Analysis Of 'Firsting And Lasting By Jean O' Brien

Local histories written in the nineteenth century are often neglected today. Yet from these accounts, one can see a pattern develop: the myth of Indian extinction, the superiority of White colonists and also to understand how American attitudes and values evolved. The myths were put forth for a reason according to Jean O’Brien. O’Brien explains how the process came to fruition in Firsting and Lasting: Writing Indians Out of Existence in New England. In the majority of local town histories, Indians are mentioned in passing, as a past that will never return. Indians were ancient, whereas English colonists brought modernity to New England. Jean O’Brien argues that local histories were the primary means by which white European Americans asserted

O’Brien argues the multiple Indians who are put forth in histories as being the last of their tribe: Eunice Mahwee of the Pequots, Esther of the Royal Narragansetts. This phenomenon falsely narrates the disappearance of Indian people, being relegated to anonymity except for the “last of their kind.” These stories also discuss the purity of Indians, downplaying their current environment. Indians were only Indians if they had complete pure blood, one drop of anything other than their own tribe meant they were not Indians. The racist contradictions in this logic is pointed out by O’Brien. For whites, any claim to one “drop” of New England Puritan blood meant this person could claim to be a descendant of the Puritan Fathers. The children or grandchildren of the “last” Indians were not truly Indian because they did not grow up in a wigwam, or possess their native

Local histories insisted on Indians no longer existing, or having moved to another area. Yet, these histories included enclaves of Indian settlements. Throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, Indians continue to live in New England, and defend their homeland and their identity. William Apess, a Pequot Indian who was also a Methodist minister was able to write on the persistence of Indians. Whites were not explicitly acknowledging it, but Indians were continuing their history. O’Brien concludes by explaining the struggle for official recognition for Indian nations in Southern New England. The records needed to apply and get approval for official government recognition is the culmination of the process that started with “firsting.” The documents were meant to bureaucratically make Indians disappear. The fight still continues for Indians, but they will continue to seek recognition. The trend continued past the eighteenth and nineteenth