist at NAU and graduate” University Attendance Scanners Make Some Uneasy). Even though that electronical scanner seems tedious, it will help more people in the long

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Privacy In Schools

    1034 Words  | 3 Pages

    From this perspective, if schools give teens more privacy the student’s will be able to learn more on their own. An article called “School District 's Webcam Surveillance Focus of Suit” by Martha Moore a USA Today publisher on school issues, analyzes how a high school girl was hanging out with her friends and noticed a glowing green light on her computer, which means that the webcam is on either taking pictures or a video. The School District has admitted theft-tracking software which means it takes pictures of the people to know where the computer is at and who has it (Moore 1).This is something that schools shouldn 't be doing no student should be getting pictures of them taken without them knowing. This is going on in and out of the school which takes privacy away from the student in school and out of school and won 't make the students feel right using the laptops to do the work. Students and parents signed a policy acknowledging the school could monitor the laptop 's ' contents and Internet usage. “The policy doesn 't mention the school 's ability to use the webcams, theft-tracking devices that were supposed to be turned on if laptops were reported missing or stolen “(Moore 1). The high school was not even following their own rules and invaded the students’ privacy. This helps to show that teens do need more privacy because schools

    Read More

  • Technology As A Tool For Education

    1211 Words  | 3 Pages

    Technologies like computers or iPads (or anything with internet access for that matter) in the classroom could possibly distract students from their work. Classroom administrators seem to forget that the majority of students really don’t want to be in the classroom.. I remember when I was in highschool, whenever a teacher would bring students into a computer lab, or bring class sets of computers, or bring iPads into the classroom for a lesson a large portion would go onto twitter, or onto any unblocked flash game website whenever the teacher was not looking, try to access anything for them to “escape” the classroom. When there are a large majority of children and/or teens that do not want to go to school, and are given tools to be rebellious so easily, what is going to stop them? Aside, who really wants to sit through the same autonomous paper typing over and over again...

    Read More

  • The Benefits of Allowing Cell Phones in the Classroom

    954 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ever since incidents such as 9/11 and Columbine, high schools have started implementing new rules regarding cellphones. Cellphones regard the attention of building managers, teachers, parents, and students. Although teachers see them as a distraction and a way to cheat, they can be quite helpful to students. School districts should permit students to use cellular devices in school for purposes of improving their education and providing themselves a sense of security.

    Read More

More about Argumentative Essay: The Use Of Tracking Devices In Schools

Open Document