America Is A Dishonest

1129 Words3 Pages

Thematic Essay - Lilly Johnsen
In the book, The One by Kiera Cass, America is already far into a competition to become the princess of Illea, and become Prince Maxon’s wife. Although America originally did not want to be a part, in The One which is the third book of the series, she realizes that she actually wants to win. But with Aspen (the person she was going to marry) at the palace as a guard, she has to decide which life she wants. The complex theme present in this text is, Because unhonest relationships result in suspension and pain, the honest and trusting relationships are stronger and more long lasting. If being dishonest about something means that you are keeping secrets and lying, then America is dishonest because she lies about …show more content…

The first scene I noticed was on page 44 when Georgia and August meet America and Maxon. They start off their relationship with each other by being honest, and telling each other their intentions. Because of this, they quickly become close and understanding of each other. I also noticed a scene on pg 26/27 where Maxon asks America a question and they both acknowledge that for their relationship to work, they both need to work on honesty. That was a hint that was not quite as subtle as the others, because both of the characters openly acknowledge this. From these scenes I saw the theme that relationships built of of honesty and trust create the most strong and long lasting relationships. I can see this because of the relationship that start rapidly building between Georgia, August, Maxon, and America. And you can see that this happens because of the openness that they have with each other. Then, you can see Maxon and America acknowledging that the issue with their relationship is trust, and they work to improve that to make their relationship strong and more long …show more content…

The end of the book shows the consequences of the lies that the characters are keeping. One scene I noticed was when Lucy, May, and Kenna find out that America was lying to them about Aspen. They all are shocked, and May and Lucy start crying, showing how this can affect everyone, and not just the person who creates the lie. Also, throughout the text they portray May as a “perfect” character and how she is just good. They also mention how honest and loyal she is during this scene which makes me think that the author is trying to show how valuable of a trait that is in a person. Also, I saw how letting down your family and friends with lies make them change the way they view you, no matter how sorry you are for your actions. I also saw the theme when Maxon confronts America about her lies. He yells at America, because he put all his trust in her, enough to marry her, just to find out that she was lying to him for all of their relationship. The quote that stuck out to me during this scene is when he says, “You were supposed to be honest with me.” This is huge because although this was put inside a paragraph of other dialogue, it really reflects the theme that can be noticed throughout the entire text. I also noticed this quote, “Do you honestly think I’d marry you, make you my princess, when you’ve been lying to me for most of our relationship? I refused to torture myself for the rest of my life.” I think the

Open Document