The Epic Of The Iliad Essay

The Epic Of The Iliad Essay

Length: 1476 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Iliad, one of Homer’s Epics, was written about a ten year war between the city of Troy and the Greek city-states. This great poem, still somewhat prevalent today in modern society, is the tale of the Trojan War. Recently the epic was recreated into a two hour film loaded with historical inaccuracies, although in some instances, does follow the Iliad fairly well. Some of the mistakes made by Hollywood are minor details, such as when the Trojans brought the gigantic wooden horse into the city of Troy. In the Iliad, gates had to be dismantled, which wasn’t shown in the movie, instead the horse was simply brought into the city. None the less, inaccuracies greatly outweighed any real historical relevance in the Iliad. Examples are the actual length of the war. In history, it lasted ten years, in the motion picture, a mere 17 days. Another example is that in the Epic, Achilles was actually dead before the Trojan Horse infiltrated the city. In the movie Troy and the Iliad, there are many instances where reality and Hollywood clash, such as the character backgrounds, geography and the actual war.
A large part of the historical Trojan War rested with the geographical layout of the city of Troy. In the movie, surrounding Troy are walls, forty to fifty feet tall. In the film, Priam, King of Troy, while talking to Hector mentions the walls. Priam says that enemies have been attacking the city of Troy for centuries and that the walls that encompass the city still stand. Although the walls may seem daunting and unreachable, they didn’t actually exist. Instead, the lower city was protected by a trench. This factor drastically makes these two different stories even more abstract from one another. Putting an enormous wall into the scenery o...


... middle of paper ...


...diers mainly fought with spears, not swords, yet again, another aspect that is changed to make the movie look more daunting. When Achilles and Hector died, coins were placed on top of the eyes of the men, even though coins hadn’t been invented yet.
All of these factors add up to a very imprecise and carelessly made movie. Though some of the same values in the Iliad and the movie Troy are still intact, these two pieces of work vary greatly in almost all details. Whether its small things such as the age of ships and armor, or a character like Ajax being killed by Hector, when Ajax really committed suicide, or larger details like how Achilles wasn’t even alive when the Greeks infiltrated Troy or the length of the war. Therefore, the movie Troy and the Epic Iliad face many differences in historical accuracy such as character backgrounds, geography and the actual war.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Epic Of Gilgamesh, And The Iliad Essay

- In Genesis, The Epic of Gilgamesh, and the Iliad, the relationship between the gods, nature, and humanity is highly complicated, with the gods typically ranked as the most powerful, although the power balance between nature and human beings depends on the source of the literature. That being said, in all of the writings, the gods have a tendency of coming to nature’s defense when humans disrespect it, thus implying a more fluid distribution of power in the hierarchy. The Bible famously opens with “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth”, which encompasses essentially all aspects of non-living nature....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh, Iliad, Achilles, Ishtar]

Strong Essays
910 words (2.6 pages)

The Epic Of Gilgamesh And Iliad Essay

- Traveling the world allows one to open their mind to the wide array of cultures. It allows one to change their views on others, but more importantly, it allows one to grow and become a better person. The Babylonian Epic of Gilgamesh and the Greek poet Homer’s Iliad express how one important part of a hero’s journey is the transformation that the hero’s character goes through over the course of their story. In the Epic of Gilgamesh and Iliad, the characters Gilgamesh and Achilles demonstrate that family is very important throughout one’s lifetime....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh, Iliad, Trojan War, Achilles]

Strong Essays
1694 words (4.8 pages)

The Epic Of Gilgamesh And Homer Iliad Essay

- “Mother-Son Bond” The Epic of Gilgamesh and Homer Iliad are intriguing stories that reveals about mother and the heroic sons relationships which consists: support, guidance, and a strong bond. Achilles from the Homer Iliad reveals his feelings of sorrow to his mother: “He raised his hands in prayer to his immortal mother, “Mother”, he cried, “you bore me doomed to live but for a little season; surely Jove, who thunders from Olympus, might have made that little glorious. It is not so. Agamemnon, son of Atreus, has done me dishonour, and has robbed me of my prize by force” (Iliad 1:31)....   [tags: Epic of Gilgamesh, Iliad, Homer, Trojan War]

Strong Essays
1315 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Warfare Within The Epic Of The Iliad By Homer

- The Iliad by Homer has much to say about war as it is fought today. It tells the story that war is both the bringer of glory to its young fighters and the destroyer of their lives. It tells the story of fighters obliged to serve under incompetent superiors. It tells the story of war as an attempt to preserve a treasured way of life. It tells the story, too, of the incalculable gulf between civilian life and the front lines; of atrocities and frivolous slaughter; of war’s mercilessness to women and children; of friendships and empathy across the battle lines....   [tags: Homer, Iliad, Trojan War, Epic poetry]

Strong Essays
714 words (2 pages)

Essay about The Epic Of The Iliad

- Early Greek society had an interesting view on woman unlike anything else in history short of modern times. Ancient Greek city states like Sparta and Athens were early feminists. How this is true is Sparta considered women almost an equal. Also many prominent Athenian philosophers like Socrates believed women should be equal also should their essence in life deem it necessary. However early Greek societies still coveted women like material objects, the Nobile always desired female slaves and women of beauty as their companions....   [tags: Iliad, Trojan War, Greek mythology, Eris]

Strong Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on The Epic Of The Iliad

- The Homerian epic, The Iliad, portrays many characters exploring the varied stages of grief when facing death. Achilles grieving for Patroclus and Priam for Hector. You could present anticipatory grief in Andromache, due to her expectation of Hector’s demise. Too many focus on the grief of the living. Is the grief of those experiencing death less valid. Brave and valiant Hector, the man killer, is acutely aware of his abbreviated amount of time to reconcile himself with death. He is in a war with depression as he confronts shame; grapples with denial and bargaining when he schemes of a way out; and finally accepts the inevitability of his demise....   [tags: Iliad, Trojan War, Achilles, Greek mythology]

Strong Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

Essay about The Epic Of The Iliad

- The Iliad sets the tone of this epic story by beginning with fighting that magnifies throughout the entire text. King Agamemnon has kidnapped Chryses’ daughter and refuses to give her back even after Chryses has begged him. Agamemnon, rudely, responds to his request calling him “old sir,” telling Chryses if he does not leave, he will make his daughter work until she is old and tired. After hearing this, Chryses leaves afraid for his and his daughter’s life. Chryses prays to the god Apollo that he would punish the Achaians for the pain they have caused him....   [tags: Iliad, Greek mythology, Achilles, Trojan War]

Strong Essays
793 words (2.3 pages)

The Epic Of The Iliad Essay

- The Iliad, one of Homer’s Epics, was written about a ten year war between the city of Troy and the Greek city-states. This great poem, still somewhat prevalent today in modern society, is the tale of the Trojan War. Recently the epic was recreated into a two hour film loaded with historical inaccuracies, although in some instances, does follow the Iliad fairly well. Some of the mistakes made by Hollywood are minor details, such as when the Trojans brought the gigantic wooden horse into the city of Troy....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Achilles, Odyssey]

Strong Essays
1476 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on The Epic Of The Iliad

- “To work with the hands or brain, according to our requirements and our capacities to do that which lies before us to do, is more honorable than rank and title” Albert Pike. Wars throughout the ages have changed drastically between their weapons, the reasoning, and the strategies used. But it seems there is a constant from cavemen to present day; the higher the rank and position of power that one is in, generally keeps them from having to do their own dirty work. Throughout The Iliad, the only person that does not seem to pull the “rank” card is Hector, Homer put Hector into The Iliad as a contrast to men such as Zeus and Agamemnon....   [tags: Trojan War, Iliad, Achilles, Greek mythology]

Strong Essays
1054 words (3 pages)

Homer's Iliad is an Anthropocentric Epic Essay

-       "So the immortals spun our lives that we, wretched men / live on to bear such torments...." (The Iliad bk.24, ln.613-614)      This pessimistic explanation of the human condition was a tradition observed and preserved by the ancient Greeks through the composition of Homer's Iliad. This one statement, made by the godlike Achilles to King Priam in the last chapter of the work, provides the reader a contextual summary of what the Greeks believed was their role in the cosmos. Homer's Iliad, among many other themes contained in the poem, “is an anthropocentric epic exposing the ancient Greek's views about man and his relationships”(Clarke 129)....   [tags: Iliad essays]

Strong Essays
1545 words (4.4 pages)